Close X
Friday, November 1, 2024
ADVT 
National

B.C. judge refuses cash award to claimant who takes part in 'underground economy'

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 08 Aug, 2024 03:29 PM
  • B.C. judge refuses cash award to claimant who takes part in 'underground economy'

A provincial court judge in Surrey, B.C., has thrown out a small claims case between a lumber company and a fence building firm over an "unlawful scheme" between the two to avoid paying GST and PST. 

The principal of Top Quality Lumber Ltd., Amarjit Dhaliwal, told the court in June that H & R Fencing owed his company almost $21,000, but H & R's owner said it was closer to $4,000 in unpaid bills. 

However, Judge Jay Soloman said in his ruling issued July 29 that Dhaliwal admitted to taking cash from customers to avoid paying taxes, and he inferred from the evidence that Top Quality was "actively engaged" in the "underground economy." 

Soloman ruled he was unsure of the accuracy of the balance owing, given the "absence of legitimate record keeping," and while he found the owner of H & R, Kamal Hehar, an unreliable witness, the claimant didn't prove his case. 

Even though Hehar admitted to owing $4,000, the judge declined to order the award, saying both companies took part in an "unlawful scheme," but it was the seller's responsibility to charge and remit PST and GST. 

The judge said the evidence presented at the hearing showed that Dhaliwal intentionally conducted his business affairs in an unlawful manner, noting the defendant paid over $64,000 in cash for products that weren't invoiced. 

MORE National ARTICLES

Canada starts on two billion tree-planting pledge

Canada starts on two billion tree-planting pledge
To get two billion trees into the ground over a decade, around 33 million would have to be planted each month during a tree-planting season, and over nine years that grows to about 37 million trees.

Canada starts on two billion tree-planting pledge

Alberta legislature member criticizes patio dinner

Alberta legislature member criticizes patio dinner
One of Alberta Premier Jason Kenney’s caucus members says restaurant owners should be allowed more leeway if the premier is allowed to break COVID-19 rules on patio dining.

Alberta legislature member criticizes patio dinner

China should be priority on PM's G7 trip: O'Toole

China should be priority on PM's G7 trip: O'Toole
Canada's Official Opposition wants Prime Minister Justin Trudeau to use his time at the G7 Leaders' Summit to take a stand against China and call for the 2022 Winter Olympics to be moved from Beijing.

China should be priority on PM's G7 trip: O'Toole

ICBC fairness office to aid in no-fault disputes

ICBC fairness office to aid in no-fault disputes
A statement from the Ministry of Public Safety and Solicitor General says regulations setting out the role of the fairness officer were approved Wednesday and the new position is expected to be in place by the end of the year.

ICBC fairness office to aid in no-fault disputes

Canada seeking U.S. doses of Moderna

Canada seeking U.S. doses of Moderna
All 5.7 million doses delivered to Canada from Moderna so far have come from their production lines in Europe. but the company's shipments to Canada have been spotty and small since April 1.

Canada seeking U.S. doses of Moderna

Ottawa asks if Canada needs another pipeline

Ottawa asks if Canada needs another pipeline
Federal officials were asking themselves how many pipelines does Canada really need in the days after U.S. President Joe Biden cancelled Keystone XL.

Ottawa asks if Canada needs another pipeline