Close X
Thursday, December 5, 2024
ADVT 
National

B.C. Treaty Process Too Slow, But What's Next For Governments, First Nations?

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 12 Apr, 2015 12:08 PM
  • B.C. Treaty Process Too Slow, But What's Next For Governments, First Nations?
VICTORIA — There is easy agreement between First Nations and the British Columbia and federal governments that treaty negotiations are languishing, 
 
expensive and fraught with obstacles, but all sides have completely different views on how to solve the trouble.
 
The agony and ecstasy of the maligned and saluted treaty process was on full display last week when hundreds of cheering people witnessed the signing of 
 
an agreement-in-principle on a southern Vancouver Island treaty after 20 years of talks.
 
Premier Christy Clark's Liberals refused to appoint former provincial cabinet minister George Abbott as the new chief of the B.C. Treaty Commission — the 
 
overseer of the federal, provincial and First Nations negotiation process — suggesting changes must be made.
 
Federal Aboriginal Affairs Minister Bernard Valcourt is digesting a report from federal envoy Doug Eyford that recommends Ottawa approach treaties with a 
 
sense of urgency and consider which talks are progressing and which should be dumped.
 
B.C.'s First Nations Summit, the province's largest aboriginal organization, wants Ottawa and B.C. treaty negotiators to come to the table with the power to 
 
make decisions rather than being forced to retreat to back rooms for approval of every move.
 
That convoluted plot line was evident at the signing ceremony Thursday when drums pounded, singers chanted and chiefs choked back tears as they 
 
honoured the commitment and sacrifice of leaders who spent years at negotiating tables.
 
Songhees First Nation Chief Ron Sam described himself as somewhat of a treaty-table rookie, devoting only six years to negotiations. Twenty years to reach 
 
a deal is too long, said Sam.
 
"These are good faith negotiations, so I think there needs to be some recognition of everybody's role in the whole process and not have it bogged down in 
 
political aspects," he said.
 
First Nations Summit spokeswoman Cheryl Casimer said moves are underway to get the three sides to meet later this month. First Nations will tell the 
 
governments they need to pick up their pace if they want to speed up treaty settlements, she said.
 
"Get some real negotiators," said Casimer. "Get some real mandates. If we had that at the table we would have far more agreements in place than we have 
 
today."
 
Four treaties have resulted from the modern-day treaty process that was launched in 1993.
 
British Columbia is the only province that didn't sign treaties with most of its more than 200 First Nations. A handful of bands signed agreements through the 
 
so-called Douglas Treaties in the mid-1800s.
 
"We can't keep people waiting," said Casimer. "We're talking about peoples lives here."
 
B.C. Aboriginal Relations Minister John Rustad said the current treaty process is in need of an overhaul where deals no longer take decades to achieve.
 
"I think each side has to look in the mirror a little bit in terms of how they've contributed to this not being successful," he said. "It's something all parties need 
 
to be thinking about in terms of how we build whatever process will be going forward."
 
Rustad said B.C. has achieved success with a stepping-stone approach to treaty making that involves reaching a series of smaller economic and land 
 
agreements that could eventually set the stage for final treaties.
 
"I believe a process to reach long-term reconciliation can be founded in that type of approach," he said.
 
MP Mark Strahl, Valcourt's parliamentary secretary, said his government plans to consult widely among First Nations about Eyford's report, but he suggested 
 
the federal government isn't about to make immediate changes to the process.
 
"Certainly Mr. Eyford has identified some concerns," said Strahl who attended the Island treaty ceremony. "We realize there are obstacles to the process but 
 
this is a reminder that through patient negotiation we can achieve these milestones."

MORE National ARTICLES

Britain's Celebrity Chef Jamie Oliver Expands Food Crusade To G20, Cites Diet Problems In Canada

Britain's Celebrity Chef Jamie Oliver Expands Food Crusade To G20, Cites Diet Problems In Canada
OTTAWA — Jamie Oliver, Britain's celebrity chef, has thrown down the gauntlet — or maybe it's an oven mitt — to Canadian politicians to join his international campaign for mandatory diet education in rich countries.

Britain's Celebrity Chef Jamie Oliver Expands Food Crusade To G20, Cites Diet Problems In Canada

Commons Committee Report Calls For A Better Strategy To Combat ISIL

Commons Committee Report Calls For A Better Strategy To Combat ISIL
OTTAWA — As Canada prepares its next forays in the fight against ISIL, the Conservative-dominated foreign affairs committee is calling on the government to develop a strategy that goes beyond the military campaign.

Commons Committee Report Calls For A Better Strategy To Combat ISIL

Corporate Profit Margins At 27-year High Amid Falling Loonie, Labour Costs: CIBC

Corporate Profit Margins At 27-year High Amid Falling Loonie, Labour Costs: CIBC
TORONTO — CIBC World Markets says corporate profit margins hit a 27-year high in the fourth quarter and are likely to remain strong despite the recent softening in the economy due to the oil price shock.

Corporate Profit Margins At 27-year High Amid Falling Loonie, Labour Costs: CIBC

New Brunswick Forecasts $477m Deficit, Hikes Gas Taxes, Cuts Teaching Jobs

New Brunswick Forecasts $477m Deficit, Hikes Gas Taxes, Cuts Teaching Jobs
FREDERICTON — New Brunswick's Liberal government has introduced an $8.6-billion budget that increases taxes for the wealthy, bumps up the price of fuel, promises to close some courthouses and cut nearly 250 teaching jobs.

New Brunswick Forecasts $477m Deficit, Hikes Gas Taxes, Cuts Teaching Jobs

Bring All Branches Of Government Under Information Law, Watchdog Urges

Bring All Branches Of Government Under Information Law, Watchdog Urges
OTTAWA — A federal watchdog says the Access to Information Act should be extended to all branches of government — including the offices that support Parliament and the courts.

Bring All Branches Of Government Under Information Law, Watchdog Urges

Tender Call Finally Issued In Decade-long Plan To Replace Military Search Planes

Tender Call Finally Issued In Decade-long Plan To Replace Military Search Planes
OTTAWA — The Harper government has issued a long-awaited call for tenders to replace Canada's aging fixed-wing search planes, more than a decade after the project was first proposed.

Tender Call Finally Issued In Decade-long Plan To Replace Military Search Planes