Close X
Monday, November 25, 2024
ADVT 
International

Opponents Take Aim At U.S. West Coast Crude-by-Rail Projects In The Works

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 23 Aug, 2015 12:20 PM
    CALGARY — To crude producers hankering for a route to market while pipeline proposals stall, a bevy of crude-by-rail projects planned on the U.S. West Coast may look enticing.
     
    But efforts to connect trainloads of crude to refineries and marine terminals in Washington, Oregon and California aren't having an easy time of it either.
     
    Big environmental organizations and small community groups have been teaming up to fight rail projects in various stages of development in the region. Among the concerns is the prospect of more Alberta bitumen, derided as "dirty" in some quarters, coming to the area by rail.
     
    "We're as much of a green enclave as you're going to get in North America," said Matt Krogh, a ForestEthics campaigner based in Washington state.
     
    "There's some real cognitive dissonance around allowing the expansion of a dirty and polluting industry in your backyard that makes no long-term economic sense." 
     
    Some of the concerns centre on local safety. The Lac-Megantic disaster two years ago, in which a crude-laden train exploded and killed 47 people, is still fresh in many minds.
     
    But the larger implications of enabling more fossil fuel development and what that means for climate change is also playing a role in the debate.
     
    The broad issue of shipping resources from the U.S. West Coast — whether that be coal, oil or liquefied natural gas — raises an "identity question," said Eric de Place, with the Seattle-based think-tank Sightline Institute.
     
    "There's a lot of anxiety about that," he said.
     
    A focal point of campaigns has been a $210-million project pitched by Tesoro Refining and Marketing LLC and Savage Energy for Vancouver, Wash.
     
    The Tesoro-Savage project, dubbed Vancouver Energy, is the largest on the table, with a planned capacity of up to 360,000 barrels a day. That alone is more than 40 per cent of the proposed Keystone XL pipeline, which has been waiting for U.S. regulatory approval for nearly seven years.
     
    The idea is to bring in North American crude by train and then send it by ship to refineries along the West Coast, which have been relying on overseas imports to meet half their needs as production in Alaska and California declines. Vancouver Energy says the project would reduce the West Coat's reliance on foreign crude by 30 per cent.
     
    Tesoro spokeswoman Jennifer Minx said the terminal is set up to handle crude mostly from the Bakken formation, centred on North Dakota and stretching into parts of Saskatchewan, rather than heavy crude, like that from the oilsands.  
     
    She cited a poll by DHM Research that suggests 69 per cent of Clark County respondents support the project because of its economic benefits and contribution to energy security.
     
    "The Vancouver Energy terminal will be a modern, purpose-built facility with strict safety and environmental protections in its design and operating procedures. We actively work with our partners to make sure the entire supply chain is operating safely," Minx said.
     
    The Washington State Energy Facility Site Evaluation council is expected to release a draft environmental impact statement for public review in November — four months later than previously expected.
     
    Brett VandenHeuvel, executive director of Columbia Riverkeeper, said he's hopeful crude trainloads can be stopped.  
     
    "If you asked me a year ago, I might have had a different answer but there's been unprecedented opposition to it," he said. "It's not just conservation groups. It's pretty diverse and broad scale concerns about these projects."
     
    As for how much oilsands crude may make it to the U.S. West Coast by rail, a lot will have to do with weather pipelines to the British Columbia coast come to fruition, said Sightline's de Place. If not, rail to the Pacific may become more popular.
     
    Kinder Morgan's plan to nearly triple the capacity of its Trans Mountain pipeline from Edmonton to the Vancouver area is being weighed by the National Energy Board. Enbridge Inc.'s Northern Gateway proposal to Kitimat, B.C., has regulatory approval, but the company has not officially decided whether to build it.
     
    Then there's the question of whether the pricey crude-by-rail option is worth it, with crude prices are at their lowest levels since 2009, de Place said.
     
    "I guess my message to the Alberta producers would be: good luck. You're going to need it."

    MORE International ARTICLES

    Indian High Commissioner To New Zealand Recalled After Wife Accused Of Assaulting Cook

    Indian High Commissioner To New Zealand Recalled After Wife Accused Of Assaulting Cook
    India on Saturday asked its envoy in New Zealand to return following allegations that his wife assaulted a member of the domestic staff.

    Indian High Commissioner To New Zealand Recalled After Wife Accused Of Assaulting Cook

    Obama Praises Nikki Haley For Lead On Confederate Flag Issue

    Obama Praises Nikki Haley For Lead On Confederate Flag Issue
    President Barack Obama praised South Carolina's Indian-American governor Nikki Haley for calling for the removal of slavery era Confederate flag from the State Capitol grounds 150 years after the end of the US Civil War.

    Obama Praises Nikki Haley For Lead On Confederate Flag Issue

    Indian-Origin US Envoy Richard Verma Recalls Troubles Of 'A Minus' In School Report Card

    Indian-Origin US Envoy Richard Verma Recalls Troubles Of 'A Minus' In School Report Card
    Verma said his father graduated from DAV College in Jalandhar, Punjab, over 60 years ago, before migrating to the US to teach

    Indian-Origin US Envoy Richard Verma Recalls Troubles Of 'A Minus' In School Report Card

    Terror Attacks On 3 Continents: One Beheaded In France, Terror Attacks In Kuwait, Tunisia Kill 62

    Terror Attacks On 3 Continents: One Beheaded In France, Terror Attacks In Kuwait, Tunisia Kill 62
    A man was beheaded and several others injured on Friday in a suspected Islamist attack on a gas factory in Isere, in the Rhone-Alps region of France, which was declared a "terrorist" act by President Francois Hollande, media reports said.

    Terror Attacks On 3 Continents: One Beheaded In France, Terror Attacks In Kuwait, Tunisia Kill 62

    #BobbyJindalisSoWhite: De-Hyphenated Piyush 'Bobby' Jindal Causes A Twitter Storm In India

    #BobbyJindalisSoWhite: De-Hyphenated Piyush 'Bobby' Jindal Causes A Twitter Storm In India
    Louisiana's Indian-American Governor Bobby Jindal has found himself in the eye of a twitter storm ever since he kicked off his US presidential campaign distancing himself from his Indian heritage.

    #BobbyJindalisSoWhite: De-Hyphenated Piyush 'Bobby' Jindal Causes A Twitter Storm In India

    Wales Man Held Guilty Of Trying To Kill Sikh Dentist Sarandev Bhambra

    Wales Man Held Guilty Of Trying To Kill Sikh Dentist Sarandev Bhambra
    Zack Davies, 26, of Chester Street in Mold, told the court that he never intended to kill Sarandev Bhambra, 24, when he launched his hammer and machete attack, Mirror online reported.

    Wales Man Held Guilty Of Trying To Kill Sikh Dentist Sarandev Bhambra