Close X
Wednesday, November 27, 2024
ADVT 
National

Burnaby Steps Up Fight Against Kinder Morgan Trans Mountain Pipeline

James Keller The Canadian Press, 12 Sep, 2014 11:42 AM
    VANCOUVER - The mayor of Burnaby, B.C., says his city's lawsuit against Kinder Morgan over the removal of trees during work related to the Trans Mountain pipeline is not a legal tactic designed to stall — and ultimately stop — the project.
     
    But Mayor Derek Corrigan acknowledges his opposition to the proposed Trans Mountain expansion wouldn't change if the company abandoned its plan to tunnel the pipeline through Burnaby Mountain, which is home to a treasured conservation area.
     
    The city filed a lawsuit this week in B.C. Supreme Court asking for an injunction to prevent the company from conducting any work that destroys trees or disrupts parkland.
     
    "This is one more battle in a long war between us and Kinder Morgan and their desire to put a pipeline through our city," Corrigan said in an interview Thursday.
     
    "We've been clear about our opposition to the pipeline. This has exacerbated the issue by taking the pipeline through a park."
     
    The City of Burnaby has been a staunch opponent of the Trans Mountain expansion — a $5.4-billion project to triple the flow of bitumen and other oil products from Alberta along a pipeline to a terminal in Burnaby.
     
    The proposed project would see an expansion to the existing pipeline, with a significant part of the route in Burnaby being relocated. There would also be oil storage tanks added to the company's existing Burnaby tank farm and increased tanker traffic in the region.
     
    That opposition boiled over earlier this month when city staff confronted Kinder Morgan workers conducting survey and geotechnical work on Burnaby Mountain and cited the company for violating local bylaws. City staff stood in front of trees to protect them and called in the RCMP.
     
    That has prompted duelling applications at the National Energy Board and B.C. Supreme Court, with the company asking the energy regulator to allow its work to proceed and the city asking the court to stop it.
     
    Corrigan said the city would be opposed to the work on Burnaby Mountain even if it supported the pipeline, but also said city would oppose the pipeline regardless of its route.
     
    "We don't want hundreds of tankers moving through Burrard Inlet and we don't want five million litres of oil on top of Burnaby Mountain," he said.
     
    The debate over pipelines — and the Trans Mountain project in particular — is a sensitive topic in Burnaby, where a 2007 construction accident along the pipeline rained down 230,000 litres of oil on a local neighbourhood. Kinder Morgan-owned Trans Mountain Pipeline and two other companies pleaded guilty to environmental charges.
     
    Kinder Morgan has put its work on Burnaby Mountain on hold for now, but it's not clear how long that will last.
     
    The National Energy Board issued a ruling last month that said Kinder Morgan didn't need permission to conduct its survey work on city land. The company filed another application with the energy board earlier this month asking for another ruling in its favour.
     
    Burnaby's civil suit claims the National Energy Board can't exempt the company from following the city's bylaws, and it argues any attempt to do so would be unconstitutional. The city wants the National Energy Board decision set aside and an injunction against Kinder Morgan.
     
    In its latest filing with the National Energy Board, submitted Wednesday, the city says it's not attempting to interfere with the board's jurisdiction over federally regulated energy projects.
     
    "Rather, the city is acting to prevent destruction of trees and vegetation and the obstruction of traffic in contravention of its bylaws," the document says.
     
    Kinder Morgan declined to comment on the city's latest submission to the National Energy Board.
     
    The company has previously said it wants to work with the city and is prepared to mitigate any damage to trees and the environment, but that it would defend its right to access the land. The company says it needs the results of the survey work to meet application deadlines with the energy board, and delays could jeopardize the process.
     
    Jason Unger of the Edmonton-based Environmental Law Centre said it's not clear what power a city has to use its own bylaws against a project operating under the approval of the National Energy Board. Unger stressed that while he is aware of the debate in Burnaby, he is unfamiliar with the specific details of the legal dispute.
     
    "Generally, the ability of other levels of government — provinces and municipalities — to frustrate a federal undertaking is limited," he said in an interview.
     
    "Where the NEB is involved with an interprovincial pipeline, the ability to limit that undertaking is diminished because of the constitution."
     
    The National Energy Board plans to begin oral hearings examining the Trans Mountain expansion in July of next year. A final report is due to federal cabinet in January 2016.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Analysis: Baird's 'one voice' Iraq foray adds non-partisan moment to Tory policy

    Analysis: Baird's 'one voice' Iraq foray adds non-partisan moment to Tory policy
    IRBIL, Iraq - Moments after climbing into a bunker manned by Kurdish Peshmerga fighters, Foreign Affairs Minister John Baird looked behind him and gestured, saying, "Paul and Marc, come on."

    Analysis: Baird's 'one voice' Iraq foray adds non-partisan moment to Tory policy

    Group decries possible use of executed Chinese prisoners in bodies display

    Group decries possible use of executed Chinese prisoners in bodies display
    TORONTO - The possible use of corpses from executed Chinese prisoners for a public display as part of an exhibition in Ontario merits a criminal and coroner's investigation, a human-rights group is asserting.

    Group decries possible use of executed Chinese prisoners in bodies display

    B.C. Teachers Rally In Vancouver, Repeat Call For Binding Arbitration

    B.C. Teachers Rally In Vancouver, Repeat Call For Binding Arbitration
    VANCOUVER - The head of British Columbia's teachers' union has turned the screws on the provincial government to agree to binding arbitration and settle a teachers strike that has kept half-a-million students out of class.

    B.C. Teachers Rally In Vancouver, Repeat Call For Binding Arbitration

    Punjab To Create Dedicated Fund For Art, Culture

    Punjab To Create Dedicated Fund For Art, Culture
    The Punjab government will set up a dedicated fund for the welfare of litterateurs, dramatists, folk singers, artistes and other personalities from the fields of language, art and culture, Chief Minister Parkash Singh Badal announced here Friday.

    Punjab To Create Dedicated Fund For Art, Culture

    Plane That Wandered Over Caribbean With Unresponsive Pilot Crashes Off Jamaica

    Plane That Wandered Over Caribbean With Unresponsive Pilot Crashes Off Jamaica
    Shadowed much of the way by two U.S. fighter jets, a small plane with an unresponsive pilot flew a ghostly 1,700-mile journey down the East Coast and through Cuban airspace on Friday before finally crashing in the waters off Jamaica. The fate of the pilot and anyone else aboard was not immediately known.

    Plane That Wandered Over Caribbean With Unresponsive Pilot Crashes Off Jamaica

    Alberta: 100 People Have Gotten Ill From E. Coli Linked To Raw Pork Products

    Alberta: 100 People Have Gotten Ill From E. Coli Linked To Raw Pork Products
    EDMONTON - Alberta's chief medical officer says 100 people in the province have gotten ill from E. coli linked to raw pork products, including 19 people who have been hospitalized.

    Alberta: 100 People Have Gotten Ill From E. Coli Linked To Raw Pork Products