Close X
Monday, November 18, 2024
ADVT 
India

People Retain Hope In Modi, But Time's Running Out

Darpan News Desk IANS, 23 May, 2015 11:53 AM
    No smart cities, no bullet trains, no spike in employment, no visible improvement in infrastructure, continuing logjam over bills in parliament, carping by in-house critics. Even then, few will say that Narendra Modi will lose if the elections are held in the near future.
     
    The reason is, first, the realisation that one year is not a long enough to give a definitive judgment on the performance of a government, especially when it is emerging from the black hole of the failures of its predecessor.
     
    Secondly, it is also realised that Modi may have been unable to anticipate the mischief-making potential of some of the trouble-makers, including those within the Sangh parivar.
     
    It is the appreciation of these difficulties by the general public which explains why he has passed muster in an opinion poll whereas if the opposition parties are to be believed, his government has failed miserably.
     
     
    However, it is undeniable that since some of the high expectations with which Modi assumed office have begun to be eroded, he cannot allow the present sense of drift to continue. Unless there is a perceptible upturn in the economy in the next 12 months, the warning bells will begin to ring.
     
    Hindsight suggests that Modi indulged in too much hyperbole during the election campaign. The bombast worked satisfactorily against the dismal backdrop of the virtually non-performing and scam-ridden Manmohan Singh government.
     
    But, Modi's spin doctors evidently did not realise that raising expectations too high - for instance, on the recovery of black money - carries the risk of an equally big disappointment if the hopes are not met.
     
    The risk is all the greater because the Bharatiya Janata Party's (BJP) main base of support at present is the notoriously impatient middle class which believes in quick results.
     
    It was this class which gave the Congress 200-plus seats in 2009 on the basis of high growth rates (although the party's 'socialists' ascribed the good showing to its populism) and then brought it down with a crash to 44 seats when the growth rates tumbled.
     
    The same fate can await Modi unless he pushes the economic reforms with much greater vigour than at present.
     
    As may be expected, Modi's tenure has been marked by a mixture of good and bad luck. Even as he benefitted from the falling oil prices and low inflation, unseasonal rain aggravated the distress of farmers.
     
    But, in political terms, the government has been a victim of what can be deemed an exceptional case of misfortune since its principal opponent, the Congress, has decided to adopt an unabashedly cussed attitude.
     
    As much is evident from the virtual u-turn it has taken on its own economic agenda, introduced in 1991, by following what finance minister Arun Jaitley has called an anti-growth line which, he says, is to the "left of Marx".
     
     
    As a result, crucial bills such as the Goods and Services Tax (GST) have been held up. But, the worst obstructionism engineered by the Congress relates to the land acquisition law, which constitutes a key feature of the government's development blueprint.
     
    Unless the law is amended, the government will be unable to implement its "make in India" plans which aim at making the country a manufacturing hub.
     
    However, it is not the Congress alone which is to blame for the stalemate. No less guilty are saffron outfits like the protectionist Swadeshi Jagran Manch (SJM) and the anti-reforms Bharatiya Mazdoor Sangh (BMS).
     
    Modi, therefore, is battling not only the anti-development groups cutting across party lines, but also a widely prevalent mindset which is deeply suspicious of the private sector and pro-market policies.
     
    Arguably, he has been unable to gauge the intensity of the opposition to capitalist endeavours even within the saffron camp though he is one of its key members.
     
    The reason perhaps is that he never pushed this line as energetically as he is now trying to do on a national scale. If his efforts in this direction in Gujarat were not opposed as stoutly as the SJM, the BMS and the Bharatiya Kisan Sangh (BKS) are doing now, it was because the pro-business policies were confined to a state.
     
    Modi's miscalculation has been that he did not prepare these groups about what he intends to do on an all-India scale.
     
    It is only belatedly that he seems to have sought the help of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) to tame the nay-sayers.
     
    Earlier, the RSS had backed off on the Ram temple issue, but had advised the BJP to listen to the saffron organisations on the reforms.
     
     
    The intensification of the anti-Modi campaign by the Congress has apparently left the government with no option but to ask the Sangh parivar's mentor to stand by its side on the land issue.
     
    Whatever the impact of the interventions by the RSS, the Agovernment doesn't have much time to lose to fulfil the expectations - "probably unrealistic", as Reserve Bank governor, Raghuram Rajan has said - of those who voted for Modi in large numbers in the hope that he will bring about India's economic recovery.

    MORE India ARTICLES

    Global Economy Prize for India's biotech queen

    Global Economy Prize for India's biotech queen
    India's biotechnology queen and Biocon chairperson Kiran Mazumdar-Shaw has been awarded the coveted Global Economy Prize for business by the Kiel Institute in Germany during its centenary celebrations.

    Global Economy Prize for India's biotech queen

    UGC, DU standoff continues; colleges defer admissions

    UGC, DU standoff continues; colleges defer admissions
    The standoff between the UGC and Delhi University (DU) over the four-year undergraduate programme (FYUP) continued Monday with most of the university's colleges deferring admissions, leading to confusion among lakhs of aspirants just a day before the admission process was to begin.

    UGC, DU standoff continues; colleges defer admissions

    When saying 'no' empowered these women

    When saying 'no' empowered these women
    As a child-bride, activist Sampat Pal's mother-in-law sternly instructed her to have dinner only after everyone in the family had eaten. She agreed, but a part of her rebelled against this gender discrimination. And a day came when she could take it no more and ate before everyone else did. That very moment forever changed the course of life.

    When saying 'no' empowered these women

    Efforts on for release of abducted Indians in Iraq

    Efforts on for release of abducted Indians in Iraq
    The Indian government is in touch with agencies and countries that can be of help in securing the release of Indians who were rounded up by suspected Sunni militants in Mosul town of violence-hit Iraq, official sources here said Sunday.

    Efforts on for release of abducted Indians in Iraq

    Indian student in UAE readies for NASA launch of experiments

    Indian student in UAE readies for NASA launch of experiments
    The experiments of an eleven-year-old Indian student in the UAE would be launched into space under a NASA programme, a media report said.

    Indian student in UAE readies for NASA launch of experiments

    Modinomics will face 'socialist' roadblock

    Modinomics will face 'socialist' roadblock
    As Narendra Modi resumes the task of continuing the economic reforms even if it means administering "bitter medicine", the first dose of which was given on Friday, one might have expected the Congress to offer him wholehearted support.

    Modinomics will face 'socialist' roadblock