Close X
Friday, November 29, 2024
ADVT 
National

Accused must knowingly breach bail conditions to be found guilty: Supreme Court

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 18 Jun, 2020 05:50 PM
  • Accused must knowingly breach bail conditions to be found guilty: Supreme Court

A person accused of breaching bail must knowingly or recklessly violate conditions in order to be found guilty of straying from them, the Supreme Court of Canada has ruled.

In its unanimous decision Thursday, the high court ordered a new trial for Chaycen Michael Zora, who was convicted of failing to comply with police checks while out on bail.

Zora was charged with a number of drug offences in British Columbia and released on condition he obey a curfew and be at his front door within five minutes of police or a bail supervisor checking on him.

Twice in one week in October 2015, police rang Zora's doorbell but he did not answer.

Zora was charged with two counts of breaching his curfew and two counts of failing to meet the condition to answer the door.

He was acquitted of the alleged curfew-breach charges as the judge was not satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt that Zora had been outside of his house at the time. However, Zora was fined $920 after being found guilty on the two counts of failing to appear at the door for curfew compliance checks.

Zora had said it was difficult to hear the doorbell from where he slept, and that he was undergoing methadone treatment and withdrawal from his heroin addiction, which made him very sleepy.

Zora had no further problems complying after changing where he slept in his home and setting up an audio-visual system to help alert him to future police checks.

He unsuccessfully challenged his convictions for the police-check violations in the B.C. Court of Appeal, prompting his appeal to the Supreme Court.

The high court said a conviction for breaching bail has profound implications for the liberty of the accused, including imprisonment even if the individual is acquitted of the underlying charge.

"A new trial is needed to address whether Mr. Zora knowingly or recklessly breached his conditions," Justice Sheilah Martin wrote on behalf of the court.

MORE National ARTICLES

Limit gun capacity to five bullets, victims group urges Trudeau government

Limit gun capacity to five bullets, victims group urges Trudeau government
As the government prepares new gun-control legislation, a victims group says magazine capacity should be limited to five bullets for all firearms to reduce the damage a mass shooter can do.

Limit gun capacity to five bullets, victims group urges Trudeau government

Canadians living in China watch developments in Meng case closely

Canadians living in China watch developments in Meng case closely
Canadian teacher Christopher Maclure remembers the first time he felt afraid living in China. Almost all the newspapers there carried stories about how angry Chinese officials were when Huawei's chief financial officer Meng Wanzhou was detained by Canadian authorities in Vancouver at the behest of the United States.

Canadians living in China watch developments in Meng case closely

Health officials concerned mass gatherings could become breeding grounds for COVID-19

Health officials concerned mass gatherings could become breeding grounds for COVID-19
Mass Protests Become Breeding Grounds for COVID-19 George Floyd was found to be COVID-19 positive at the time of his DEATH. What Does that mean to #BlackLivesMAtter Protests #Worldwide.

Health officials concerned mass gatherings could become breeding grounds for COVID-19

Trudeau urges shared COVID-19 vaccine at global summit in a week amid UN run

Trudeau urges shared COVID-19 vaccine at global summit in a week amid UN run
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says a COVID-19 vaccine must be shared by the world in order to eradicate the disease.

Trudeau urges shared COVID-19 vaccine at global summit in a week amid UN run

'Defunding' police, funding mental health resources will save lives: experts

'Defunding' police, funding mental health resources will save lives: experts
The death of a Toronto woman who fell from her 24th-floor balcony while police were in her home has renewed calls for an overhaul of how society deals with people in mental health crises.

'Defunding' police, funding mental health resources will save lives: experts

Special payments to seniors to arrive in early July, Liberals say

Special payments to seniors to arrive in early July, Liberals say
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says a special one-time payment for seniors will go out the week of July 6.

Special payments to seniors to arrive in early July, Liberals say