Close X
Friday, November 1, 2024
ADVT 
International

Northerners Press Trudeau On Electoral Reform; Pm Admits 'I Turned My Back'

The Canadian Press, 11 Feb, 2017 02:18 PM
    YELLOWKNIFE — Now is no time to be provoking political instability in Canada, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said Friday as he justified turning his back — his words — on his unequivocal promise to change the way Canadians elect their federal government.
     
    Trudeau, travelling through the Arctic on a so-called "listening tour" of town hall meetings and photo-ops, has been confronted repeatedly by people who want to discuss why he's no longer committed to electoral reform.
     
    "It is because I felt it was not in the best interests of our country and of our future that I turned my back on that promise," Trudeau said Friday when asked by a member of the audience about why he abandoned the plan.
     
    "I know people will be disappointed, yep," he continued as a smattering of boos rose up from the crowd.
     
    "But this was my choice to make, and I chose to make it with full consequence of the cost that is possibly going to come (from) it, but I will not compromise on what is in the best interests of Canada. That's what Canadians elected me for."
     
    In Iqaluit on Thursday, he evoked the controversy surrounding Conservative leadership hopeful Kellie Leitch and her stated plan to screen recent immigrants for so-called "anti-Canadian values" as one possible danger.
     
     
    The following day in Yellowknife, Trudeau didn't mention Leitch by name, but he did double down on the notion that an electoral system like proportional representation would give too much parliamentary power to fringe elements.
     
     "If we were to make a change or risk a change that would augment individual voices, that would augment extremist voices and activist voices ... I think we'd be entering an era of instability and uncertainty," Trudeau said.
     
    "We'd be putting at risk the very thing that makes us luckier than anyone else on the planet: the fact that we look at our differences as something to draw on and discover and build on, as opposed to emphasize and highlight."
     
    He went on: in a nutshell, while he has a responsibility to keep his promises, he has a greater responsibility to keep the country together.
     
    "As strongly and as passionately as I believed we could move forward on improving our electoral system ... I recognize a higher responsibility even than that, and that is the responsibility every Canadian prime minister has to keep this country together and united."
     
    As opposed to first-past-the-post, an electoral system in which the first party to win a majority of the seats gets to form a government, proportional representation is designed to more accurately reflect the results of the popular vote.
     
    Eli Purchase, a candidate for the Green party in 2011 and the one who asked Trudeau about electoral reform on Friday, said he disagrees with Trudeau's assessment.
     
     
    "Proportional representation works," Purchase said. "We know it works, based on other proportional representation governments around the world, and anything against it is just a deflection."
     
    A ranked ballot would be far better than the current first-past-the-post system, Purchase added.
     
    Trudeau promised — during the 2015 election campaign, in the Liberal government's first throne speech and several times since — that he would change the way Canadians cast ballots in federal elections in time for 2019.
     
    His newly appointed minister of democratic institutions, Karina Gould, was dispatched to abandon the promise formally last week.
     
    Trudeau dropped Leitch's name in Iqaluit when confronted by a woman who wanted to know why he did not believe a system of proportional representation should replace the existing first-past-the-post voting system.
     
    "Do you think that Kellie Leitch should have her own party?" Trudeau was heard to say.
     
    "Because if you have a party that represents the fringe voices ... or the periphery of our perspectives and they hold 10, 15, 20 seats in the House, they end up holding the balance of power."
     
    Trudeau was also heard to say that the federal New Democrats had been unwilling to budge on the idea of proportional representation. During question period Friday, New Democrat MP Murray Rankin accused him of "spreading alternative facts."
     
    "Do the Liberals not understand that blaming everyone else for their broken promises is exactly what breeds cynicism in politics?" Rankin said.
     
    During the Yellowknife town hall, Trudeau said that holding a national referendum would foment discord and disunity at a time when the forces of nationalism and populism are whipsawing governments and countries across the globe.
     
     
    A referendum would spark "division" and "a campaign that's going to get a lot of heated rhetoric at a time where we're looking for stability in the face of a very unpredictable and unstable political context around the world," Trudeau said.
     
    "I don't think a referendum is the way to go."  

    MORE International ARTICLES

    Sikh Girl, Kiranmeet Kaur Jassal, To Represent Malaysia In Miss Universe Contest

    Sikh Girl, Kiranmeet Kaur Jassal, To Represent Malaysia In Miss Universe Contest
    She idolises  Aishwarya Rai and Sushmita Sen, who won Miss World and Miss Universe in 1994, respectively.

    Sikh Girl, Kiranmeet Kaur Jassal, To Represent Malaysia In Miss Universe Contest

    Donald Trump Raises Business Issues That Could Impact India

    Donald Trump Raises Business Issues That Could Impact India
      Nine days before he is to be sworn as the 45th US President, Trump spoke of his plans to stem the flow of manufacturing from America and took aim at the pharmaceutical sector. 

    Donald Trump Raises Business Issues That Could Impact India

    Ontario's Indo-Canadians To Mark India's 68th Republic Day

    Ontario's Indo-Canadians To Mark India's 68th Republic Day
      Panorama India has been hosting this event for the last several years to promote India's cultures and heritage, reported Mississauga online daily on Wednesday.

    Ontario's Indo-Canadians To Mark India's 68th Republic Day

    Indian American Harish Jajoo Seeking Reelection of Sugar Land City Council Seat

    Indian American Harish Jajoo Seeking Reelection of Sugar Land City Council Seat
    Indian American Harish Jajoo, a City Councilman in Texas, is seeking re-election for the post for a fourth term.

    Indian American Harish Jajoo Seeking Reelection of Sugar Land City Council Seat

    Nikki Haley's Confirmation Hearing For US Envoy To UN Next Week

    Nikki Haley's Confirmation Hearing For US Envoy To UN Next Week
    If confirmed, Nikki Haley, would be first-ever Indian-American to serve on a Cabinet rank position.

    Nikki Haley's Confirmation Hearing For US Envoy To UN Next Week

    Donald Trump Says He Will Be Greatest Jobs Producer That God Ever Created

    Donald Trump Says He Will Be Greatest Jobs Producer That God Ever Created
    "We're the largest buyer of drugs in the world and yet we don't bid properly and we're going to start bidding and we're going to save billions of dollars over a period of time," he said.

    Donald Trump Says He Will Be Greatest Jobs Producer That God Ever Created