Close X
Tuesday, November 5, 2024
ADVT 
National

Census Definition Of Secondary Residence Appears Clearer Than Senate Rules

The Canadian Press, 04 Jul, 2015 11:50 AM
    OTTAWA — Call it the Mike Duffy question.
     
    When Canadians receive their census questionnaire next year, they'll be asked to fill out the address of their "secondary residence," if they happen to have one and are at that location on census day.
     
    "A secondary residence" could be, "for example, a cottage," the form reads.
     
    It's the same question that Statistics Canada asks every five years: Tell us where you live and whether this is your usual place of residence. Statcan says the questions were the same in 2011.
     
    All of which means the agency has a better idea of what constitutes a secondary residence than the Senate does — a question central to the ongoing controversy over housing expenses and the upper chamber.
     
    The census question is meant to ensure that respondents aren't counted more than once. Such a mistake, multiplied millions of times over, could throw off population counts that governments and private businesses use when designing programs or planning projects.
     
    It's up to the person filling out the form to determine their "usual place of residence," said spokeswoman Nadine Lacroix. She said Statistics Canada doesn't capture data on the number of people on census day who are "temporarily staying at a secondary residence."
     
    This particular question was tested between June 2013, just after the scandal over Duffy's housing claims were referred to the RCMP, and May 2014, after the RCMP confirmed Nigel Wright, Prime Minister Stephen Harper's former chief of staff, wouldn't face criminal charges for giving Duffy money to cover the repayment of the senator's questionable housing claims.
     
    The testing didn't turn up any problems that required rewording of the residence question so people could understand it better, Statistics Canada says.
     
    That may be cold comfort to the eight senators who are in trouble over their housing claims, including Duffy, Patrick Brazeau and Mac Harb, as well as five others who were referred to the RCMP after last month's Senate spending audit.
     
    In each case, senators have been accused of not spending enough time at their primary residence, which would make them ineligible for an annual housing allowance.
     
    What exactly constitutes a primary and secondary residence has become a key component of Duffy's criminal trial, where he has pleaded not guilty to all 31 charges related to his Senate spending.
     
    Court has heard that Duffy started renovating his Prince Edward Island cottage after being appointed a senator from P.E.I.; the work was focused on making the structure a year-round home.
     
    One witness who did work on the building, Clifford Dollar, testified that the Cavendish, P.E.I., cottage didn't have running water in the winter and was sometimes so snowed in that Duffy wasn't able to walk to the front door.
     
    The Crown alleges Duffy lived primarily at a home in an Ottawa suburb that he had owned for years, but identified Cavendish as his primary residence in order to claim about $90,000 in housing and meal expenses through the Senate.
     
    Duffy's defence lawyer has said Duffy followed the Senate's rules when he filed the claims, and has attacked the rules themselves as problematic and vague.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Judge Tosses Band's Bid To Block Sale Of B.C. Rail Corridor To Local Governments

    Judge Tosses Band's Bid To Block Sale Of B.C. Rail Corridor To Local Governments
    KELOWNA, B.C. — A B.C. Supreme Court judge has dismissed a bid by the Okanagan Indian Band to block the sale of a rail corridor.

    Judge Tosses Band's Bid To Block Sale Of B.C. Rail Corridor To Local Governments

    Names Released Of 2 Whistler Cyclists, 1 Passenger Killed In Weekend Sea-To-Sky Highway Crash

    Names Released Of 2 Whistler Cyclists, 1 Passenger Killed In Weekend Sea-To-Sky Highway Crash
    Fifty-three-year-old Kelly Blunden and 50-year-old Ross Chafe were riding with a group along the Sea-to-Sky Highway when they were hit around noon on Sunday.

    Names Released Of 2 Whistler Cyclists, 1 Passenger Killed In Weekend Sea-To-Sky Highway Crash

    First Nation Chiefs Wants Investigation Into Aboriginal Teen's Death In Vancouver Downtown Eastside

    First Nation Chiefs Wants Investigation Into Aboriginal Teen's Death In Vancouver Downtown Eastside
    VANCOUVER — The Union of B.C. Indian Chiefs is demanding police investigate the government agencies whose alleged inaction led to the overdose death of an aboriginal teenager in Vancouver's Downtown Eastside.

    First Nation Chiefs Wants Investigation Into Aboriginal Teen's Death In Vancouver Downtown Eastside

    RCMP Toxic To Women, Says Lawyer As Hearing Begins For Potential Class-Action

    RCMP Toxic To Women, Says Lawyer As Hearing Begins For Potential Class-Action
    VANCOUVER — A lawyer arguing for a class-action proceeding involving the RCMP says the force is toxic to women and has been for a number of years.

    RCMP Toxic To Women, Says Lawyer As Hearing Begins For Potential Class-Action

    Bobbi O'Shea Lawsuit Alleges Vancouver Police Tethered Her To A Door

    Bobbi O'Shea Lawsuit Alleges Vancouver Police Tethered Her To A Door
    VANCOUVER — As Vancouver Police jail guards allegedly bound her feet with a strap and yanked it hard under a cell door, Bobbi O'Shea remembers feeling betrayed.

    Bobbi O'Shea Lawsuit Alleges Vancouver Police Tethered Her To A Door

    Veterans, Government Agree To Put Benefits Lawsuit On Hold Until After Election

    VANCOUVER — A long-running lawsuit launched by veterans against the federal government is off the docket until after the federal election, if not for good.

    Veterans, Government Agree To Put Benefits Lawsuit On Hold Until After Election