Close X
Friday, October 11, 2024
ADVT 
National

B.C. court rejects attempt to stop thousands of trees from being cut in Stanley Park

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 03 Oct, 2024 03:42 PM
  • B.C. court rejects attempt to stop thousands of trees from being cut in Stanley Park

The B.C. Supreme Court will not grant an injunction to stop tree removal in Vancouver's Stanley Park after a group claimed the work was doing more harm than good. 

The court ruled this week that the challenge raised "novel" issues about whether park users were owed a duty of care by the city and park board, but it would be "unlikely" that a trial would establish such a duty. 

The case was filed by park users Michael and Katherine Caditz, Anita Hansen and Jillian Maguire, who claim the removal of trees because of a looper moth infestation caused them "emotional and psychological harm."

They claim the city and the park board were negligent in ordering the tree removal work, relying on a "fundamentally flawed report" by a forestry consulting company hired to carry out the logging work. 

Plaintiff Michael Caditz says he and his fellow plaintiffs disagree with the court's ruling, but no trial date to hear the case in full has been set. 

Caditz says they are exploring other legal options because they still believe the decision to cut down thousands of trees in the park was based on "bad science," and that upcoming logging activity in the park should be halted. 

"We feel there was gross negligence involved and we disagree with the judge's decision and we're analyzing the decision to determine how to proceed," Caditz said in an interview on Thursday. 

He said they consulted a number of experts who agreed that the "logging operation that's being done is not necessary." 

"It's causing more harm than good," Caditz said. "It's creating an elevated risk of falling trees and a fire and that there's no basis at all in science, in evidence-based science for the logging operation." 

The B.C. Supreme Court declined to issue an injunction before a trial, finding that "before anything as extensive as the potential removal of 160,000 trees in Stanley Park is effected, there is time" for the park board to fulfil "its statutory obligations with respect to the care and management of Stanley Park." 

The court also found that there's also a legal avenue for "a public law challenge, by way of judicial review, to any decision to proceed with tree removal beyond that contemplated for the 2024/2025 window, if warranted." 

The city and park board's lawyer, Ian Dixon, did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the court's ruling. 

 

MORE National ARTICLES

Minister sorry for 'crappy piece of land' remark that angered pro-Palestinian groups

Minister sorry for 'crappy piece of land' remark that angered pro-Palestinian groups
British Columbia's Post-Secondary Education Minister Selina Robinson has apologized for saying Israel was founded on a "crappy piece of land," remarks that have angered pro-Palestinian groups and others and triggered calls for her resignation. Robinson said in a social media post on Thursday that her comments were "disrespectful," and she was referring to the land having limited natural resources.  

Minister sorry for 'crappy piece of land' remark that angered pro-Palestinian groups

Cremated remains found at YVR

Cremated remains found at YVR
Police are asking for the public's help in reuniting cremated remains with the rightful guardian. Mounties in Richmond say someone left a package at the outbound international screening checkpoint at Vancouver International Airport on November 27th.

Cremated remains found at YVR

Man charged with multiple B & E's

Man charged with multiple B & E's
A man suspected of multiple break-and-enters last year and in 2022 has been charged with 27 counts in relation to the incidents. Burnaby Mounties say the 44-year-old is facing charges ranging from break-and-enter to possession of stolen property, including for the purpose of trafficking.

Man charged with multiple B & E's

3 year housing plan for Surrey

3 year housing plan for Surrey
The City of Surrey is launching a three-year plan to boost the number of new housing units to an average of more than four thousand per year. A statement from the City of Surrey says the plan is enabled by 96-million-dollars in federal funding.  

3 year housing plan for Surrey

Bus firm and union agree to mediator's plan to avert Metro Vancouver strike

Bus firm and union agree to mediator's plan to avert Metro Vancouver strike
Coast Mountain Bus Company and the union representing its transit supervisors have both accepted the recommendations of a mediator in an agreement that looks set to avert another Metro Vancouver bus strike. A statement from the bus firm's president, Michael McDaniel, said the next step was to sign a memorandum of agreement before the contract ratification process.

Bus firm and union agree to mediator's plan to avert Metro Vancouver strike

Increase in U.S. softwood lumber duties 'entirely unwarranted,' trade minister says

Increase in U.S. softwood lumber duties 'entirely unwarranted,' trade minister says
The federal government is lashing out at the U.S. Commerce Department over plans to raise duties on Canadian softwood lumber. International Trade Minister Mary Ng says the U.S. has signalled it intends to raise duties to 13.86 per cent, up from 8.05 per cent.  Ng calls the move disappointing and entirely unwarranted.

Increase in U.S. softwood lumber duties 'entirely unwarranted,' trade minister says