Close X
Tuesday, December 3, 2024
ADVT 
International

'Death By A Thousand Cuts:' Memo To PM Questions Across-the-board Budget Cuts

The Canadian Press , 26 Nov, 2014 11:26 AM
    OTTAWA — Prime Minister Stephen Harper was briefed earlier this year on how across-the-board budget cuts hurt public service morale, productivity and citizen satisfaction.
     
    The memorandum — headlined "Death by a Thousand Cuts: How governments undermine their own productivity" — laid out arguments from an Australian, union-funded study that suggests poorly executed austerity undermines trust and confidence in public institutions.
     
    The Conservative government is on track for a budgetary surplus in 2015 after years of belt-tightening.
     
    Billed as "back office" or administrative cuts by Conservatives, the ongoing austerity measures are supposed to shrink departmental budgets without affecting programs or services — a promise the independent parliamentary budget office has been unable to verify even after taking the government to court in a fruitless effort to get a full public accounting.
     
    But the cumulative impact of all the cuts has begun attracting wider notice.
     
    Military veterans are incensed over the closure of Veterans Affairs offices and lapsed funding, First Nations have learned that funding for critically needed infrastructure has been diverted, transportation safety budgets have been slashed, Coast Guard stations have been closed and services across government — from national parks to access to information — are being squeezed.
     
    In a  Jan. 27 memorandum to the prime minister, obtained under the Access to Information Act, the Clerk of the Privy Council briefed Stephen Harper on how  austerity measures were being assessed in Australia.
     
    "The authors found that prolonged cuts of this nature result in a loss of workforce capability, public sector productivity and innovation, and trust and confidence in public sector institutions," states the memo.
     
    The memo details how public trust is undermined "as programs become less efficient and effective in the wake of across-the-board cuts, and as mistakes and oversights occur."
     
    The study recommends that a better way to trim costs is by using efficiency audits of departments and by engaging staff to find effective and efficient new ways of delivering programs and services.
     
    As the memo summarizes the Australian study, "skills shortages are having a significant impact on government operations, resulting in higher costs for recruitment and training over time, the appointment of more expensive private sector contractors for information technology, and diminished procurement expertise."  
     
    Large portions of the four-page memo are blacked out.
     
    The Prime Minister's Office says it receives many memos and would not comment on the views in the Australian study.
     
    "I will say that our government is proud of the steps we have taken to trim the size of government bureaucracy and ensure that tax dollars are being spent on programs and services that benefit Canadians," spokesman Jason MacDonald said in an email.
     
    The full, 29-page Australian report was attached to the memo. It is rather more unsparing than the overview provided by the Privy Council.
     
    "Increasingly, governments are choosing to take an irresponsible, and ultimately self-defeating, approach to budget savings," says the opening paragraph of the report, prepared by the Centre for Policy Development, a self-described progressive think tank.
     
    "Rather than identifying ineffective programs and undertaking the political hard work of persuading the public of the advisability of cancelling the service, many politicians and parties institute across-the-board cuts .... This allows them to claim credit for budget savings without taking responsibility for service cuts."
     
    The study, based on austerity measures taken by national and regional governments in Australia, notes that politicians habitually claim cuts will be efficient and painless.
     
    "In practice, however, claims that administrative budgets can be cut without affecting services are likely to be made only by politicians who have evaded explicit and responsible government decision-making, or want to evade it, or who are prepared to re-define services in order to evade it."

    MORE International ARTICLES

    MH17 crash: Australia demands compensation from Russia

    MH17 crash: Australia demands compensation from Russia
    Australian Prime Minister Tony Abbott Tuesday held Russia complicit in the downing of the Malaysia Airlines flight MH17 and demanded compensation...

    MH17 crash: Australia demands compensation from Russia

    IS planning to introduce own currency?

    IS planning to introduce own currency?
    The Islamic State (IS) terrorist organisation plans to introduce its own currency and bring back solid gold and silver coins, according to media reports....

    IS planning to introduce own currency?

    Target Offers Early Access To Some Of The Black Friday Deals

    Target Offers Early Access To Some Of The Black Friday Deals
    The Minneapolis-based retailer is kicking off its holiday push with a one-day online sale Monday that will last from noon to midnight Eastern time with nine items that can be ordered online and picked up at stores.

    Target Offers Early Access To Some Of The Black Friday Deals

    Lupita Nyong'o, Laverne Cox, Samantha Power, Robin Roberts To Receive Glamour Magazine Awards

    Lupita Nyong'o, Laverne Cox, Samantha Power, Robin Roberts To Receive Glamour Magazine Awards
    NEW YORK — Actresses Lupita Nyong'o and Laverne Cox, fashion designer Sarah Burton, U.N. Ambassador Samantha Power and Chelsea Clinton are among those being awarded Women of the Year awards by Glamour magazine.

    Lupita Nyong'o, Laverne Cox, Samantha Power, Robin Roberts To Receive Glamour Magazine Awards

    Hundreds Of Kids Poisoned By Detergent Pods; Poison Centres Get Thousands Of Calls

    Hundreds Of Kids Poisoned By Detergent Pods; Poison Centres Get Thousands Of Calls
    CHICAGO — Accidental poisonings from squishy laundry detergent packets sometimes mistaken for toys or candy landed more than 700 U.S. children in the hospital in just two years, researchers report. Coma and seizures were among the most serious complications.

    Hundreds Of Kids Poisoned By Detergent Pods; Poison Centres Get Thousands Of Calls

    Hindus in Pakistan urge PM to prevent atrocities

    Hindus in Pakistan urge PM to prevent atrocities
    The Pakistan Hindu Council has proposed the establishment of an active committee under Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif to prevent atrocities against minorities....

    Hindus in Pakistan urge PM to prevent atrocities