Close X
Monday, November 25, 2024
ADVT 
National

Canadian Kids Must Go Back To Germany Where Father Lives, Court Rules

The Canadian Press, 14 Sep, 2016 10:43 AM
  • Canadian Kids Must Go Back To Germany Where Father Lives, Court Rules
TORONTO — Two Canadian children at the centre of a protracted custody dispute must return to Germany where their father lives over their objections and against the wishes of their mother, Ontario's top court ruled Tuesday.
 
In addition, the court ruled, the father will have to provide suitable housing for the mother and children in the European country.
 
"Although this case involves the interests and needs of these two young children, it raises legal issues that transcend their interests and that affect the interests of countless other children and their parents," the Appeal Court ruled.
 
The appeal involving John Balev and his wife Catharine-Rose Baggott turned on interpretation of rules on international child abductions known as the Hague Convention.
 
The couple, Canadian citizens who married in Toronto in 2000, moved to Germany the following year. The children, born in Germany in 2002 and 2005 and mostly raised there, are sole Canadian citizens.
 
Balev and Baggott separated in 2011 and the father was given interim custody, according to the Court of Appeal. In April 2013, however, they agreed Baggott would take the children to Canada to attend school, and Balev signed a letter transferring custody temporarily to her. The mother and children left most of their belongings in Germany when they came to Canada.
 
A year later, Balev began trying to get the children back. The mother refused.
 
After legal wrangling and delays in both Canada and Germany, the case proceeded in Ontario.
 
Initially, a Superior Court justice in St. Catharines, Ont., ruled the children's habitual residence was in Germany — a fact that did not change during the time they spent in Canada — and ordered their return.
 
On appeal, however, Divisional Court reversed that decision after finding their usual home had changed before their mother refused to allow them to go back to Germany and the Hague Convention did not apply.
 
"I have considerable sympathy for the mother, who obviously feels strongly that it is in her children's best interests to remain in Canada," Justice Robert Sharpe wrote for the Appeal Court. "I also recognize that the children have now been in Ontario for more than three years, and that moving them back to Germany is likely to be difficult."
 
 
Nevertheless, the Court of Appeal ruled the children must return to Germany.
 
In coming to its decision, the Appeal Court found the German-born children were normally residents in Germany and the mother had violated the Hague Convention by moving them.
 
The court also agreed the parents intended the Canadian visit to be temporary — and the children believed it would be — and Baggott breached Balev's custody rights by keeping them in Ontario against his wishes.
 
"The Divisional Court's decision would, if upheld, undermine the purpose and proper operation of the Hague Convention," the Appeal Court decided.
 
The court also found the children's objections to returning to Germany to be insubstantial. They had complained about too much homework there and losing friends in Ontario.
 
In an interview late Tuesday, Baggott said the Appeal Court ignored several salient facts and said she would appeal.
 
"I have to take this to the Supreme Court because the Hague Convention has become a means of legislated kidnapping," Baggot said.

MORE National ARTICLES

Helicopter Crash Survivor In Surprising Good Shape After Sunday's Crash That Killed Two

Helicopter Crash Survivor In Surprising Good Shape After Sunday's Crash That Killed Two
Michel Laplante, his face bloody and scarred, spoke to the media on Thursday about what it was like to survive the recent helicopter crash that killed Quebec singer Roberto Bissonnette and the chopper's pilot, Frederick Decoste.  

Helicopter Crash Survivor In Surprising Good Shape After Sunday's Crash That Killed Two

Judge Who Made 'Knees Together' Remark At Rape Trial To Address His Hearing

Judge Who Made 'Knees Together' Remark At Rape Trial To Address His Hearing
CALGARY — A judge who asked a sexual assault complainant why she couldn't keep her knees together will take the witness stand today at a hearing to determine his future. 

Judge Who Made 'Knees Together' Remark At Rape Trial To Address His Hearing

Marijuana Producers Getting High On Expansion In Anticipation Of Rising Demand

Marijuana Producers Getting High On Expansion In Anticipation Of Rising Demand
TORONTO — Canadian cannabis producers say they are ramping up their operations to keep up with growing demand for medical marijuana and in anticipation of legislation that would allow for recreational use of the drug.

Marijuana Producers Getting High On Expansion In Anticipation Of Rising Demand

Mother Says Son 'High' Hours Before Senior Killed In Saskatoon Crash

Mother Says Son 'High' Hours Before Senior Killed In Saskatoon Crash
The mother of a 17-year-old boy who was allegedly involved in a fatal Saskatoon collision says that just hours before the crash she begged a judge to keep her drug-addicted son behind bars to dry out.

Mother Says Son 'High' Hours Before Senior Killed In Saskatoon Crash

Anti-Terror Revamp To Stretch Into Next Year As Liberals Launch Consultation

Anti-Terror Revamp To Stretch Into Next Year As Liberals Launch Consultation
OTTAWA — The Liberal government's promised changes to a controversial anti-terrorism law likely won't come until next year, once officials have digested an array of public suggestions on revamping national security. 

Anti-Terror Revamp To Stretch Into Next Year As Liberals Launch Consultation

Muslim Parents Pull Children Out Of Toronto School's 'Un-islamic' Mandatory Music Class

Muslim Parents Pull Children Out Of Toronto School's 'Un-islamic' Mandatory Music Class
Mohammad Nouman Dasu has been engaged in a three-year fight with the Toronto District School Board over his decision to take his children home for an hour during music class

Muslim Parents Pull Children Out Of Toronto School's 'Un-islamic' Mandatory Music Class