Close X
Tuesday, January 7, 2025
ADVT 
National

Canada's chief actuary report at odds with Alberta's pension plan estimate

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 24 Dec, 2024 11:12 AM
  • Canada's chief actuary report at odds with Alberta's pension plan estimate

A report from Canada's chief actuary suggests Alberta would not be entitled to more than half of the Canada Pension Plan's assets that the province has argued it should get if it were to leave the investment fund.

The chief actuary’s paper, published Friday, says the calculation that claims Alberta should get 53 per cent — or $334 billion — of the $575-billion in CPP assets “does not respect” federal pension legislation.

The $334-billion estimate comes from a report commissioned by the Alberta government in 2023 from consultants LifeWorks.

Instead, the chief actuary agreed with the interpretation of University of Calgary economics professor Trevor Tombe, who had pegged Alberta’s share at between 20 and 25 per cent of total assets.

“It is a complete rejection of the formula used in the LifeWorks report," said Tombe, adding that he, like Alberta Premier Danielle Smith, was disappointed the report didn't contain more detailed data.

However, Tombe said Smith's frustration over not getting a dollar figure is disingenuous because the report provides a simple formula to arrive at one.

"This is not hard. We can have this assigned to some high school students to calculate, and they could do it," he said, adding provincial officials have likely already calculated a number.

Smith reiterated Thursday that her government wouldn't consider moving forward with a referendum on the issue until it had a firm number from Ottawa.

"We were under the impression that the chief actuary was hiring three different analysts to look at the legislation, to be able to get three very precise ways of looking at this issue, so that we had a precise number," Smith said at an unrelated news conference.

Applying data from the LifeWorks report to the formula provided by the chief actuary would suggest Alberta's share would be about $135 billion, Tombe said.

However, he noted that CPP assets grow and shrink all the time, so any estimate could quickly become irrelevant.

Chief Actuary Assia Billig wrote that the LifeWorks formula would split up the CPP pie by leaving some provinces with a net negative allocation — an arrangement that would go against the wording of federal legislation.

That position, the report says, is consistent with the findings of an independent advisory council. Four of the five panel members ultimately sided with Tombe's approach.

Tombe said the LifeWorks estimate calculated what Alberta would be entitled to if it had an independent provincial pension plan beginning at the same time as the inception of the CPP in 1966.

Smith has long argued Albertans are getting a raw deal under the CPP.

Her United Conservative Party government spent $7.5 million on a public campaign touting the benefits of a provincial plan, including the possibility of lower contributions and higher payouts to retirees.

It also struck a public panel to speak directly to Albertans on the issue but later set it on the back burner pending a federal estimate.

Tombe said it's worth having a public debate about the potential risks and rewards of a provincial pension plan, but the Alberta government should be transparent about its methods.

"The challenge for the government is that the poll numbers didn't move at all, even with a completely exaggerated set of benefits," he said. 

Last week, a spokesperson for the federal finance department said it, along with the provinces and territories, are reviewing the findings from the chief actuary.

“Discussions will take place between the government of Canada and provinces and territories over the coming weeks regarding the report and possible next steps,” the spokesperson said.

 

MORE National ARTICLES

Put politics aside and act on online harms, mother of sextortion victim tells MPs

Put politics aside and act on online harms, mother of sextortion victim tells MPs
Parents of children who died because of online sexual extortion are urging MPs to act on online harms legislation. The bill and other legislation have been blocked from moving forward for months due to a parliamentary privilege debate raging between the Liberals and Conservatives.

Put politics aside and act on online harms, mother of sextortion victim tells MPs

Poilievre calls on House to back Singh's 'wise' words in no-confidence motion

Poilievre calls on House to back Singh's 'wise' words in no-confidence motion
Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre says he agrees with NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh on one thing: Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s Liberals are too weak to fight for Canadians. Poilievre kicked off debate in the House of Commons Thursday on a cheekily worded Conservative motion designed to use Singh’s own words against him.

Poilievre calls on House to back Singh's 'wise' words in no-confidence motion

B.C. premier says feds and provinces plan right-left approach to Trump's tariff plans

B.C. premier says feds and provinces plan right-left approach to Trump's tariff plans
Eby says the premiers and Prime Minister Justin Trudeau talked about using their political diversity and connections to approach politicians and business leaders in the United States, as talks over Trump's proposed 25 per cent tariff on imports from Canada and Mexico ramp up.

B.C. premier says feds and provinces plan right-left approach to Trump's tariff plans

Vancouver changes tune under Swift spell, with Gastown clock to chime 'Shake it Off'

Vancouver changes tune under Swift spell, with Gastown clock to chime 'Shake it Off'
Taylor Swift's Eras Tour is changing many things in Vancouver, from the tune of Gastown's iconic clock to traffic patterns as thousands of fans pour into the city ahead of Friday's first show. 

Vancouver changes tune under Swift spell, with Gastown clock to chime 'Shake it Off'

Overseas hikers rescued in B.C. relied on online app: rescue group

Overseas hikers rescued in B.C. relied on online app: rescue group
The search and rescue organization for Metro Vancouver's North Shore mountains says its teams recently rescued two international visitors who became stranded after relying on online hiking apps without doing further research. A statement on social media by North Shore Rescue says the first call last Thursday came when a visitor "seriously underestimated the difficulty" of an unofficial trail marked in an online app.

Overseas hikers rescued in B.C. relied on online app: rescue group

Five Eyes security agencies send up flare for help on preventing youth radicalization

Five Eyes security agencies send up flare for help on preventing youth radicalization
Security agencies from Canada and other members of the Five Eyes intelligence-sharing alliance are calling for a "whole-of-society response" to deal with the radicalization of young people lured into violent extremism. A new report from the alliance, which also includes Australia, New Zealand, the United Kingdom and the United States, emphasizes the importance of looking for signs of radicalization.

Five Eyes security agencies send up flare for help on preventing youth radicalization