Close X
Monday, December 2, 2024
ADVT 
National

B.C. Didn't Infringe On Teachers' Contract Rights On Class Size: Appeal Court

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 30 Apr, 2015 12:28 PM
    VANCOUVER — British Columbia's highest court has ruled the province did not violate teachers' charter rights, reversing two lower-court decisions in favour of a union that has fought for class size and composition clauses in its contracts.
     
    Four of the five B.C. Appeal Court judges said the trial judge's latest finding that the province had failed to consult the union in good faith was based on legal and factual errors.
     
    Two earlier rulings from the B.C. Supreme Court said the government infringed on teachers' rights when it removed their ability to bargain class size and composition with separate legislation in 2002 and in 2012.
     
    "In our opinion, the legislation was constitutional," the high court judges said in the decision released Thursday. "Between the consultations and the collective bargaining leading up to the legislation, teachers were afforded a meaningful process in which to advance their collective aspirations. Their freedom of association was respected."
     
    "In our opinion, the judge should not have assessed the substantive merit or objective reasonableness of the parties' negotiating positions. Courts are poorly equipped to make such assessments."
     
    The B.C. Teachers Federation has the option to seek leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada, which has already heard previous cases involving the two sides.
     
    Dissenting Judge Ian Donald wrote that the trial judge did not err in law or fact in finding that the province had failed to consult in good faith and that the legislation did infringe the charter.
     
    The appeal court also released a separate, unanimous decision ensuring that confidential cabinet documents that were revealed in the most recent trial would be kept secret.
     
    B.C. Supreme Court judge Susan Griffin had ruled that the union could share its written submissions with members, but the appeal court overturned that decision saying information from private government documents was included.
     
    Griffin had pored over hundreds of pages of the confidential documents and concluded the government negotiated in bad faith and deliberately planned to provoke a strike in 2012.
     
    The court first ruled the government had violated teachers' rights in a 2011 decision that restored the contract provisions that had been deleted nine years earlier.
     
    The B.C. government passed legislation in 2012 that once again deleted the contract clauses and the teachers' union responded with another legal challenge, which led to a second decision in the union's favour in January 2014.
     
    The province appealed and a hearing was held last October. In its written arguments, the province said it had bargained in good faith and that it has the right to set education policy.
     
    The court case emerged as one of the main sticking points in last year's strike, which closed schools earlier in June and delayed the start of classes in September until the B.C. Teachers' Federation signed a six-year deal.
     
    It included a clause that could reopen negotiations for class size and composition, but the high court decision makes that irrelevant.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Former Kandahar Combat Commander Named As Canada's Next Defence Chief

    Former Kandahar Combat Commander Named As Canada's Next Defence Chief
    OTTAWA — A former combat commander who has led operations at home and overseas has been appointed to the country's top military job.

    Former Kandahar Combat Commander Named As Canada's Next Defence Chief

    Conservatives Commit $13.5 Million To April And May Ad Blitz On Budget Measures

    Conservatives Commit $13.5 Million To April And May Ad Blitz On Budget Measures
    The tax agency's $6 million in TV advertising is augmented by a $7.5 million campaign by the Finance department, all designed to promote previously announced and new targeted tax breaks.

    Conservatives Commit $13.5 Million To April And May Ad Blitz On Budget Measures

    Hundreds Gather At Surrey's Gurdwara Discuss Gang Violence, Importance Of Parental Involvement

    Hundreds Gather At Surrey's Gurdwara Discuss Gang Violence, Importance Of Parental Involvement
    Surrey residents concerned about the spate of gang violence in their city are taking action to restore peace to the community's streets.

    Hundreds Gather At Surrey's Gurdwara Discuss Gang Violence, Importance Of Parental Involvement

    Nepal's Death Toll Soars To 3,815, British Columbia Firefighters Go On Rescue Mission

    Nepal's Death Toll Soars To 3,815, British Columbia Firefighters Go On Rescue Mission
    A team of firefighters from B.C.'s Lower Mainland is joining an effort to find survivors of the worst earthquake to hit Nepal in more than 80 years.

    Nepal's Death Toll Soars To 3,815, British Columbia Firefighters Go On Rescue Mission

    2 Homeless Men Killed In Downtown Winnipeg, Police Advising Caution

    2 Homeless Men Killed In Downtown Winnipeg, Police Advising Caution
    Police in Winnipeg are advising the homeless to use caution in the wake of two homicides. Police say the bodies of two homeless men were found on Saturday behind buildings in the downtown area.

    2 Homeless Men Killed In Downtown Winnipeg, Police Advising Caution

    Massive Hospital Move Underway As Patients Arrive At New Montreal Superhospital

    Massive Hospital Move Underway As Patients Arrive At New Montreal Superhospital
    MONTREAL — A massive hospital move is underway in Montreal today as patients are being transferred from the Royal Victoria to the newly-built "superhospital."

    Massive Hospital Move Underway As Patients Arrive At New Montreal Superhospital