Close X
Monday, November 11, 2024
ADVT 
National

B.C.'s High Court Rejects Discrimination Suit From Victoria Guide Dog Owner

06 Oct, 2017 03:36 PM
    VANCOUVER — A blind Victoria man has lost his discrimination complaint in British Columbia's highest court.
     
    In a unanimous ruling, a panel of the B.C. Court of Appeal finds Graeme McCreath and his guide dog, Adrienne, were not discriminated against when they were refused a taxi ride in July 2014.
     
    McCreath claimed systemic discrimination when a driver with Victoria Taxi said he could not allow dogs in his car because of his allergies.
     
    The driver refused to transport McCreath and his dog, but arranged for another taxi that arrived within minutes.
     
    Both Human Rights Tribunal and the B.C. Supreme Court rejected the man's complaint, finding the taxi company had demonstrated there was a valid and reasonable justification for the discrimination.
     
    McCreath took the matter to the Court of Appeal, but it has now dismissed the case, ruling the taxi company is also required to meet the special needs of its own drivers. 
     
    "It was the duty to accommodate drivers with disabilities that provided the bona fide and reasonable justification for the discrimination against Mr. McCreath because any further effort to accommodate Mr. McCreath would have resulted in discrimination against the drivers," Justice David Tysoe said on behalf of the panel.
     
    Justice Gail Dickson and Justice Gregory Fitch concurred with Tysoe's reasons which dismissed the appeal without costs.
     

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Youth homelessness advocate completes cross-country walk pushing a shopping cart

    Youth homelessness advocate completes cross-country walk pushing a shopping cart
    A man who lived on the streets of Vancouver as a teenager will push a shopping cart through the city's rough-and-tumble Downtown Eastside once again on Friday, but this time will mark the end of a cross-country journey to raise awareness about youth homelessness.

    Youth homelessness advocate completes cross-country walk pushing a shopping cart

    U.S. court tosses appeal from B.C. woman falsely labelled a terrorist

    U.S. court tosses appeal from B.C. woman falsely labelled a terrorist
    A British Columbia woman has hit a dead end in her quest for compensation from the Canadian government, whom she accuses of falsely branding her a terrorist and an arms dealer to American authorities.

    U.S. court tosses appeal from B.C. woman falsely labelled a terrorist

    Pilot narrowly avoids crash with glider on Vancouver-to-Chicago flight

    Pilot narrowly avoids crash with glider on Vancouver-to-Chicago flight
    A passenger aboard a flight from Vancouver to Chicago says there were some tense moments as the pilot swerved to avoid crashing into a smaller aircraft.

    Pilot narrowly avoids crash with glider on Vancouver-to-Chicago flight

    Missing, murdered women inquiry hears stories of loss at first B.C. hearing

    Missing, murdered women inquiry hears stories of loss at first B.C. hearing
    Mary Jane Hill wasn't there to witness the birth of her grandchildren or to see them graduate from high school. She won't be there when her daughter needs her most, when she's in pain, or on her wedding day.

    Missing, murdered women inquiry hears stories of loss at first B.C. hearing

    Pop star Miley Cyrus joins campaign to protect B.C.'s grizzly bears

    Pop star Miley Cyrus joins campaign to protect B.C.'s grizzly bears
    Pop star Miley Cyrus has added some high-profile clout to the latest awareness campaign launched by a British Columbia-based environmental group seeking a total ban on grizzly hunting across the province.

    Pop star Miley Cyrus joins campaign to protect B.C.'s grizzly bears

    High school student dies after accidental shooting at Salt Spring Island

    High school student dies after accidental shooting at Salt Spring Island
    A high school student from Salt Spring Island has died after RCMP were called to a home for a report of an accidental shooting.

    High school student dies after accidental shooting at Salt Spring Island