Close X
Saturday, October 5, 2024
ADVT 
National

B.C. court rejects attempt to stop thousands of trees from being cut in Stanley Park

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 03 Oct, 2024 03:42 PM
  • B.C. court rejects attempt to stop thousands of trees from being cut in Stanley Park

The B.C. Supreme Court will not grant an injunction to stop tree removal in Vancouver's Stanley Park after a group claimed the work was doing more harm than good. 

The court ruled this week that the challenge raised "novel" issues about whether park users were owed a duty of care by the city and park board, but it would be "unlikely" that a trial would establish such a duty. 

The case was filed by park users Michael and Katherine Caditz, Anita Hansen and Jillian Maguire, who claim the removal of trees because of a looper moth infestation caused them "emotional and psychological harm."

They claim the city and the park board were negligent in ordering the tree removal work, relying on a "fundamentally flawed report" by a forestry consulting company hired to carry out the logging work. 

Plaintiff Michael Caditz says he and his fellow plaintiffs disagree with the court's ruling, but no trial date to hear the case in full has been set. 

Caditz says they are exploring other legal options because they still believe the decision to cut down thousands of trees in the park was based on "bad science," and that upcoming logging activity in the park should be halted. 

"We feel there was gross negligence involved and we disagree with the judge's decision and we're analyzing the decision to determine how to proceed," Caditz said in an interview on Thursday. 

He said they consulted a number of experts who agreed that the "logging operation that's being done is not necessary." 

"It's causing more harm than good," Caditz said. "It's creating an elevated risk of falling trees and a fire and that there's no basis at all in science, in evidence-based science for the logging operation." 

The B.C. Supreme Court declined to issue an injunction before a trial, finding that "before anything as extensive as the potential removal of 160,000 trees in Stanley Park is effected, there is time" for the park board to fulfil "its statutory obligations with respect to the care and management of Stanley Park." 

The court also found that there's also a legal avenue for "a public law challenge, by way of judicial review, to any decision to proceed with tree removal beyond that contemplated for the 2024/2025 window, if warranted." 

The city and park board's lawyer, Ian Dixon, did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the court's ruling. 

 

MORE National ARTICLES

Jasper bus tour registration open, limited to evacuees with damaged homes

Jasper bus tour registration open, limited to evacuees with damaged homes
Wildfire evacuees from Jasper, Alta., whose homes were destroyed or damaged last week, were able to start registering online Friday for bus tours of the burned townsite. However, when the tours would take place was still undecided.

Jasper bus tour registration open, limited to evacuees with damaged homes

Water behind B.C. landslide is more likely to move over top than burst: minister

Water behind B.C. landslide is more likely to move over top than burst: minister
The minister said there's no timeline on when the water will start flowing, and "current modelling" shows that overtopping of the dam is more likely than a sudden break. They estimate it will take 12 to 24 hours for water and debris from the dam to reach Hope, B.C., about 500 kilometres south of the massive landslide.

Water behind B.C. landslide is more likely to move over top than burst: minister

Brazen sexual assault in Surrey

Brazen sexual assault in Surrey
Mounties in Surrey are warning the public and appealing for information after what they describe as a "brazen" sexual assault at a community centre. The R-C-M-P say they responded to the report on Wednesday morning at the Grandview Heights Aquatic Centre.

Brazen sexual assault in Surrey

Firearms seizure after video surfaces of people dancing with guns

Firearms seizure after video surfaces of people dancing with guns
Police in Metro Vancouver say they have seized several firearms after a video appeared online showing a group of people dancing with guns. Surrey R-C-M-P say they became aware of the video yesterday and they were able to confirm the address of the property where it was allegedly filmed. 

Firearms seizure after video surfaces of people dancing with guns

Homicide in Langley

Homicide in Langley
Mounties in Langley say one man is dead and another is recovering in hospital after an overnight shooting that's believed to be an isolated incident. R-C-M-P say they received a report of gunshots in area along 202 Street near 72 Avenue just after midnight.

Homicide in Langley

Canadians urged to leave Lebanon as flights cancelled amid growing tensions

Canadians urged to leave Lebanon as flights cancelled amid growing tensions
Canada has been planning since October for a possible evacuation of its citizens and sent military personnel to Lebanon and Cyprus in preparation. Salameh hopes that her rescheduled flight on Aug.

Canadians urged to leave Lebanon as flights cancelled amid growing tensions