Close X
Monday, November 11, 2024
ADVT 
International

Pennsylvania Fines Uber $11Million For Operating Without Approval

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 21 Apr, 2016 11:44 AM
    HARRISBURG, Pa. — Pennsylvania regulators fined Uber $11.4 million on Thursday — a record for the utility commission — for operating for six months in 2014 without the required approval. The company said it would appeal.
     
    The Public Utility Commission, which also regulates buses and taxis, voted 3-2 for a penalty that was considerably lower than the $50 million fine recommended by a pair of administrative law judges in November.
     
    Commissioners who voted for it justified the lower amount because they said the ride-hailing company has modified its practices to comply with state rules and has not generated many consumer complaints while operating under emergency and experimental authority.
     
    San Francisco-based Uber Technologies, Inc. drew criticism from the judges last year for continuing to operate a month after being issued a cease-and-desist order and for what were described as obstructive actions during the investigation. Commissioners John Coleman and Gladys Brown said the company's actions warranted punishment.
     
    "It must be recognized that Uber has deliberately engaged in the most unprecedented series of wilful violations of commission orders and regulations in the history of this agency," they said in proposing the smaller fine. "A record number of proven violations should be expected to result in a record setting fine."
     
     
    The two commissioners who voted no said the fine was excessive compared to the commission's past actions. Its previous record fine was $1.8 million over an electric generation supplier's handling of a guaranteed savings plan for customers.
     
    Uber spokesman Jason Post said the company was "shocked" by the fine amount, adding Uber's actions did not harm anyone and the commission "subsequently approved the same operations."
     
    Other cases with large fines, said commissioner Pamela Witmer, "involved incidents of serious bodily injury, fatalities, significant property damage and/or patterns of unsafe business practices that jeopardized public safety." She called for "a more measured and reasonable outcome."
     
    Commissioner Robert Powelson, the other no vote, said he would have preferred a $2.5 million fine.
     
    "When Uber launched its operations in Pennsylvania, they were operating in a legally grey area," Powelson said. "The commission should take this into account."
     
    The two judges wrote in November that Uber had argued it was providing needed alternatives, it used a broker license held by a subsidiary and there was no proof that harm occurred.
     
     
    Uber was fined more than $7 million in January for failing to provide sufficient information to California regulators.

    MORE International ARTICLES

    Ontario Judge Approves $20.6m Settlement In Scotiabank Overtime Class-action Suit

    Judge Edward Belobaba of the Ontario Superior Court approved the settlement Thursday, with written reasons to follow in the coming weeks

    Ontario Judge Approves $20.6m Settlement In Scotiabank Overtime Class-action Suit

    Turkish Court Sentences 2 Men In Death Of Migrant Boy Alan Kurdi

    Turkish Court Sentences 2 Men In Death Of Migrant Boy Alan Kurdi
    The court in the Aegean resort of Bodrum convicted the two of human trafficking but acquitted them of the charge of causing the drowning deaths through deliberate negligence, the agency said.

    Turkish Court Sentences 2 Men In Death Of Migrant Boy Alan Kurdi

    Bill Would Make California 2nd State With Smoking Age Of 21

    Bill Would Make California 2nd State With Smoking Age Of 21
    California lawmakers on Thursday revived a stalled effort to make the nation's most populous state one of two to raise the smoking age to 21.

    Bill Would Make California 2nd State With Smoking Age Of 21

    Indian American Woman Manisha Nagrani Arrested For Skimming Funds For Blood Cancer

    Indian American Woman Manisha Nagrani Arrested For Skimming Funds For Blood Cancer
    Manisha Nagrani, 40, tried to raise funds by unwittingly linking her fake appeal to the fundraising site Giving Forward

    Indian American Woman Manisha Nagrani Arrested For Skimming Funds For Blood Cancer

    US Bans Use Of E-Cigarettes Banned On Airline Flights

    Electronic cigarettes are prohibited on any domestic or foreign airline flying to, from or within the United States under a final rule the government issued Wednesday.

    US Bans Use Of E-Cigarettes Banned On Airline Flights

    PM Justin Trudeau Intends To Steer Clear Of A Contentious Topic During U.S. Visit: Donald Trump

    PM Justin Trudeau Intends To Steer Clear Of A Contentious Topic During U.S. Visit: Donald Trump
    The prime minister feels very strongly about this — he doesn't get involved in domestic politics,

    PM Justin Trudeau Intends To Steer Clear Of A Contentious Topic During U.S. Visit: Donald Trump