Close X
Tuesday, March 11, 2025
ADVT 
National

$7M Award Upheld For Girl Disabled After Jumping From Moving School Bus

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 05 Nov, 2019 07:43 PM

    TORONTO - A bus company is on the hook for a $7 million award to a girl who suffered a brain injury when she jumped from a moving vehicle in keeping with an informal last-day-of-school tradition, Ontario's top court has ruled.

     

    In rejecting most arguments from the bus company, the Court of Appeal found no issues with how the trial judge had instructed the jury in the case of Sarah Little, of Barrie, Ont., who was 13 years old when she jumped out of the rear emergency exit in June 2011.

     

    "The trial judge did not misdirect on causation, and there was ample evidence to support the jury's verdict and apportionment of liability," the Appeal Court said. "As such, the liability verdict is reasonable."

     

    The incident happened on the last day of Grade 8 when Little and other students were on their way home from their area public school. She and her twin sister had ridden the bus for years and Sarah, as a bus patroller, knew how to open the emergency doors.

     

    Evidence was that the risky practice of jumping from moving buses had become something of a tradition among graduating Grade 8 students at their school. Despite knowing how dangerous it was and despite efforts of her sister and other students to dissuade her, Little jumped from the bus before it stopped to let her off. She smashed her head on the sidewalk.

     

    Sarah cannot care for herself and will likely never live or work independently, court records show.

     

    After a four-week trial, jurors found the teen 25 per cent responsible for her own injuries, and the bus company, which now operates as Landmark Bus Lines, for the rest. In May 2018, the Superior Court jury awarded Little $7 million for her share of damages.

     

    Among other things, jurors found the company didn't follow its own policies by failing to tell schools about previously known instances of students jumping from buses on their last day.

     

    On appeal, the company called for either a new trial or a reduction in the award. It argued Justice Elizabeth Quinlan made legal errors in her instructions to jurors, who should have put more blame on Little for what happened to her.

     

    The higher court rejected the arguments. Quinlan, the court said, had clearly set out the factors that led to the teen's injuries, and jurors were aware of those. Both sides also had a hand in drafting the jury instructions and neither had objected when Quinlan delivered them, the court said.

     

    "There is no question that the jury was alive to the defence position that Ms. Little should be principally responsible for her tragic decision to jump from a moving school bus," the Appeal Court said. "In assessing Ms. Little's contributory negligence at 25 per cent, the jury rejected her argument that the (company) should bear 80 to 90 per cent of the fault."

     

    The Appeal Court did find Quinlan made a mistake in instructing the jury about whether Little had failed to lessen her pre-trial losses by having psychiatric treatment or by moving to a group home. However, the panel said the error was not material given the lack of evidence her prognosis would have been any different.

     

    The court did side with the company on one aspect: It ordered a new trial to decide whether the award to Sarah should have been reduced by the amount of statutory accident benefits she received.

     

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Trudeau Turns To Political Veteran Anne McLellan On Tips To Form Government

    Anne McLellan, a one-time Liberal deputy prime minister, and Isabelle Hudon, Canada's ambassador to France, are providing tips to Trudeau on the formation of his new government.

    Trudeau Turns To Political Veteran Anne McLellan On Tips To Form Government

    Coquitlam RCMP Ask For Help Finding Sexual Assault Suspect ‘Jordan’, May Be Protected By Silence

    Coquitlam RCMP is asking you to help advance a two-month-old sexual assault investigation by identifying a suspect who is likely being protected by silence.

    Coquitlam RCMP Ask For Help Finding Sexual Assault Suspect ‘Jordan’, May Be Protected By Silence

    Supporting Extracurricular Opportunities For Students In B.C. Schools

    Supporting Extracurricular Opportunities For Students In B.C. Schools
    More than 1,300 parent advisory councils (PAC) and district parent advisory councils (DPAC) throughout B.C. are receiving approximately $11 million in Community Gaming Grants for the 2019-20 school year.

    Supporting Extracurricular Opportunities For Students In B.C. Schools

    People Move From Homelessness To Housing In Langley

    People Move From Homelessness To Housing In Langley
    Forty-nine people are transitioning from homelessness to supportive housing, as the doors open this week at a newly renovated building at 6465 201 St. in Langley.

    People Move From Homelessness To Housing In Langley

    BC Celebrating Access to Justice Week 2019

    BC Celebrating Access to Justice Week 2019
    The B.C. government has proclaimed Oct. 27 to Nov. 2, 2019, Access to Justice Week, an annual event that engages the public and legal community to showcase ways to make it easier for British Columbians to resolve their disputes and deal with legal matters.    

    BC Celebrating Access to Justice Week 2019

    How Amplify BC Is Helping Artists' Voices Be Heard

    Biawanna is excited to film their first music video, thanks to a grant from Amplify BC.    

    How Amplify BC Is Helping Artists' Voices Be Heard