Close X
Monday, November 18, 2024
ADVT 
National

Aggravated Sex-Assault Conviction Upheld For Ottawa Man Who Hid HIV-Positive Status

The Canadian Press, 01 Apr, 2016 11:59 AM
    TORONTO — An aggravated sexual assault conviction will stand for a man who had unprotected sex with two other men without telling them he was HIV-positive.
     
    In a ruling this week, Ontario's top court upheld the December 2012 jury conviction against Steven Boone, who argued the complainants would have had sex with him anyway.
     
    Among other things, Boone argued the trial judge should have instructed jurors to acquit him if they found the complainants were reckless or prepared to assume the risk of unprotected sex without knowing the sexual health of their partner.
     
    "It is one thing to be careless or reckless about whether a risk exists — and quite another to assume a known risk," the Appeal Court said in rejecting the argument.
     
    "Even if the complainants were reckless in their sexual behaviour, whether in the past or at the time of their sexual encounter with the appellant, this has no bearing on the issue whether they would have consented had they known of the appellant’s HIV-positive status."
     
    Evidence shows Boone knew in October 2009 he was infected — a fact he failed to mention before the impugned sexual activity in March 2010 in Kitchener, Ont.
     
    After two sexual rounds, one of which involved a foursome, Boone sent a text to one of the complainants to let him know — much to his horror — that he was HIV-positive.
     
    Neither complainant, who sought immediate medical attention, contracted the virus that can lead to AIDS.
     
    At trial, Boone admitted to the unprotected sex and withholding his health status. The complainants testified they would not have had sex with him had they known — the central issue at trial.
     
     
    Before the trial, Boone's lawyer won permission to grill the complainants on their prior sexual conduct — normally off-limits in cases of sexual assault. Both admitted to regularly having unprotected sex — including group sex — with men whose HIV status they did not know, court records show.
     
    Boone argued the evidence showing they had been sexually careless in the past cast doubt on their claim that they would not have had sex with him had they known he was HIV-positive. The Appeal Court disagreed.
     
    In its ruling, the court said a person must disclose their HIV-positive status before having sex — an obligation that doesn't end if the proposed partner had previously been reckless.
     
    The decision includes a discussion — at the Crown's request — of the earlier ruling allowing Boone's lawyer to cross-examine the complainants on their prior sexual conduct.
     
    In his reasons, Justice Robert Sharpe said he wanted to clarify the law, which aims to protect sexual-assault complainants from the "twin myths" that their past sexual behaviour either made it more likely they had given consent or that they were less worthy of belief. Ultimately, Sharpe decided, the judge had been wrong to allow the questioning.
     
    "There are many cases, among them sexual assault, where consent is at issue in which the accused is faced with incriminating evidence from a witness that is difficult to challenge," the decision states.
     
    "Such difficulties do not justify changing, bending or distorting the law to make it easier for the accused to raise a reasonable doubt."

    MORE National ARTICLES

    South Surrey Woman Recovering After Deck Collapse That Sent Her Sliding Into 16 Metre Ravine

    South Surrey Woman Recovering After Deck Collapse That Sent Her Sliding Into 16 Metre Ravine
    Unnamed victim was on a deck at the back of a home in south Surrey when the deck collapsed into the ravine below.

    South Surrey Woman Recovering After Deck Collapse That Sent Her Sliding Into 16 Metre Ravine

    Indian-Origin Man Parmpal Gill Arrested In Brampton, Ont. For Alleged Gun-Point Threatening

    Parmpal Gill, 32 was arrested on Monday after he picked up a quarrel with a 20-year old man over their business in the area of Cadetta Road and Highway 50 in Brampton

    Indian-Origin Man Parmpal Gill Arrested In Brampton, Ont. For Alleged Gun-Point Threatening

    Police Identify Woman Found In Surrey, B.C.

    Police Identify Woman Found In Surrey, B.C.
    The woman was found on Monday at about 4 p.m. near 180th Street and 66A Avenue, in the North Cloverdale West neighbourhood.

    Police Identify Woman Found In Surrey, B.C.

    Surrey named among World’s Top 7 Intelligent Communities again

    The fourteenth annual Top7 list includes cities from four nations. Montreal and Winnipeg are the other Canadian cities to make the list and the remaining communities are from Germany, Taiwan, and New Zealand. 

    Surrey named among World’s Top 7 Intelligent Communities again

    International Tourism To B.C. Increasing, With France In Lead

    International Tourism To B.C. Increasing, With France In Lead
    It says tourism to B.C. from France jumped by 33 per cent in 2014 compared to the previous year.

    International Tourism To B.C. Increasing, With France In Lead

    Donald Trump Website Sparks International Interest In Cape Breton: Tourism Group

    Donald Trump Website Sparks International Interest In Cape Breton: Tourism Group
    Mary Tulle, CEO of destination Cape Breton, says her group's website has exploded with 300,000 referrals from the "Cape Breton if Donald Trump Wins" site, with about 216,000 of the clicks from curious Americans.

    Donald Trump Website Sparks International Interest In Cape Breton: Tourism Group