Close X
Friday, September 20, 2024
ADVT 
India

Rajya Sabha Discusses JNU, Vemula; Smriti Irani's Reply Cut Short

Darpan News Desk IANS, 25 Feb, 2016 11:11 AM
    Functioning for nearly the whole day after a long time, the Rajya Sabha on Thursday witnessed an intense debate on the recent incidents in JNU and Dalit scholar Rohith Vemula's suicide, even as HRD Minister Smriti Irani's reply was cut short due to protests which lead to its adjournment for the day.
     
    As the house saw proceedings without any disruptions due to protests, the debate saw several heated-up moments, where the treasury and opposition members engaged in fierce arguments.
     
    Taking on the opposition over their criticisms, Irani, the human resource development minister, said she is called the "anpadh mantri" (illiterate minister).
     
    "I do not claim I am as erudite a speaker as (CPI-M general secretary Sitaram) Mr. Yechury. But since people blame me for having a flair for drama, let me quote from 'Macbeth' and say "fair is foul and foul is fair" that is how 'Macbeth' began indicating that nothing is as it seems," she said starting her reply to the short duration discussion.
     
    She even said that she has been cautioned over getting agitated.
     
    "I have been cautioned, Smriti don't get agitated," the minister said.
     
    Defending the government actions, Irani said it was not the first time police entered the Jawaharlal Nehru University campus.
     
    She also said that she talked to Vemula's mother often, but people don't know about it.
     
     
    However, touching upon the JNU issue, Irani referred to "Mahishasur Martyrdom Day" observed in JNU, when the scene got ugly.
     
    As she read out a document on Mahishasur Puja, referring to the demon slain by the goddess Durga, which she said came from JNU, it created a huge uproar among the opposition.
     
    "When they went to JNU they wanted insult of gods and goddesses be within freedom of speech. What was the need for (Congress vice president) Rahul Gandhi to accept such insult of gods," Irani said amid ruckus in the house, leading to its adjournment for the day.
     
    The debate, which was started by Communist Party of India-Marxist's (CPI-M) Yechury, saw opposition parties condemning the police action in the JNU incident, and violence at Patiala House court, as well a the circumstances around the suicide of Vemula, following his suspension from the University of Hyderabad.
     
    Yechury accused the NDA government of attempting to turn India into a Hindu Rashtra and demanded that a house committee probe the issues arising out of the unrest in JNU, Hyderabad University and other institutions.
     
    The government's undue "interference which is not sanctioned by the law" in the working of the educational institutions is aimed at promoting their agenda of Hindu Rashtra, he said while initiating a debate on the issue.
     
    "It's an effort to replace secular India with a Hindu nation," he said.
     
    Finance Minister Arun Jaitley, meanwhile said the government agreed that there should be freedom in universities, but questioned how can "vandalism" be condemned while "sedition" is called free speech.
     
    "What happened in Patiala House (court) is condemnable. But vandalism is condemnable, and sedition is free speech? Nobody can subscribe to this ideology and least of all should Congress party subscribe to this ideology," Jaitley said, intervening in the debate.
     
     
    His reference to "vandalism" was to the incidents on February 15 of some students and media persons being roughed up at Patiala House courts complex where Jawaharlal Nehru University Students' Union president Kanhaiya Kumar, arrested for sedition, was being presented before a judge.
     
    "Of course vandalism should be condemned," Jaitley said.
     
    "We all know what (executed parliament attack convict) Afzal Guru represented... He was not protesting against 'Manuvaad',' capitalism', or 'Brahmanism' that they will raise slogans against Manuvaad and capitalism on his martyrdom day," the minister said, referring to the event organised on February 9 at the JNU where anti-national slogans were allegedly raised.
     
    BJP's Bhupendra Yadav said that what has been happening in the JNU is not "freedom of expression" but "expression of freedom from India", referring to campus events where students allegedly voiced support for Kashmiri separatists.
     
    "Freedom of expression is there in the constitution. But what happened in JNU, was it freedom of expression or expression of freedom from the country? Was it freedom of speech or speech for freedom?" he asked.

    MORE India ARTICLES

    Will She, Won't She? Kashmir In Suspense Over Mehbooba

    Will She, Won't She? Kashmir In Suspense Over Mehbooba
    What is holding back PDP leader Mehbooba Mufti from taking oath as Jammu and Kashmir's new chief minister? More and more people are asking this but there seems to be no clear answer.

    Will She, Won't She? Kashmir In Suspense Over Mehbooba

    Congress Names Ramanjit Singh Sikki As Candidate For Khadoor Sahib Assembly Bypoll In Punjab

    Congress Names Ramanjit Singh Sikki As Candidate For Khadoor Sahib Assembly Bypoll In Punjab
    The Congress on Tuesday named former legislator Ramanjit Singh Sikki as its candidate for the by-election to the Punjab legislative assembly from Khadoor Sahib constituency.

    Congress Names Ramanjit Singh Sikki As Candidate For Khadoor Sahib Assembly Bypoll In Punjab

    Did The British Empire Have Any Benefits For India? No, Says Shashi Tharoor

    Tharoor contested the contentions of co-panellist, British historian, author and MP Tristram Hunt, that the benefits included rule of law and an effective parliamentary system, saying he was not sure how good the latter has been for India.

    Did The British Empire Have Any Benefits For India? No, Says Shashi Tharoor

    Arvind Kejriwal Slams President's Rule In Arunachal Pradesh

    Arvind Kejriwal Slams President's Rule In Arunachal Pradesh
    Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal on Tuesday criticised imposition of President's rule in Arunachal Pradesh, invoking BJP veteran L.K. Advani's concern about "emergency-like conditions" in the country.

    Arvind Kejriwal Slams President's Rule In Arunachal Pradesh

    Women Barred From Going To Maharashtra Shani Temple, Call It 'Black Day'

    Women Barred From Going To Maharashtra Shani Temple, Call It 'Black Day'
    Women were on Tuesday barred by police from proceeding towards the famous Shani Shingnapur Temple here to offer prayers, as they sought to defy the centuries-old tradition at the temple against entry of women.

    Women Barred From Going To Maharashtra Shani Temple, Call It 'Black Day'

    After Roti Bank, A 'Kapda Bank' Opened In Maharashtra's Aurangabad

    After Roti Bank, A 'Kapda Bank' Opened In Maharashtra's Aurangabad
    After launching a 'Roti Bank' here last month, the Haron Mukati Islamic Centre on Tuesday inaugurated a 'Kapda Bank' intended to provides clothes to the poorest of poor.

    After Roti Bank, A 'Kapda Bank' Opened In Maharashtra's Aurangabad