Close X
Wednesday, December 4, 2024
ADVT 
National

B.C. couple partially victorious in bankruptcy fight with securities regulator

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 31 Jul, 2024 02:51 PM
  • B.C. couple partially victorious in bankruptcy fight with securities regulator

The Supreme Court of Canada has ruled that people fined by provincial securities regulators can wipe out penalties through bankruptcy, but orders to pay back ill-gotten gains remain in place. 

The ruling handed down Wednesday says penalties imposed by "administrative tribunals or regulatory agencies" are not covered by a list of exceptions in the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, which outlines specific types of debts that "survive bankruptcy."

The case involved a B.C. couple, Thalbinder Singh Poonian and Shailu Poonian, who were ordered by the British Columbia Securities Commission to pay $13.5 million in administrative penalties and $5.6 million to repay those who lost money in a market manipulation scheme that "caused vulnerable investors to lose millions of dollars."

University of British Columbia law professor Cristie Ford said the high court's ruling is a "bit of a blow to the securities commission and its ability to protect investors in the capital markets."

"It's a powerful regulator with important priorities," Ford said. "Sometimes, the important priorities that securities regulators are trying to take care of can run up against other important priorities when it comes to other areas of law." 

Ford said provincial securities regulators are empowered to penalize bad actors in the country's capital markets, but this case saw it run up against a "deep constitutional question around what courts can do and what administrative tribunals or the executive can do." 

She said there is a "considerable challenge around making sure that securities commissions can be as effective as possible within the bounds of these constraints that are imposed by deep constitutional principles.

"It's tricky," she said. 

A majority of the high court ruled penalties are not exempt because they aren't imposed by a court, and don't directly result from fraudulent conduct, but rather are made "indirectly" through the commission's decision to sanction the Poonians.

The court ruled that if debts from administrative penalties did survive bankruptcy by being covered by the law's exemptions, there would be "potential to capture debts or liabilities that are not the direct result of deceit." 

The court found, however, that disgorgement orders issued by the regulator "represent the value of the bankrupts’ fraud — the funds that they gained as a result of their market manipulation."

"There is therefore a direct link between the fraudulent conduct of the bankrupts and the commission’s disgorgement orders," the ruling says. 

The high court said if Parliament wanted fines or penalties levied by regulators like the commission to survive bankruptcy, "it could have said so expressly."

Amending Canada's Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, Ford said, would "be the simplest fix for this problem," but whether that happens is unclear. 

"I can't really say whether or not Parliament is going to take up this invitation to amend the bankruptcy act," she said. "While an amendment to the bankruptcy act would fix this immediate problem, it is sort of more of a Band-Aid solution to a bigger problem, which is that securities commission priorities don't always fit perfectly well with other parts of the law." 

MORE National ARTICLES

Targeted shooting in Kamloops

Targeted shooting in Kamloops
Kamloops R-C-M-P say a 40-year-old man known to police has suffered serious, but non-life-threatening injuries after a targeted shooting that officers believe to be gang-related. Police say it happened last night in the 170 block of Tranquille Road.

Targeted shooting in Kamloops

48 year old Inderjit Singh Sandhu sentenced to life in imprisonment for killing wife Kamaljit Sandhu

48 year old Inderjit Singh Sandhu sentenced to life in imprisonment for killing wife Kamaljit Sandhu
Police say a 48-year-old Abbotsford man has been sentenced to life in prison without parole eligibility for 13 years for murdering his wife. Inderjit Singh Sandhu pleaded guilty in April to second-degree murder in connection with the July 2022 homicide in the Fraser Valley city.

48 year old Inderjit Singh Sandhu sentenced to life in imprisonment for killing wife Kamaljit Sandhu

Environment Canada issues multiple warnings as B.C. braces for weekend heat

Environment Canada issues multiple warnings as B.C. braces for weekend heat
The six warnings span Vancouver Island, where they will be in effect from Friday until early next week, and the North Coast including Kitimat and Terrace, where the warnings will be in place from Saturday until Tuesday night.

Environment Canada issues multiple warnings as B.C. braces for weekend heat

B.C. seniors advocate seeks tenancy protection for residents of retirement homes

B.C. seniors advocate seeks tenancy protection for residents of retirement homes
British Columbia's seniors advocate is calling for the enforcement of tenancy laws to protect residents of retirement homes who he says face illegal rent increases and evictions. Dan Levitt says in a new report that some retirement homes claim the Residential Tenancy Act does not apply to their residents, or to mandatory fees for services including meals and housekeeping.

B.C. seniors advocate seeks tenancy protection for residents of retirement homes

Border workers who nearly went on strike in June ratify new contract

Border workers who nearly went on strike in June ratify new contract
The union representing Canada's border workers says members have voted 91 per cent in favour of a new collective agreement. More than 9,000 Canada Border Services Agency workers were planning job action in June but the strike was averted when a tentative agreement was reached with the federal government.

Border workers who nearly went on strike in June ratify new contract

Anita Huberman, CEO of Surrey Board of Trade announces she will leave on August 30

Anita Huberman, CEO of Surrey Board of Trade announces she will leave on August 30
Huberman is the longest serving President and CEO of the Surrey Board of Trade, having served for 18 years – unprecedented in the chamber of commerce/board of trade industry. During her 31 years with the organization, having served in a variety of roles, she has built the organization up from a struggling entity into one of the largest organizations of its kind in Canada.

Anita Huberman, CEO of Surrey Board of Trade announces she will leave on August 30