Close X
Thursday, November 14, 2024
ADVT 
National

Appeal Court Tosses Out Constitutionality Challenge Over Health Care

The Canadian Press, 10 Sep, 2015 12:23 PM
    OKOTOKS, Alta. — A former Calgary-area dentist who paid for back surgery in Montana rather than wait to have it done in Alberta has lost his challenge of a lower-court ruling that determined he could not sue the government over a delay in getting the procedure done in his own province.
     
    Darcy Allen, who is from Okotoks, Alta., had argued unsuccessfully in Court of Queen's Bench that the Alberta government's monopoly on health care was unconstitutional.
     
    Allen's legal team had sought to have a 2005 Supreme Court of Canada decision expanded to Alberta.
     
    That decision struck down a Quebec law that banned private insurance for medically necessary services.
     
    However, a Court of Queen's Bench judge ruled Allen had failed to establish a sufficient link between the government's practices and the harm he suffered.
     
    On Wednesday, the Alberta Court of Appeal ruled against him again, concluding that his "attempt to adjudicate the constitutionality of the Alberta statute in a summary fashion was inappropriate" and the issues raised in the case would require a full trial.
     
    Allen injured his back playing hockey in late 2007 and was told it could take up to eight months to get an MRI scan under public health care.
     
    A scan he had done at a private clinic confirmed disc damage and when pain medication and other treatments didn't work, the dentist was told he needed surgery.
     
    He was scheduled for an operation in September 2011, but he instead paid $77,000 to have it done in Montana in December 2009.
     
    Allen, who eventually had to give up his practice due to his condition, had originally wanted to sue the province for damages resulting from the time he spent on MRI and surgical wait lists.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    River Temperatures Down In B.c., But So Are Projected Sockeye Returns: DFO

    River Temperatures Down In B.c., But So Are Projected Sockeye Returns: DFO
    Area director Stu Cartwright says temperatures are now around 15 or 16 degrees, an acceptable range crucial to the health of 1.5-million sockeye due to reach spawning grounds in B.C. over the coming weeks.

    River Temperatures Down In B.c., But So Are Projected Sockeye Returns: DFO

    Indian-Born Policeman Sharnjit Gill Appointed Superintendent Of Surrey RCMP

    Indian-Born Policeman Sharnjit Gill Appointed Superintendent Of Surrey RCMP
    Born in Rajiana village in Moga, Punjab, Gill began his career in Surrey General Duty 26 years ago.

    Indian-Born Policeman Sharnjit Gill Appointed Superintendent Of Surrey RCMP

    Nathaniel Jessup, 28, Charged With Abduction Attempts Of 2 Young Girls In Stanley Park

    Nathaniel Jessup, 28, Charged With Abduction Attempts Of 2 Young Girls In Stanley Park
    Twenty-eight-year-old Nathaniel Jessup is accused of two counts of assault and one count of forcible confinement.

    Nathaniel Jessup, 28, Charged With Abduction Attempts Of 2 Young Girls In Stanley Park

    Man Accused In Toronto Office Stabbing Rampage Found Not Criminally Responsible

    Man Accused In Toronto Office Stabbing Rampage Found Not Criminally Responsible
    An Ontario judge said his decision in Chuang Li's case was "an extremely close call," but he ultimately found the 49-year-old not criminally responsible due to a mental disorder.

    Man Accused In Toronto Office Stabbing Rampage Found Not Criminally Responsible

    B.C. Teen Nicholas Hannon's Death Leads To First-Degree Murder Charges Against Three Friends

    B.C. Teen Nicholas Hannon's Death Leads To First-Degree Murder Charges Against Three Friends
    First-degree murder charges have been laid against three young men, more than 18 months after the disappearance of their friend.

    B.C. Teen Nicholas Hannon's Death Leads To First-Degree Murder Charges Against Three Friends

    Victoria-Area Inmate Walks Out Of Jail Following Accidental Release from Custody

    Victoria-Area Inmate Walks Out Of Jail Following Accidental Release from Custody
    A warrant has been issued for a 30-year-old inmate from the Vancouver Island Regional Correctional Centre after he was accidentally released from custody.

    Victoria-Area Inmate Walks Out Of Jail Following Accidental Release from Custody