Close X
Monday, November 25, 2024
ADVT 
National

Beer Trial Told Fathers Of Confederation Wanted Free Trade Among Provinces

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 26 Aug, 2015 12:54 PM
    CAMPBELLTON, N.B. — A professor of political history testifying at a hearing over the right to buy beer in another province says the Fathers of Confederation wanted Canada to be a united country with unfettered trade.
     
    Andrew Smith of the University of Liverpool in England is considered the key defence witness in the case of a New Brunswick man charged with illegally importing alcohol from Quebec.
     
    Gerard Comeau of Tracadie is fighting the charge on constitutional grounds.
     
    An agreed statement of facts says he was caught in October 2012 with 14 cases of beer and three bottles of liquor that he had bought in nearby Pointe-a-la-Croix.  
     
    The New Brunswick Liquor Control Act limits anyone from having more than 12 pints of beer not sold by a provincially licensed liquor outlet.
     
    The defence argues that a section of the Liquor Control Act is unconstitutional because Section 121 of the Constitution Act says all goods from a province are to be admitted free into each of the other provinces.
     
    "Admitted free means of all impediments," Smith told the court Wednesday.
     
    Smith said his study of history shows the Fathers of Confederation wanted free trade within the provinces.
     
    "There was general acceptance of the need for free trade and a consensus for economic union," he said.
     
    Defence lawyer Mikael Bernard said it was important to have Smith explain to the court what the Fathers of Confederation intended.
     
    "Let's go back to 1864, 1863, 1865, 1866 and 1867 to find out what were their intentions, not just read the piece of paper as it stands today. Let's put everything into context," Bernard said.
     
    RCMP Const. Guy Savoie, the arresting officer, told the court that no one complained to police that New Brunswick residents were buying cheaper beer in Quebec.
     
    Instead, he said the decision was made by a corporal at the detachment to enforce the provincial law that limits the amount of beer that can be imported.
     
    Under questioning from defence lawyer Arnold Schwisberg, Savoie couldn't explain why police confiscated all of Comeau's liquor including what he was allowed to have.
     
    "It was our instruction to seize all the beer. I didn't question," Savoie said.
     
    Comeau was also given a fine of $292.50.
     
    A total of 17 people were fined and had their liquor confiscated during the two-day operation, which included RCMP officers in Quebec. 
     
    Savoie said no similar sting operations have been conducted since.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Quebecer Motorist Gets Upgraded Charges After 4-Year-Old Boy Dies From Crash Injuries

    Quebecer Motorist Gets Upgraded Charges After 4-Year-Old Boy Dies From Crash Injuries
    A Quebec motorist who is being detained in the deaths of a couple and their four-year-old son had some of the charges against him upgraded Friday.

    Quebecer Motorist Gets Upgraded Charges After 4-Year-Old Boy Dies From Crash Injuries

    Alberta Regulator Investigates Reports That 30 Herons Died At Oilsands Site

    Alberta Regulator Investigates Reports That 30 Herons Died At Oilsands Site
     The Alberta Energy Regulator says it is investigating reports that approximately 30 blue herons have died at an oilsands site.

    Alberta Regulator Investigates Reports That 30 Herons Died At Oilsands Site

    Quebec Judge Orders Review Of Inmate's Grievance Over Porn TV Channels In Prison

    Quebec Judge Orders Review Of Inmate's Grievance Over Porn TV Channels In Prison
    MONTREAL — A Federal Court judge has ordered a new review of a Quebec prisoner's grievance over access to TV channels showing late-night pornography.

    Quebec Judge Orders Review Of Inmate's Grievance Over Porn TV Channels In Prison

    Duceppe Won't Predict How Many Seats He Can Win In Fall Election

    Duceppe Won't Predict How Many Seats He Can Win In Fall Election
    MONTREAL — Bloc Quebecois Leader Gilles Duceppe says he will serve his full term if he is elected this fall, no matter how his party fares at the ballot box.

    Duceppe Won't Predict How Many Seats He Can Win In Fall Election

    Canadian Health Officials Warn About Outbreak Of Intestinal Illness Cyclospora

    OTTAWA — Public health officials are warning about an outbreak of the intestinal illness Cyclospora, with 83 cases are being investigated across Canada.

    Canadian Health Officials Warn About Outbreak Of Intestinal Illness Cyclospora

    One winning ticket for $50-million jackpot in Friday's Lotto Max

    The ticket was purchased somewhere in Alberta.

    One winning ticket for $50-million jackpot in Friday's Lotto Max