Thursday, March 28, 2024
ADVT 
National

Blanchet's blocks limit free speech: experts

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 19 Jan, 2021 01:30 AM
  • Blanchet's blocks limit free speech: experts

Dozens of people — including some MPs — say Bloc Québécois Leader Yves-François Blanchet has blocked them on Twitter after they criticized his statements about Transport Minister Omar Alghabra, with some arguing they have a right to be heard.

Nour El Kadri, the president of the Canadian Arab Federation who was among those blocked by Blanchet on the social media platform, said people should be able to respond to accusations made by politicians.

Last week, after Alghabra, born to a Syrian family in Saudi Arabia, was sworn in as federal transport minister, the Bloc issued a release that sought to sow doubt about his association with what it called the "political Islam movement" due to the minister's former role as head of the Canadian Arab Federation.

El Kadri tweeted at Blanchet to say the Canadian Arab Federation has been a secular organization under its constitution since it was founded in 1967.

"(I told him) it's secular like Quebec that you're asking for, then he blocked me," he said.

"He started to block other people who were voicing opposing opinions."

On Twitter, Blanchet argued against the idea that he was robbing anyone of their right to free expression.

"When I 'block' people, it's because their posts don't interest me (fake accounts, political staff, insults …)," he wrote in French last Thursday.

"That does not prevent them from publishing them. I just won't see them, nor they mine," he said, adding things are calmer this way.

Richard Moon, a law professor at the University of Windsor, said it is credible to claim that Blanchet infringed the charter-guaranteed right to freedom of expression of those who can no longer see or comment on his tweets.

While Twitter is not itself subject to the charter as a private entity, Moon said, when a politician uses it as a platform to make announcements and discuss political views, the politician's account becomes a public platform.

"To exclude someone from responding or addressing because of their political views could then be understood as a restriction on their freedom of expression," he said.

Duff Conacher, co-founder of the pro-transparency group Democracy Watch, said Blanchet's Twitter account is a public communication channel and he cannot decide arbitrarily to not allow voters to communicate with him there.

"Politicians are public employees, so they can't just cut people off from seeing what they're saying through one of their communication channels," he said.

"The public has a right to see all their communications."

Ottawa Mayor Jim Watson faced a lawsuit in 2018 from local activists he had blocked on Twitter. The court action was dropped after Watson conceded his account is public and unblocked everyone he had blocked, so no legal precedent was set.

Blanchet has also blocked some fellow members of Parliament, including Quebec Liberal Greg Fergus, Ontario New Democrat Matthew Green and Manitoba New Democrat Leah Gazan.

Green said he found himself blocked when he criticized Blanchet's statements that defended the right of universities' professors to use the N-word.

Gazan accused Blanchet last week of racism and Islamophobia over his statement about Alghabra.

"When criticized, he refuses to engage in a conversation, and a conversation he clearly needs to have around his Islamophobia," she said.

MORE National ARTICLES

Ottawa clears Boeing 737 MAX for flight

Ottawa clears Boeing 737 MAX for flight
Monday's announcement caps a recertification process without precedent in the history of modern aviation.

Ottawa clears Boeing 737 MAX for flight

B.C. to phase out enhanced driver's licences

B.C. to phase out enhanced driver's licences
The enhanced driver's licence and enhanced identification card allowed the holder to enter the United States through land crossings or marine ports without needing to present a valid passport.

B.C. to phase out enhanced driver's licences

B.C. hospice refusing MAID must vacate premises

B.C. hospice refusing MAID must vacate premises
The statement comes a week after the society's board sent layoff notices to all clinical staff at the hospice before the cancellation of its service agreement.

B.C. hospice refusing MAID must vacate premises

University director resigns after holiday travel

University director resigns after holiday travel
In a statement on the school's website, Berman says his resignation was effective on Friday.

University director resigns after holiday travel

Pfizer vaccine shortage will have an impact: Dix

Pfizer vaccine shortage will have an impact: Dix
Dix says this may mean that health officials will revisit the 35-day gap between providing the first and second doses of the vaccine.

Pfizer vaccine shortage will have an impact: Dix

Toronto Police are asking for the public's help in locating Zeevesh Chawla

Toronto Police are asking for the public's help in locating Zeevesh Chawla
He is described as 5'8", 170 lb., short black hair with brown eyes.

Toronto Police are asking for the public's help in locating Zeevesh Chawla