Close X
Sunday, January 12, 2025
ADVT 
National

Canadian Court Finds Designation Of Egyptian Man As Security Threat Unreasonable

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 24 May, 2016 12:31 PM
    TORONTO — The Canadian government's designation of an Egyptian man as a threat to national security is unreasonable, a federal court judge has ruled.
     
    The decision in favour of Mahmoud Jaballah, a father of three, could see the end of an ordeal that first saw Canada brand him as a terrorist more than 16 years ago.
     
    "I conclude that the security certificate filed by the minister is not reasonable and will be set aside," Federal Court Judge Dolores Hansen said in her decision.
     
    "Classified reasons will also be issued and will include the information that cannot be disclosed for reasons of national security."
     
    The public reasons for Hansen's decision were not immediately available Tuesday.
     
    The government has long insisted that Mahjoub, now 54, was a ranking member of the Vanguards of Conquest, an Egyptian group linked to al-Qaida. Mahjoub also worked on an agricultural project in Sudan run by former al-Qaida leader Osama bin Laden in the early 1990s.
     
    His lawyers argued the government had failed to produce independent evidence that Mahjoub ever committed, or would commit, terrorist acts. They also said Canada's spy agency had made no attempts to investigate or verify information about him it was given by foreign intelligence services.
     
    A beaming Jaballah, of Toronto, who came to Canada in 1995 and was initially granted refugee status, was not immediately able to comment on Hansen's ruling due to court-imposed conditions, but his lawyer, Marlys Edwardh, told The Canadian Press it had been a long and difficult ordeal.
     
    "He has spent earlier on years in a maximum-security setting, part of it in solitary confinement...merely because of the allegations," Edwardh said.
     
    Jaballah was originally arrested in Canada in 1999 under a highly criticized national security certificate based largely on secret evidence he was not allowed to see. That certificate was quickly deemed unreasonable, but the government issued a second one in 2001, which was upheld in 2003 after the government argued it had new secret evidence against him.
     
    In 2007, the Supreme Court of Canada ruled the national certificate process to be unfair because of the secrecy, and quashed the certificates but gave the government a year to rewrite the rules. As a result, Ottawa appointed special advocates — lawyers with top-level security clearance able to review the government's secret evidence.
     
    In 2008, the government issued the third certificate against Jaballah — the one Hansen has now found unreasonable.
     
    "It is a long, deeply challenging road to have walked," Edwardh said.
     
    In previous years, the Canadian Security Intelligence Service admitted listening in on calls between Mahjoub and his lawyers, and, in 2011, government lawyers mistakenly took files belonging to his defence.
     
    Jaballah has said that he was jailed without charge and tortured on several occasions in Egypt. He staved off deportation to Egypt on the basis he would likely be tortured there.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Whooping Cough Outbreak Declared At Calgary School By Alberta Health Services

    Whooping Cough Outbreak Declared At Calgary School By Alberta Health Services
    CALGARY — Alberta Health Services has declared an outbreak of whooping cough at a school in Calgary.

    Whooping Cough Outbreak Declared At Calgary School By Alberta Health Services

    Police, Medical Examiner Investigating Hospital Death In Newfoundland

    Police, Medical Examiner Investigating Hospital Death In Newfoundland
    Under the province's Fatalities Investigation Act, reportable deaths involve violence, accident, suicide, improper or negligent treatment.

    Police, Medical Examiner Investigating Hospital Death In Newfoundland

    Reward Offered For Information Leading To Arrests In Recent Halifax Homicides

    HALIFAX — Nova Scotia has announced cash rewards for tips that help solve four recent homicides in Halifax.

    Reward Offered For Information Leading To Arrests In Recent Halifax Homicides

    Judge-Approved Assisted Death Didn't Clear Hurdles For Calgary Woman

    Judge-Approved Assisted Death Didn't Clear Hurdles For Calgary Woman
    Even though she had a judge's approval, Hanne Schafer could not find a doctor in her hometown of Calgary to help her die.

    Judge-Approved Assisted Death Didn't Clear Hurdles For Calgary Woman

    Citizenships Being Granted Without All Checks Being Carried Out: Auditor

    People with serious criminal records and others using potentially phoney addresses are among those who managed to secure Canadian citizenship, thanks to a system that doesn't do enough to root out fraud, the auditor general has found.

    Citizenships Being Granted Without All Checks Being Carried Out: Auditor

    Wildfire Threatening Fort McMurray Grows In Size, Crews Face Hot, Dry Day

    Crews and bulldozers kept the fire from spreading overnight east toward a camping area and two neighbourhoods.

    Wildfire Threatening Fort McMurray Grows In Size, Crews Face Hot, Dry Day