Close X
Monday, November 11, 2024
ADVT 
National

Auditor Slams Feds For Not Properly Tracking Impact Of Tax Credits On Treasury

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 28 Apr, 2015 10:36 AM
    OTTAWA — Canada's auditor general says parliamentarians and the public they represent have no idea precisely how many billions of dollars the federal treasury foregoes each year through election-friendly tax credits and giveaways.
     
    Michael Ferguson's spring report, released today, says Finance Department reports do not include future cost projections on a wide suite of tax benefits that MPs ought to be able to take into account when they debate budgets and public spending.
     
    The auditor says overall projections are available for measures such as the children's fitness tax credit, the first-time home buyers credit and the age credit, but that is not the same as tracking the actual amount of dollars being lost.
     
    Aside from public accountability, the issue is important because the Harper government is fond of using tax-based expenditures to curry favour with voters, as opposed to direct subsidies or rebates.
     
    Ferguson says "a properly designed tax expenditure report is critical" in order to provide MPs and Canadians with a comprehensive picture of federal tax revenue and what each measure is — or is not — accomplishing.
     
    Unlike direct program spending, which is detailed in an annual budget and a budget implementation bill, the auditor says ongoing tax credit measures do not require the annual approval of Parliament.
     
    "These expenditures were not systematically evaluated and the information reported did not adequately support parliamentary oversight," said the report. 
     
    "Important programs are delivered through the tax system, and the resulting tax-based expenditures could account for tens of billions of dollars annually. Furthermore, Parliament requires complete information on tax-based expenditures to exercise adequate oversight."
     
    Finance does publish, separate from the budget, a tax expenditure and evaluation report, but Ferguson says it does not include valuable information that may be available in publications from other departments, such as the Canada Revenue Agency.
     
    He says the finance report doesn't spell out the number of beneficiaries for each tax expenditure, nor lay out information about the objective or purpose of each measure.
     
    Perhaps most importantly, the auditor says they don't publish future cost projections for each tax expenditure.
     
    The federal government used to provide those specific figures, but stopped doing so in 2008.
     
    The audit also questioned why Finance is not analyzing some of the measures, including the mineral exploration tax credit, the age credit, the textbook tax credit, and the credit for first-time home buyers.
     
    In total, those credits are responsible for an estimated $3 billion per year in revenue the government has opted to forego.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Harper Government Back In The Middle Of Historic Turk-Armenian Dispute

    Harper Government Back In The Middle Of Historic Turk-Armenian Dispute
    The Harper government is sending Immigration Minister Chris Alexander to Armenia to attend the commemoration of the 1915 massacre of Armenians at the hands of Ottoman Turks. It's a historic tragedy that Ottawa calls genocide, to the anger of Turkey.

    Harper Government Back In The Middle Of Historic Turk-Armenian Dispute

    'Math Is Difficult': Numbers Dominate As Alberta Leaders Square Off In Debate

    'Math Is Difficult': Numbers Dominate As Alberta Leaders Square Off In Debate
    EDMONTON — Alberta Premier Jim Prentice traded barbs with NDP Leader Rachel Notley — mock commiserating with her that "math is difficult" — and literally turned his back on Brian Jean of the Wildrose in a flinty debate Thursday night.

    'Math Is Difficult': Numbers Dominate As Alberta Leaders Square Off In Debate

    Justice Marshall Rothstein To Retire From Supreme Court Of Canada In August

    Justice Marshall Rothstein To Retire From Supreme Court Of Canada In August
    OTTAWA — Justice Marshall Rothstein is retiring from the Supreme Court of Canada effective Aug. 31, just months short of his mandatory retirement on his 75th birthday in December.

    Justice Marshall Rothstein To Retire From Supreme Court Of Canada In August

    Go-Slow Strategy In Play At Duffy Trial Seems To Frustrate Presiding Judge

    Go-Slow Strategy In Play At Duffy Trial Seems To Frustrate Presiding Judge
    Justice Charles Vaillancourt says after 14 days of arguments and testimony, he's only just beginning to see the broad brush strokes of the issues at hand.

    Go-Slow Strategy In Play At Duffy Trial Seems To Frustrate Presiding Judge

    More Residents Set To Leave Northern Ontario Community Threatened By Flood

    More Residents Set To Leave Northern Ontario Community Threatened By Flood
    Chief Derek Stephen says 600 vulnerable residents of Kashechewan on the western shore of James Bay are the first to be evacuated.

    More Residents Set To Leave Northern Ontario Community Threatened By Flood

    Airpark Owner Says He Warned Pilot About Engine Before Highway 91 Landing

    Airpark Owner Says He Warned Pilot About Engine Before Highway 91 Landing
    Arnold Klappe of King George Airpark says he and his mechanic told Paul Deane-Freeman about the condition of his plane's engine on several occasions, and even priced out the parts needed to fix it.

    Airpark Owner Says He Warned Pilot About Engine Before Highway 91 Landing