Close X
Sunday, November 17, 2024
ADVT 
India

Why Mysore Beat Chandigarh As India's Cleanest City

Darpan News Desk IANS, 11 Mar, 2016 01:07 PM
    Chandigarh, India’s first planned city -- known for wide roads laid out in geometrical precision and large, green spaces that adorn neatly arranged rectangular neighbourhoods, called sectors -- faces an unlikely problem: How to collect, segregate and dispose its 25 truckloads of solid waste daily.
     
    Chandigarh’s 1.05 million people generate 370 tonnes of solid waste every day. The city employs 4,085 sweepers, which is 2.65 sweepers per km of road.
     
    Mysore, the former royal capital of old Mysore State, won the top spot in the central government’s sanitation survey, Swachh Sarvekshan. The city of 0.89 million people employs half the number of sweepers -- 1.37 sweepers per km -- but handles more solid waste, 410 tonnes, or 27 truck-loads, than Chandigarh. Mysore generates 0.45 kg of garbage per person daily, Chandigarh 0.35 kg.
     
    More than 95 percent of Chandigarh’s population is plugged in to a sewage network, and there are no open drains, entangled mess of overhead wires, narrow approach roads or market areas within residential spaces. It is not a surprise that Chandigarh was ranked second in the sanitation survey but a Chandigarhian might wonder why the city did not finish first.
     
     
    One might not see much garbage lying around in Chandigarh, but that doesn’t imply that it is being disposed off smartly. Having been born and brought up in Chandigarh, I have always found the city to be clean and charming: Small and, relatively, sparsely peopled -- 114 sq km, 9,252 persons per sq km -- alert administration and roads designed for easy cleaning.
     
    Although sanitation standards fall away towards the more densely populated southern part, the system works.
     
    Where Mysore scores is in its greater citizen participation, as a result of ‘Let’s do it Mysore’, a non-government initiative, which consistently involves people in trash segregation. Chandigarh also runs campaigns, especially the Swachh Bharat Abhiyan (Clean India Campaign) in educational institutes and offices, but these are one-time affairs or limited to efforts of certain religious groups.
     
    Mysore segregates its garbage, Chandigarh does not. Of the 370 tonnes waste that Chandigarh produces every day, 270 tonnes goes to a garbage-processing plant run by a company of the Jaypee Group, which makes refuse-derived fuel pellets.
     
    The remaining 100 tonnes goes to a dumping site, beset by sanitary and administrative problems. As with most garbage mountains across India, those who live around Chandigarh suffer its primitive methods.
     
     
     
    The company running it has also threatened to shut the plant if Municipal Corporation Chandigarh (MCC) does not pay a tipping fee -- given by municipalities to private processing plants for collecting and processing waste. The MCC refuses any payment because it transports the waste to the plant.
     
    One solution to reduce the garbage produced is to segregate at source and recycle. Chandigarh does not do either, and this is the main reason why it does not match up to Mysore.
     
    Mysore segregates at source and has nine waste-segregation plants that focus on producing quality manure. The sale of manure and dry waste like plastic adds to the revenue of its municipal corporation.
     
    MCC Joint Commissioner Rajiv Gupta said Chandigarh wanted to segregate its garbage. “We are starting a pilot soon in four sectors for source-based segregation,” he said. “Besides, a five-tonne capacity bio-methanation plant will start operating next month, which will generate electricity from organic waste.”
     
    Chandigarh’s door-to-door garbage collection, initially handled by residents’ welfare associations and NGOs who hired contract labour, is now dominated by a few private contractors.
     
    In 2012, the garbage collectors went on strike when the corporation hired employees on contract for a pilot project. The dispute was resolved by an agreement that restricted contract labour to cleaning markets, but it hampers segregation efforts and forces punitive action.
     
     
    Last year, the MCC issued 3,543 challans (notices) to people found littering in public spaces and earned Rs.6 lakh in fines. Those who refused to pay were prosecuted.

    MORE India ARTICLES

    Five militants killed in Jammu and Kashmir gunfight

    Five militants killed in Jammu and Kashmir gunfight
    Five militants have been killed in an ongoing gunfight between a group of militants and the army in Jammu and Kashmir's Kupwara district, authorities said Wednesday....

    Five militants killed in Jammu and Kashmir gunfight

    Punjab's Traditional Craft Inscribed On UNESCO List

    Punjab's Traditional Craft Inscribed On UNESCO List
    The traditional brass and copper craft of utensil making from Punjab has been inscribed on Unesco's 2014 Representative List of the Intangible Cultural Heritage of Humanity, an official statement said Tuesday.

    Punjab's Traditional Craft Inscribed On UNESCO List

    Punjab police top brass found 'missing' as Sukhbir Badal takes attendance

    Punjab police top brass found 'missing' as Sukhbir Badal takes attendance
    This was one call of duty that the top brass of Punjab Police failed miserably to meet with. Senior police officers were running for cover Tuesday after ....

    Punjab police top brass found 'missing' as Sukhbir Badal takes attendance

    AAP to file criminal case against BJP: Kejriwal

    AAP to file criminal case against BJP: Kejriwal
     The Aam Admi Party (AAP) would file a criminal case against the BJP for levelling baseless allegations against its source of funding, party chief Arvind Kejriwal said Tuesday...

    AAP to file criminal case against BJP: Kejriwal

    BJP minister regrets offensive remark after uproar in parliament

    BJP minister regrets offensive remark after uproar in parliament
    Cornered by a united opposition and isolated within the BJP, union Minister of State for Food Processing Industries Sadhvi Niranjan Jyoti Tuesday expressed....

    BJP minister regrets offensive remark after uproar in parliament

    Kashmiris defy boycott call, winter cold to vote in large numbers

    Kashmiris defy boycott call, winter cold to vote in large numbers
    People defied a boycott call by separatist groups and turned up in large numbers Tuesday to vote in the second of the five-phase assembly elections in Jammu and Kashmir....

    Kashmiris defy boycott call, winter cold to vote in large numbers