Close X
Sunday, October 13, 2024
ADVT 
National

B.C. court rejects attempt to stop thousands of trees from being cut in Stanley Park

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 03 Oct, 2024 03:42 PM
  • B.C. court rejects attempt to stop thousands of trees from being cut in Stanley Park

The B.C. Supreme Court will not grant an injunction to stop tree removal in Vancouver's Stanley Park after a group claimed the work was doing more harm than good. 

The court ruled this week that the challenge raised "novel" issues about whether park users were owed a duty of care by the city and park board, but it would be "unlikely" that a trial would establish such a duty. 

The case was filed by park users Michael and Katherine Caditz, Anita Hansen and Jillian Maguire, who claim the removal of trees because of a looper moth infestation caused them "emotional and psychological harm."

They claim the city and the park board were negligent in ordering the tree removal work, relying on a "fundamentally flawed report" by a forestry consulting company hired to carry out the logging work. 

Plaintiff Michael Caditz says he and his fellow plaintiffs disagree with the court's ruling, but no trial date to hear the case in full has been set. 

Caditz says they are exploring other legal options because they still believe the decision to cut down thousands of trees in the park was based on "bad science," and that upcoming logging activity in the park should be halted. 

"We feel there was gross negligence involved and we disagree with the judge's decision and we're analyzing the decision to determine how to proceed," Caditz said in an interview on Thursday. 

He said they consulted a number of experts who agreed that the "logging operation that's being done is not necessary." 

"It's causing more harm than good," Caditz said. "It's creating an elevated risk of falling trees and a fire and that there's no basis at all in science, in evidence-based science for the logging operation." 

The B.C. Supreme Court declined to issue an injunction before a trial, finding that "before anything as extensive as the potential removal of 160,000 trees in Stanley Park is effected, there is time" for the park board to fulfil "its statutory obligations with respect to the care and management of Stanley Park." 

The court also found that there's also a legal avenue for "a public law challenge, by way of judicial review, to any decision to proceed with tree removal beyond that contemplated for the 2024/2025 window, if warranted." 

The city and park board's lawyer, Ian Dixon, did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the court's ruling. 

 

MORE National ARTICLES

Squamish hit and run leaves one dead

Squamish hit and run leaves one dead
The crash happened September 2nd, 2022, when the driver of a pickup truck lost control navigating a corner and the vehicle flipped over a sidewalk and landed on a bus stop, pinning two women who were sitting there. Police say 44-year-old Gurpreet Sangha died in hospital, while the second woman survived with "life-altering injuries."

Squamish hit and run leaves one dead

B.C. finds solution for religious ban on assistance in dying at St. Paul's Hospital

B.C. finds solution for religious ban on assistance in dying at St. Paul's Hospital
The British Columbia government has announced a workaround to help those who want to use medical assistance in dying while they are being treated St. Paul's Hospital in Vancouver. A statement from the Health Ministry says Vancouver Coastal Health will set up a clinical space adjacent to St. Paul's, allowing it to continue to refuse to opt out of medical assistance in dying on religious grounds.  

B.C. finds solution for religious ban on assistance in dying at St. Paul's Hospital

Post about Vancouver sex assault was 'misinformation,' woman fell off scooter: VPD

Post about Vancouver sex assault was 'misinformation,' woman fell off scooter: VPD
The Vancouver Police Department says a viral social media post claiming a woman had been violently abducted and sexually assaulted in East Vancouver in early November was based on "misinformation." Police say they reviewed security footage and interviewed witnesses, and found the woman who was allegedly assaulted had actually fallen off an electric scooter and hit her face on the pavement. 

Post about Vancouver sex assault was 'misinformation,' woman fell off scooter: VPD

Indigenous signage aims to make B.C. legislature more inclusive, accepting

Indigenous signage aims to make B.C. legislature more inclusive, accepting
The Speaker of British Columbia's legislature says the unveiling of Indigenous-themed signs outside the building is a necessary step toward opening doors that have been historically closed. Raj Chouhan says the B.C. legislature is the province's largest symbol of colonialism, but it's his priority to make the building a more welcoming and inclusive place.  

Indigenous signage aims to make B.C. legislature more inclusive, accepting

Vancouver Bright Nights extended til Jan

Vancouver Bright Nights extended til Jan
The Vancouver Park Board has two Christmas surprises for everyone who missed out on snagging the tickets for the Stanley Park Christmas Train. The Park Board says it’s releasing another 17-thousand tickets for the Bright Nights event and it’s also extending the run until January 6th due to high demand.

Vancouver Bright Nights extended til Jan

Online harms bill: Don't link boy's suicide with government actions, Trudeau says

Online harms bill: Don't link boy's suicide with government actions, Trudeau says
NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh referred to the death of the 12-year-old in Prince George, B.C., during question period today as he asked Trudeau when the Liberal government will table long-promised legislation designed to mitigate online harms. 

Online harms bill: Don't link boy's suicide with government actions, Trudeau says