Close X
Wednesday, December 18, 2024
ADVT 
International

Oxford Graduate Loses Legal Bid Against His Varsity Over Poor Teaching

IANS, 08 Feb, 2018 11:43 AM
    A former Oxford University student, believed to be of Indian-origin, has lost his claim of one million pounds in damages from the prestigious institution for its alleged poor teaching in his specialist Indian subject.
     
     
    Faiz Siddiqui had sued the varsity after 17 years, in last November, claiming that he received “inadequate” teaching on his specialist course on Indian imperial history, which led to him getting a 2:1 back in 2000 and compromised his earnings in the job market as a high-flying lawyer.
     
     
    But a judge dismissed the case this week, saying the 39- year-old may have “simply coasted” during his course and offered him “sympathy and understanding”.
     
     
    “It is to be hoped that he can re-focus, perhaps lower his expectations at least for the time being and start using his undoubted intelligence to create a worthwhile future for himself,” Justice Foskett said in his ruling.
     
     
    Lawyers for Siddiqui, who studied modern history at Brasenose College, had argued that the second-class degree meant a loss of earnings in his future career as a lawyer. 
     
     
    They had also claimed that missing out on a first-class degree had led to a rejection from the Harvard Law School and affected his mental health and career.
     
     
     
     
    While the judge accepted the claimant had suffered severe depression, he felt it could not be attributed to his degree result.
     
     
    He also found there were other reasons beyond his bouts of depression to explain his failure to hold down various jobs he had with leading legal and accountancy firms in the UK.
     
     
    In one case, his employers had complained of “poor behaviour, rudeness and lack of IT skills”.
     
     
    “There is nothing at any point to suggest that what is said to have been his preoccupation with his Oxford degree result played any part in these false starts,” the judge noted.
     
     
    He said that it was possible that Siddiqui simply got over-anxious during the examination process.  “However, anxiety producing a less than otherwise merited result is not an unfamiliar examination scenario generally nor, in his case, is it the fault or responsibility of his teachers,” Justice Foskett said.
     
     
    Siddiqui had claimed that he was the “victim of poor teaching” due to staff being absent on sabbatical leave.
     
     
    Oxford University had accepted there was fewer teaching staff available in the autumn term in 1999 due to staff being granted leave of absence but denied the teaching standards were “inadequate”.
     
     
    The judge accepted that view and said students must not use the courts to settle grievances about their university education.
    There may be “some rare cases” where compensation is due for the inadequacy of the tuition, “but it is hardly the ideal way of achieving redress,” the judge warned.
     
     
    The university had applied to the High Court to strike out the claim for damages but a judge had ruled last year that Oxford University had a case to answer and that the arguments should be heard at a trial, which concluded in last November.
     
     
    This week’s judgment will come as some relief for educational institutions fearing similar claims by students unsatisfied with the teaching they receive. 

    MORE International ARTICLES

    Indian-Origin Man Charged With Stabbing His Wife In Singapore

    Indian-Origin Man Charged With Stabbing His Wife In Singapore
    A 29-year-old Indian-origin man was charged at a court here on Monday with stabbing his wife using a knife with a 10-cm-long blade.

    Indian-Origin Man Charged With Stabbing His Wife In Singapore

    Vice Suspends 2 Top Execs After Sexual Misconduct Report

    Vice Suspends 2 Top Execs After Sexual Misconduct Report
    Vice Media has suspended its president, Andrew Creighton, and chief digital officer Mike Germano, as it investigates allegations against them, according to a company memo sent to employees Tuesday. A Vice spokesman declined to comment.

    Vice Suspends 2 Top Execs After Sexual Misconduct Report

    After Calling Pakistan Full Of 'Lies And Deceit' Tweet Trump Blocks USD 255 Million Military Aid

    After Calling Pakistan Full Of 'Lies And Deceit' Tweet Trump Blocks USD 255 Million Military Aid
    The United States has suspended its USD 255 million military aid to Pakistan for now, the White House has confirmed, saying the fate of such assistance will depend on Islamabad’s response to terrorism on its soil.

    After Calling Pakistan Full Of 'Lies And Deceit' Tweet Trump Blocks USD 255 Million Military Aid

    2017’s Aww-dorable Proposals That Went Viral

    2017’s Aww-dorable Proposals That Went Viral
    Thinking of popping the question? These men in 2017 have set the bar high so let's look back at few heartwarming wedding proposals of the year.

    2017’s Aww-dorable Proposals That Went Viral

    B.C. Police Investigate Third Deadly 'Targeted' Shooting Within Days

    B.C. Police Investigate Third Deadly 'Targeted' Shooting Within Days
    A 24-year-old man is dead in what British Columbia police say is the third such targeted shooting within a week.

    B.C. Police Investigate Third Deadly 'Targeted' Shooting Within Days

    Surrey RCMP Looking For Man Who Escaped Police Custody While In Hospital

    Surrey RCMP Looking For Man Who Escaped Police Custody While In Hospital
    RCMP in Surrey, B.C., are searching for a man who managed to give his police guard the slip and escape from a Metro Vancouver hospital while still wearing handcuffs.

    Surrey RCMP Looking For Man Who Escaped Police Custody While In Hospital