Close X
Sunday, January 12, 2025
ADVT 
India

Rafale Papers Stolen From Defence Ministry, Govt Tells Supreme Court

Darpan News Desk IANS, 06 Mar, 2019 08:47 PM

    As the Supreme Court on Wednesday began hearing review petitions on the Rafale jet deal, the central government told the court that Rafale papers were stolen from the defence ministry.

     

    The Supreme Court, which is hearing petitions seeking review of its December 2018 verdict refusing to order a probe into the Rafale fighter jets deal, has put off hearing in the case until March 14.


    The Centre took a strong exception to advocate Prashant Bhushan reading out from “secret” documents in the Supreme Court. Attorney General KK Venugopal said these documents were stolen from the government either by current or former officials.


    “What have you done about it?” the three-judge Bench headed by Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi asked the Attorney General who said an investigation had been ordered into the matter.


    While posting the matter for further hearing on March 14, the Bench left it to the government to file an affidavit on the issue detailing the action taken by it.


    The NDA Government signed a deal with France in 2016 for the purchase of 36 Rafale fighter jets manufactured by Dassault Aviation for an estimated cost of Rs 59,000 crore in flyaway condition. The top court had in December last year dismissed petitions seeking probe into the deal.


    The top court refused to hear the petition filed by AAP leader and Rajya Sabha MP Sanjay Singh seeking review of its December 2018 verdict declining to order a probe into the Rafale fighter jet deal, saying he had made “very derogatory” remarks on its verdict.


    The CJI said the court would take action against him after completing the hearing on the review petitions.


    Before the action was taken, Singh would be given an opportunity to explain his conduct, said CJI Gogoi.


    The CJI also refused to accept any new documents from Bhushan, including ‘The Hindu’ reports, and asked him to confine himself to the documents already on record.


    Explaining the government’s case, the Attorney General sought the dismissal of the review petitions. At one point he wondered, without Rafale, how India could resist F-16s of Pakistan.


    Venugopal requested the court to exercise restraint while commenting on Rafale deal as such statements would be used to target either the government or the opposition. As he asserted courts could not rely upon stolen documents as evidence, the Bench asked several pointed questions on the issue.


    “When there is allegation of corruption, can the government take shelter under national security?” asked Justice KM Joseph.


    The Bench said the government can’t take a general stand that no secret documents can be considered by the court. There were a large number of judgments which said courts could look into secret documents even when the government had claimed privilege in terms of Section 123 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, Justice Joseph pointed out.


    As Venugopal insisted that the petitioners must reveal the source of the documents, the CJI sought to know what if an accused established the plea of alibi based on a stolen document. “Should the Court ignore?” he asked.


    Prashant Bhushan told the Bench that there was an attempt to intimidate the petitioner on the part of the Attorney General who raised the issue of certain documents which are already in the public domain. Such an attempt amounted to criminal contempt of court, he added.

    MORE India ARTICLES

    Man Shot Dead After His Car Collided With A Scooter In Delhi's Shahdara

    Man Shot Dead After His Car Collided With A Scooter In Delhi's Shahdara
    The deceased has been identified as Sushil Chauhan, a resident of New Usmanpur.

    Man Shot Dead After His Car Collided With A Scooter In Delhi's Shahdara

    Economist Surjit Bhalla Quits From PM Modi's Economic Advisory Council

    "I resigned as part-time member of PMEAC on December 1," Surjit Bhalla said on social networking site Twitter.  

    Economist Surjit Bhalla Quits From PM Modi's Economic Advisory Council

    Congress Knocks Out BJP In Hindi Heartland, TRS' Gamble Pays Off In Telangana

    In a severe jolt to the BJP in the Hindi heartland in the "semi finals" ahead of the 2019 Lok Sabha elections, the Congress on Tuesday knocked the saffron party out of power in Chhattisgarh and Rajasthan

    Congress Knocks Out BJP In Hindi Heartland, TRS' Gamble Pays Off In Telangana

    Opening Of Kartarpur Corridor Is Clearly ISI Game Plan: Amarinder Singh

    He admitted that Pakistan was attempting to revive militancy in Punjab and thus, everyone should be wary of all of its overtures, no matter how grand they appear to be

    Opening Of Kartarpur Corridor Is Clearly ISI Game Plan: Amarinder Singh

    Navjot Singh Sidhu 'Getting Better' After He Injured His Vocal Cords

    Navjot Singh Sidhu 'Getting Better' After He Injured His Vocal Cords
    The nodules and abrasions in Navjot Singh Sidhu's throat have been cured and bleeding has stopped completely.  

    Navjot Singh Sidhu 'Getting Better' After He Injured His Vocal Cords

    Manmohan Singh, Rahul Gandhi Visit Indisposed Punjab CM Amarinder Singh

    Navjot Singh Sidhu, who also skipped today's event as he had been advised by the doctor not to speak, was away to Apollo Hospital, New Delhi, for his medical follow-up.    

    Manmohan Singh, Rahul Gandhi Visit Indisposed Punjab CM Amarinder Singh