Close X
Monday, November 18, 2024
ADVT 
National

B.C. judge refuses cash award to claimant who takes part in 'underground economy'

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 08 Aug, 2024 03:29 PM
  • B.C. judge refuses cash award to claimant who takes part in 'underground economy'

A provincial court judge in Surrey, B.C., has thrown out a small claims case between a lumber company and a fence building firm over an "unlawful scheme" between the two to avoid paying GST and PST. 

The principal of Top Quality Lumber Ltd., Amarjit Dhaliwal, told the court in June that H & R Fencing owed his company almost $21,000, but H & R's owner said it was closer to $4,000 in unpaid bills. 

However, Judge Jay Soloman said in his ruling issued July 29 that Dhaliwal admitted to taking cash from customers to avoid paying taxes, and he inferred from the evidence that Top Quality was "actively engaged" in the "underground economy." 

Soloman ruled he was unsure of the accuracy of the balance owing, given the "absence of legitimate record keeping," and while he found the owner of H & R, Kamal Hehar, an unreliable witness, the claimant didn't prove his case. 

Even though Hehar admitted to owing $4,000, the judge declined to order the award, saying both companies took part in an "unlawful scheme," but it was the seller's responsibility to charge and remit PST and GST. 

The judge said the evidence presented at the hearing showed that Dhaliwal intentionally conducted his business affairs in an unlawful manner, noting the defendant paid over $64,000 in cash for products that weren't invoiced. 

MORE National ARTICLES

Canadians mark year since plane downing in Iran

Canadians mark year since plane downing in Iran
The ceremonies, part of an international effort, began with a livestream on Thursday at 9:42 p.m. ET, the time Ukrainian International Airlines Flight PS752 left Tehran's international airport.

Canadians mark year since plane downing in Iran

No unexpected effects from COVID-19 shots so far

No unexpected effects from COVID-19 shots so far
Health Canada continues to review data from two other vaccine developers, AstraZeneca and Johnson & Johnson, but is still awaiting more data from the companies.

No unexpected effects from COVID-19 shots so far

Snowboarder dies after fall in Whistler, B.C

Snowboarder dies after fall in Whistler, B.C
RCMP confirm the man, in his mid-20s, fell about 20 metres from a cliff at one of the highest points of the resort, Thursday morning.

Snowboarder dies after fall in Whistler, B.C

Man killed in Richmond, B.C., shooting

Man killed in Richmond, B.C., shooting
The deadly attack is the first in Richmond in 2021 and comes just two days after a targeted shooting in Surrey killed 24-year-old Gary Kang.

Man killed in Richmond, B.C., shooting

B.C. COVID-19 restrictions extended to Feb. 5

B.C. COVID-19 restrictions extended to Feb. 5
The public health rules prohibit social gatherings among people from different households, as well as adult team sports and other activities.

B.C. COVID-19 restrictions extended to Feb. 5

B.C. care home outbreak spurs calls for oversight

B.C. care home outbreak spurs calls for oversight
The outbreak, among the deadliest in long-term care homes in B.C., is raising questions about oversight at such facilities.

B.C. care home outbreak spurs calls for oversight