Close X
Wednesday, November 20, 2024
ADVT 
National

B.C.'s Defence In Wrongful-Imprisonment Case Embarrassing And Ironic: Lawyers

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 25 Nov, 2015 12:16 PM
  • B.C.'s Defence In Wrongful-Imprisonment Case Embarrassing And Ironic: Lawyers
VANCOUVER — "Odd," "ironic," and "embarrassing" are among the words two prominent lawyers are using to describe British Columbia's legal defence against a man who was wrongfully imprisoned for nearly three decades.
 
Ivan Henry has sued the province, the federal government and the City of Vancouver after his 2010 acquittal on 10 counts of sexual assault — 27 years after he was originally convicted.
 
Eric Gottardi, former head of the criminal justice section of the Canadian Bar Association, said Tuesday that he was perplexed by the province's argument that Henry's sex-assault trial in the early 1980s may have ended differently had Henry not represented himself in court.
 
"It's an odd position for the province to be taking," said Gottardi.
 
"It's ironic that the province is saying, 'Well, this is one of the problems that comes from representing yourself — you might end up wrongly convicted,' when they're the ones that control a large portion of the purse strings in terms of access to publicly funded counsel through legal aid."
 
Michael McCubbin, who sits on the legal-aid action committee of the Trial Lawyers Association of B.C., called the province's position "embarrassing" when it argued that its failure to disclose important documents to Henry during the trial wouldn't likely have affected the outcome.
 
"(The province) is acknowledging a very legitimate miscarriage of justice for which they're responsible and then relying on a very technical and speculative argument to say that, 'Well, it doesn't really matter because (Henry) is too unskilled and simple to have done anything with it even if we had given him the documents,'" said McCubbin.
 
"What they're trying to say is, 'Yeah, we acknowledge that we screwed up. But even if we hadn't screwed up Ivan Henry would have been in the same position.'"
 
Neither Gottardi nor McCubbin are directly connected to the Henry case.
 
The documents in question that weren't disclosed to defence include sperm samples found on several complainants that failed to match Henry's blood type, as well as a hand-written letter from a complainant sent to the home address of one of the investigating officers.
 
"I didn't want to let you down. I didn't want to disappoint you," the complainant wrote in the letter read out in court by Henry's lawyer John Laxton.
 
Laxton suggested the letter held the reasons why the woman positively identified the accused.
 
"You have a very special place in my heart and I think of you often," read Laxton. "Take care of those blue eyes and don't work too hard.''
 
The complainant identified Henry using a police lineup in which he was held in a chokehold by three officers, which Laxton excoriated as "seriously flawed and unfair."
 
Henry reached a settlement with the City of Vancouver last week, but he is still pursuing compensation from the provincial and federal governments.

MORE National ARTICLES

New Democrats Repeatedly Demand The Resignation Of B.C. Children's Minister

The death of an 18-year-old male in government care is a part of a pattern of tragedies plaguing British Columbia's Ministry of Children and Families, say Opposition New Democrats who made repeated calls Monday for the minister to resign. 

New Democrats Repeatedly Demand The Resignation Of B.C. Children's Minister

Tractors, Cows On Ottawa Streets As Farmers Express Trade Talk Fears

Tractors, Cows On Ottawa Streets As Farmers Express Trade Talk Fears
Dozens of tractors are clogging Wellington Street in front of the Parliament Buildings.

Tractors, Cows On Ottawa Streets As Farmers Express Trade Talk Fears

Suspected Drunk Driver's Family 'deeply Saddened' By Crash That Left Grandfather And 3 Kids Dead

Suspected Drunk Driver's Family 'deeply Saddened' By Crash That Left Grandfather And 3 Kids Dead
Marco Muzzo's mother Dawn Muzzo expressed the family's condolences in a statement released today.

Suspected Drunk Driver's Family 'deeply Saddened' By Crash That Left Grandfather And 3 Kids Dead

New B.C. Rules Make Pensions More Secure, Offer Key For Locked-in Funds

New B.C. Rules Make Pensions More Secure, Offer Key For Locked-in Funds
The British Columbia government is announcing new standards for workplace pension plans, creating options that could be activated even before an employee retires.

New B.C. Rules Make Pensions More Secure, Offer Key For Locked-in Funds

Seniors Outnumber Children Under 14 For The First Time In Canada: Statistics Canada

The agency said the number of Canadians aged 65 or older edge out the number of children under the age of 14, according to the most recent population figures.

Seniors Outnumber Children Under 14 For The First Time In Canada: Statistics Canada

Police Investigating Possible Cases Of Animal Cruelty In Fredericton

Police Investigating Possible Cases Of Animal Cruelty In Fredericton
"The cat's head was resting on her front paws as if she was sound asleep. It was definitely posed that way," Nixon said Tuesday from his home in Fredericton.

Police Investigating Possible Cases Of Animal Cruelty In Fredericton