Close X
Thursday, December 12, 2024
ADVT 
International

Woman Ticketed For Not Holding Escalator Handrail To Be Heard By Supreme Court

The Canadian Press, 16 Nov, 2018 02:12 PM
    OTTAWA — The Supreme Court of Canada agreed Thursday to hear the case of a woman who was ticketed and arrested after she refused instructions to hold onto an escalator handrail.
     
     
    Bela Kosoian was in a subway station in the Montreal suburb of Laval in 2009 when a police officer told her to respect a pictogram with the instruction, "hold the handrail."
     
     
    She replied that she did not consider the image, which also featured the word "Careful," to be an obligation. She refused to hold the handrail, and tensions mounted after she also refused to identity herself.
     
     
    She was "taken by force" by the officer and another who had arrived as backup, according to court documents.
     
     
    The officers detained Kosoian for about 30 minutes before letting her go with two tickets — one for $100 for disobeying a pictogram and another for $320 for having obstructed the work of an inspector.
     
     
    She was acquitted of the two infractions in Montreal municipal court in 2012 and subsequently filed a $45,000 lawsuit against the Montreal Transit Corp., the City of Laval and one of the officers, Fabio Camacho.
     
     
    Her suit was rejected by Quebec court in 2015 and by the Quebec Court of Appeal in 2017, which said Kosoian was the "author of her own misfortune."
     
     
    It will now be up to the country's high court to settle the matter.
     
     
    "This is excellent news," said Kosoian's lawyer, Aymar Missakila. He said the Court of Appeal ruling created a dangerous precedent.
     
     
    "A police officer who has a sincere but false belief that a law exists and decides to punish a party on the basis of this law could be exonerated of all responsibility .... It goes squarely against important principles of law," he said.
     
     
    In the Court of Appeal decision, Justice Julie Dutil wrote that the officer "had reasonable grounds to believe that an infraction had been committed," which justified his decision to fine Kosoian and arrest her "because she had refused to identify herself."
     
     
    In a dissenting opinion, Justice Mark Schrager wrote that the officer's "honest but false belief" she had committed an infraction was not enough to clear him of responsibility.
     
     
    He concluded the pictogram was "a warning," and someone who saw it was under no "obligation to hold the handrail at risk of receiving a fine."
     
     
    Neither the Montreal Transit Corp. nor the City of Laval was immediately available to comment on the Supreme Court's decision to hear the case.

    MORE International ARTICLES

    Mixing Business And Family: Justin Trudeau Turns To Singapore Ancestors To Widen Trade

    SINGAPORE — Slowly strolling along a paved walkway, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau looked around Fort Canning and came face-to-face with his history.

    Mixing Business And Family: Justin Trudeau Turns To Singapore Ancestors To Widen Trade

    China Says Butt Out; Canada Calls For Release Of 'Arbitrarily' Detained Muslims

    China Says Butt Out; Canada Calls For Release Of 'Arbitrarily' Detained Muslims
    OTTAWA — Canada stood firm against Chinese criticism Thursday after the Trudeau government rallied more than a dozen countries in expressing concern to Beijing about its jailing of hundreds of thousands of its Muslim minority.

    China Says Butt Out; Canada Calls For Release Of 'Arbitrarily' Detained Muslims

    Don't Sign USMCA Until LGBTQ Language Excised, U.S. Lawmakers Urge Trump

    Don't Sign USMCA Until LGBTQ Language Excised, U.S. Lawmakers Urge Trump
    WASHINGTON — Conservative members of Congress are urging President Donald Trump to not sign the U.S.-Mexico-Canada Agreement because of its protections for LGBTQ rights.

    Don't Sign USMCA Until LGBTQ Language Excised, U.S. Lawmakers Urge Trump

    21-Yr-Old Punjab Youth ABHI BRAR Found Dead In Unites States

    His Parents Also Live In Canton Township Of Michigan But He Used To Live In A Paying Guest (Pg) Accommodation Near The Campus.

    21-Yr-Old Punjab Youth ABHI BRAR Found Dead In Unites States

    India Best Trade Negotiators: Donald Trump At White House Diwali Celebrations

    India "Best" Trade Negotiators: Trump At White House Diwali Celebrations Along with nearly two dozen top Indian American officials of his Administration, present in the room with President Trump was his daughter Ivanaka Trump. 

    India Best Trade Negotiators: Donald Trump At White House Diwali Celebrations

    Er... No Hindus? Twitter Calls Out Donald Trump On Diwali Post - WATCH

    US President Donald Trump's tweet calling Diwali a "holiday observed by Buddhists, Sikhs and Jains" have started a raging twitter storm over his apparent omission of Hindus, the members of the first and largest religion to observe it.

    Er... No Hindus? Twitter Calls Out Donald Trump On Diwali Post - WATCH

    PrevNext