Close X
Friday, December 27, 2024
ADVT 
National

Accessing Child Porn Not Part Of Possession Offence, Appeal Court Rules

The Canadian Press, 01 Jun, 2017 12:57 PM
    TORONTO — The criminal charge of possessing child pornography does not include a lesser offence of accessing the lewd images, Ontario's top court ruled on Wednesday.
     
    In acquitting a man convicted of a possession charge, the Court of Appeal rejected prosecution arguments that it should instead convict him of accessing child porn.
     
    "It is possible to possess child pornography without accessing it," the Appeal Court said. "The elements of the offence of accessing are not intrinsically embraced within the offence of possession."
     
    The prosecution had argued that it is "legally impossible" to possess child pornography without at some point accessing it. However, on looking at the two charges — separate under the Criminal Code — the Appeal Court disagreed.
     
    As an example, the court cited a situation in which someone downloads child pornography onto a memory stick and then hands it off to someone who knows what's on it.
     
    "He would have knowledge of the contents of the memory stick and control over those contents; therefore the elements of possession would be satisfied," the Appeal Court ruled. "He would not be guilty of accessing child pornography because he has not viewed the images on the memory stick nor has he transmitted them to himself."
     
    In this case, the man who can only be identified as M.N. was initially convicted of possession based on images found on a computer's Internet cache — temporary storage files created when accessing websites. He shared the device with his common law spouse, and their 14-year-old daughter used it occasionally as well.
     
    Evidence at his trial in Peterborough, Ont., was that M.N. and his spouse discovered child pornography on the computer in February 2007 and they decided to call the police, who found 55 images in the temporary Internet files folder.
     
     
    M.N. admitted to sometimes viewing adult porn, but not to accessing child pornography. His daughter testified she sometimes used the computer to access adult pornography and, on one occasion, a child pornography site popped up.
     
    What's now not disputed is that Ontario court judge Rhys Morgan who initially heard the case didn't understand the evidence from an expert witness about how images can appear in the cache. As a result, Morgan rejected M.N.'s contention that he didn't know about the child pornography and hadn't downloaded it and convicted him of possession in 2009.
     
    M.N. appealed, but the summary conviction appeal judge, Superior Court Justice Hugh O'Connell, also failed to understand the expert evidence and dismissed the appeal in 2013.
     
    Although M.N. had already served his six-month jail term, he turned to the province's top court in April still seeking an acquittal.
     
    The prosecution agreed there was not enough forensic evidence to prove that M.N. knowingly possessed porn. Nevertheless, it argued against an acquittal, saying accessing child pornography was included in the possession offence for which M.N. had been convicted.
     
    Alternatively, the prosecution called on the Appeal Court to amend the charge against to align with evidence that M.N. had illegally accessed child pornography and order a new trial.
     
    In rejecting the prosecution's inclusion arguments, the Appeal Court also said it would not be in the interests of justice under the circumstances to amend the charge.
     
    "To do so would prejudice the appellant," Justice Karen Weiler wrote for the Appeal Court. "Accordingly, I would grant leave to appeal, allow the appeal, and enter an acquittal for the offence of possession of child pornography."

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Overall Abbotsford Crime Rate Dips But Thefts From Auto Leap, Say Police

    The Abbotsford Police Department says in a news release that 859 thefts from vehicles have been reported his year, an eight per cent hike over the same period last year.

    Overall Abbotsford Crime Rate Dips But Thefts From Auto Leap, Say Police

    Kerala Painter's Work Draws Huge Response In Victorian Parliament

    Kerala Painter's Work Draws Huge Response In Victorian Parliament
    The painting by Sedunath Prabhakar, settled in Melbourne, showcased portraits of 50 prominent Australians drawn from a wide and varying cultural, social and political spectrum. 

    Kerala Painter's Work Draws Huge Response In Victorian Parliament

    US Judge Issues Arrest Warrant For 'Hot' Yoga Guru Bikram Choudhury

    A Los Angeles judge has issued an arrest warrant for Bikram Choudhury, the Indian American "hot" yoga guru, after he failed to pay more than $7 million in 2016 to his former lawyer who was the victim in a sexual harassment case against him.

    US Judge Issues Arrest Warrant For 'Hot' Yoga Guru Bikram Choudhury

    Two Men Dead Following Separate Incidents In Montreal

    Two Men Dead Following Separate Incidents In Montreal
    Montreal police are investigating the city's ninth and 10th homicides of the year in different neighbourhoods.

    Two Men Dead Following Separate Incidents In Montreal

    Mayors Across Canada Urge Federal Government To Lead On Overdose Deaths Crisis

    VANCOUVER — Mayors across Canada are calling for federal leadership on the "national emergency" of overdoses by ensuring provinces provide timely access to addiction treatment and by launching public education campaigns.

    Mayors Across Canada Urge Federal Government To Lead On Overdose Deaths Crisis

    Man Who Killed Children Struggles With Anger Management: Psychiatrist

    COQUITLAM, B.C. — A man found not criminally responsible for killing his three children because of a mental disorder is making slow progress but still faces serious anger issues, a psychiatrist says.

    Man Who Killed Children Struggles With Anger Management: Psychiatrist