Close X
Sunday, December 15, 2024
ADVT 
International

BBC Withdraws Controversial Immigration Film With South Asian Characters

IANS, 03 Aug, 2018 12:29 PM
  • BBC Withdraws Controversial Immigration Film With South Asian Characters
The BBC has been forced to withdraw a documentary film which had animated images of South Asian characters aimed at making schoolchildren more aware about the country’s immigration debate, it emerged on Friday.
 
 
 
The YouTube video, part of a ‘Don’t Hate the Debate’ series attracted complaints about a particular section which said the debate around immigration had fuelled a “huge rise” in support for far-right politics.
 
 
 
It had animated images of South Asian characters in turbans and women in saris with a voiceover claiming that Britain was “multicultural long before curry and carnival”.
 
 
Migration Watch UK, an immigration research think tank, challenged the “lack of balance” and a number of “factual inaccuracies” in the video, aimed at 14-16-year-olds.
 
 
 
 
Chairman Lord Green wrote to Sir David Clementi, Chairman of the BBC, last month pointing out that the video failed to provide an objective analysis of the immigration debate and therefore did not meet the BBC’s own impartiality guidelines.
 
 
“Net migration to the UK has been running at a quarter of a million per year over the past decade and nearly two-thirds of the public wish to see a reduction. Polling makes clear that most people in the UK are not opposed to immigration per se, but they are concerned (we think rightly) about its present scale, which is surely unsustainable,” the letter said.
 
 
“Yet the overall impression of the video is that anyone who questions its current scale is unreasonable and prejudiced.”     The head of BBC Education responded and said that the BBC would withdraw the video with a view to re-editing it.
 
 
“While we believe the film did convey the broad elements of the immigration debate, we accept further efforts could have been made to involve contributors with a more diverse range of opinions, so we removed the video,” a BBC spokesperson said.
 
 
Lord Green welcomed the decision, adding that: “We have offered the BBC our assistance in producing an accurate and unbiased teaching aid on a very topical and important issue.”  
 
 
The documentary was part of a series of films designed to help teachers enable classroom debates about topical issues. Each film includes a real debate between four young people, all giving views on a particular topic.
 
 
In the immigration-related debate, which has now been withdrawn, the animated characters were heard saying: “Think immigration is a recent thing? Think again.”
 
 
“Because you see, you got the Celts, the Romans, the Anglo-Saxons and the Vikings, the Normans, the Flemish, the Irish, black Britons and Jewish people.”   
 
 
“Yep, we were multicultural long before curry and carnival – it’s in our DNA.” 
 
    
It further highlighted that there is no such thing as “pure Briton”.
 
 
“Despite what some flag wielders would have you believe, the average Briton is only 36 per cent Anglo-Saxon,” it said.
Migration Watch UK countered that percentage, claiming that the average British person’s DNA is “at least 90 per cent European”. 

MORE International ARTICLES

Indian-American Woman Sabrina Singh Is Key Player In Democrats' Offensive Against Trump

Indian-American Woman Sabrina Singh Is Key Player In Democrats' Offensive Against Trump
Sabrina Singh, whose grandfather was instrumental in formulating a historic legislation in 1946 that enacted a quota of 100 Indians to immigrate to the US per year

Indian-American Woman Sabrina Singh Is Key Player In Democrats' Offensive Against Trump

Obama Warns Against Rise Of ‘Strongman Politics’ In Veiled Attack On Trump

Obama Warns Against Rise Of ‘Strongman Politics’ In Veiled Attack On Trump
Former US President Barack Obama on Tuesday made a passionate defense of democracy and warned against the rise of “strongman politics” in a speech marking the 100th birth anniversary of anti-apartheid icon Nelson Mandela, in a veiled attack on his successor Donald Trump.

Obama Warns Against Rise Of ‘Strongman Politics’ In Veiled Attack On Trump

Sikh, Hindu Victims Of Afghan Attack Honoured In Washington

Sikh, Hindu Victims Of Afghan Attack Honoured In Washington
Condemning the terrorist attack on Sikhs and Hindus that killed 18, US Congresswoman Tulsi Gabbard has called for confronting "hatred with love, fear with understanding, and darkness with light".

Sikh, Hindu Victims Of Afghan Attack Honoured In Washington

Indian Student Sharat Koppu Death: Police Confirm Suspect Died In Shootout

Indian Student Sharat Koppu Death: Police Confirm Suspect Died In Shootout
Police in the US have confirmed that the man shot dead in a shootout in Kansas City was the suspect in the killing of Indian student Sharat Koppu, who was from Telangana.

Indian Student Sharat Koppu Death: Police Confirm Suspect Died In Shootout

Kerala Man's Body Found In UAE A Week After He Went Missing

Kerala Man's Body Found In UAE A Week After He Went Missing
An Indian expat who had been missing here for a week was found dead, police said.

Kerala Man's Body Found In UAE A Week After He Went Missing

Creating Job Opportunities From E-Waste: India-Born Australian Scientist Shows The Way

Creating Job Opportunities From E-Waste: India-Born Australian Scientist Shows The Way
The solution uncovering significant economic value in e-dumps is also in line with Prime Minister Narendra Modi's "Swachh Bharat" and "Make in India" campaigns, said Veena Sahajwalla, materials scientist at the University of New South Wales (UNSW) in Sydney.

Creating Job Opportunities From E-Waste: India-Born Australian Scientist Shows The Way