Close X
Thursday, November 28, 2024
ADVT 
India

Reality Check: Modi government's media policy - keep them away?

Darpan News Desk Darpan, 20 Jul, 2014 07:15 AM
    It has been almost two months since Narendra Modi took charge as India's prime minister, but the new government is yet to spell out its media and information policy - except by default.
     
    All that journalists are able to surmise - in the absence of any official articulation - is that the Modi government wants to keep members of the fourth estate at an arm's length and feed them information crumbs - only when and what it wants to.
     
    Departing from the convention of naming a media adviser, one of the first acts of any new prime minister in a democracy, Modi has appointed 70-year-old veteran aide, Jagdish Thakkar, as only a Public Relations Officer (PRO), an indication by itself that Modi did not feel the need to have "media advice".
     
    Thakkar, a PRO during Modi's chief ministership in Gujarat and who is familiar with Modi's working style, is increasingly becoming infamous in media circles for not answering calls and, simply, just not being available.
     
    When a group of journalists cornered him at Parliament House recently, Thakkar gave no assurances and said he would only give them what he was asked to give - nothing more. 
     
    He also made no promise of answering journalists' calls or queries, a standard practice of a media or press adviser and part of his job profile.
     
    Modi's council of ministers also believe in evading the media - even those who were earlier friendly with the media and loved chatting with them.
     
    Any journalist seeking an interview with External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj, who was known to be media-savvy and always available for a juicy anti-government byte as Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha, now gets a firm "no" in abrupt and unlikely response.
     
    It is widely known that the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) ministers have been told "not to speak to the media" unless an official line about the government's position is to be announced. 
     
    It was only after he presented his maiden budget July 10 that the otherwise media savvy Finance Minister Arun Jaitley gave interviews, but only to a select few.
     
    Only Law Minister Ravi Shankar Prasad and Information and Broadcasting Minister Prakash Javadekar, both former party spokesmen, are the ones who are seen on television and sometimes quoted in print.
     
    Senior bureaucrats, who under the previous UPA regime were welcoming to scribes, have been issued a gag order and asked not to "entertain" the media.
     
    "I am personally against such an order but cannot do much about it," an official in the urban development ministry told IANS, while making sure he was not going to be named.
     
    In fact, in some ministries, if a mediaperson is seen near a minister's office, in Parliament House, or in the ministries, they are rounded up and packed off.
     
    This was not so during the Manmohan Singh regime.
     
    Ministers and secretaries were ready to talk to mediapersons, give bytes and interviews and, in the last months, even against their own government.
     
    For the media, all this is new. From being treated as VIPs, mediapersons now suddenly feel they are "pariahs" in the new establishment.
     
    With tweets, Facebook and official releases being almost the sole "source" for news stories, many journalists openly share that getting an "exclusive" would now become difficult. It also means that everyone will get the news at the same time.
     
    "No minister is willing to talk. Even taking an appointment to meet the secretary has become extremely difficult. These are not good signs," a seasoned journalist who did not wish to be identified told IANS.
     
    Human Resource Development (HRD) Minister Smriti Irani, who was caught in a controversy over her educational qualification, has been meeting journalists in informal groups. On one such occasion, she pulled them up for writing stories that projected her negatively.
     
    Like her, many of her cabinet colleagues are yet to call a formal press conference to spell out policies and plans for their ministries.
     
    Journalist and commentator Swapan Dasgupta, however, feels it is a "media impression that the council of ministers is avoiding them".
     
    "It is in any case not a public issue. It's a media issue," Dasgupta, known to be close to the ruling establishment, told IANS.
     
    The only formal interaction of the media with any minister was when Javadekar called journalists for dinner July 16. It was also interesting that on the same day and at the same place - India Habitat Centre, but in a different venue - Neelam Kapur, principal director general of the Press Information Bureau (PIB), had also invited senior journalists for dinner.
     
    However, on reaching the venue, journalists were told that the two events had been merged without giving an explanation. But Kapur did look subdued.
     
    Javadekar, when harried by journalists for an interview slot, was evasive. But journalists who hoped he would share information nuggets about the new regime, or the prime minister, were disappointed.
     
    The writing on the wall is clear - avoid the media so that they do not have anything to sensationalise or create controversies.
     
    Modi, who has stopped taking a large press party on his trips abroad and only takes official or demi-official media, may feel that keeping the media at a distance is the best media policy to have. 
     
    Veteran journalist Kuldip Nayar, who was the media adviser to late prime minister Lal Bahadur Shastri, feels the Modi administration should follow a clear media policy. 
     
    "The channels of communication should be open. The new government should have a transparent media policy. Media wants some kind of connection," Nayar told IANS.

    MORE India ARTICLES

    Girls below 18 victims in most Delhi rapes

    Girls below 18 victims in most Delhi rapes
    Girls below 18 years of age have been the victims in most of the rape cases in the national capital and the majority of such cases have happened in residences or involved friends and acquaintances, says a study by Delhi Police.

    Girls below 18 victims in most Delhi rapes

    No bed for ailing African woman at AIIMS

    No bed for ailing African woman at AIIMS
    Martha Susan Kabura (51) has come all the way from Kenya to India's premiere institute, AIIMS, hoping for a cure for her fatal ailment. But for the past week, she has been camping outside the hospital - in the sweltering

    No bed for ailing African woman at AIIMS

    Uproar in India: Baba Ramdev's aide meets Most Wanted Terrorist Hafiz Saeed

    Uproar in India: Baba Ramdev's aide meets Most Wanted Terrorist Hafiz Saeed
    Yoga guru Ramdev's close aide Ved Pratap Vaidik's meeting with 26/11 Mumbai attack mastermind Hafiz Saeed in Pakistan sparked off a major row Monday with the Congress seeking to pin down the Narendra Modi government by asking if he was sent as an emissary even as the ruling BJP distanced itself from the meeting, asserting Saeed was a "terrorist".

    Uproar in India: Baba Ramdev's aide meets Most Wanted Terrorist Hafiz Saeed

    Akali Dal leaders to meet president over Haryana SGPC

    Akali Dal leaders to meet president over Haryana SGPC
    Leaders of Punjab's ruling Shiromani Akali Dal will meet President Pranab Mukherjee soon to protest against the recent bill passed by the Haryana assembly under which a new Haryana Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee (HSGPC) would be set up to manage gurdwaras in Haryana.

    Akali Dal leaders to meet president over Haryana SGPC

    Haryana SGPC move illegal, Congress wants to divide Sikhs: Badal

    Haryana SGPC move illegal, Congress wants to divide Sikhs: Badal
    Punjab Chief Minister Parkash Singh Badal Saturday termed the move of the Bhupinder Singh Hooda-led Haryana government to set up a separate committee for managing Sikh shrines in the state "illegal and patently wrong" as well as "politically motivated".

    Haryana SGPC move illegal, Congress wants to divide Sikhs: Badal

    SGPC vs HSGPC: Is Hooda's Haryana Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee illegal

    SGPC vs HSGPC: Is Hooda's Haryana Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee illegal
    For Haryana Chief Minister Bhupinder Singh Hooda, the passing of the Haryana Sikh Gurdwaras (Management) Bill, which paves the way for a separate body for Haryana's gurdwaras, may have been a cakewalk Friday but this has to overcome hurdles with serious legal and political implications.

    SGPC vs HSGPC: Is Hooda's Haryana Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee illegal