No untoward incident after Ashish Mishra granted bail: UP govt to SC in Lakhimpur Kheri case
Darpan News Desk IANS, 04 Apr, 2022 11:42 AM
New Delhi, April 4 (IANS) The Uttar Pradesh government on Monday told the Supreme Court that Lakhimpur Kheri violence case, where eight people lost their lives, was a grave offence, and no untoward incident happened after Ashish Mishra, prime accused in the case was granted bail, and he was also not a flight risk.
However, the top court sought clarity from the state government on its stand on SIT recommendations for cancellation of bail granted to Mishra.
At the beginning of the hearing, a bench headed by Chief Justice queried senior advocate Mahesh Jethmalani, representing the Uttar Pradesh government, "It is your choice, I can't insist... You have not responded to the letter. This is not a matter where you've to wait so much." The bench pointed at the two letters written by SIT to the additional chief secretary, home, Uttar Pradesh and the judge monitoring the Lakhimpur violence case probe recommending cancellation of bail granted to Mishra on February 10 by the Allahabad High Court.
Jethmalani said, "We've forwarded the report to the state...whether to file SLP... the state government has provided security (to all 98 witnesses in the case)...each of the witnesses contacted over phone." He added that none of the witnesses have expressed any apprehension with the security provided.
However, the bench, also comprising Justices Surya Kant and Hima Kohli, pointed out to Jethmalani that the matter at hand is whether bail granted to Mishra is correct or not? The bench questioned the detailed examination of evidence like the post mortem report while granting bail to Mishra, son of Union minister Ajay Mishra, by the high court in the case. "This way of going into merits and going into wounds, etc., is unnecessary for the question of bail," noted the bench.
Jethmalani submitted it was a very serious offence, and a grave offence, however, the high court took a different view despite the state government's objection. "He (Ashish Mishra) is not a flight risk, no untoward incident happened after he was granted bail", said Jethmalani. However, the Chief Justice pointed out that the matter was not about protection granted to witnesses, and not filing the SLP (special leave petition by state government against bail to Mishra).
The Chief Justice said the court constituted an SIT to probe the case and appointed Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain, a former judge of the Punjab and Haryana High Court, to monitor the probe. The Chief Justice further added, "State should have acted on the suggestion made by the SIT...we are not forcing you to file SLP...What is your stand?" Jethmalani said whether the vehicle mowed down the victims, intentionally or not is a matter of trial. "98 witnesses have been provided security, 78 are from Lakhimpur Kheri district...all witnesses are regularly contacted by police (telephonically). Offence is serious", said Jethmalani.
Senior advocate Ranjit Kumar, representing Mishra, submitted that once the top court cancels his client's bail, no court will grant him bail. The bench asked Kumar, what was the tearing hurry for his client to apply for bail? Kumar submitted that Mishra was not in the vehicle, which mowed down farmers. Senior advocate Dushyant Dave and advocate Prashant Bhushan, representing the victims' families, said the high court failed to consider relevant facts, and the order suffered from gross non-application of mind by the high court. Dave added that none of the victims were heard by the high court. After hearing arguments, the top court reserved the order on the plea seeking cancellation of bail granted to Ashish Mishra in the case.
Mishra was arrested on October 9 last year in the case. On October 3, 2021, eight people, including four farmers, were killed in Lakhimpur Kheri in clashes during a farmers' protest. He was granted bail on February 10.
The family members of the farmers, mowed down by a car belonging to Mishra, in Lakhimpur Kheri had moved the top court challenging bail granted to him. He is the son of Union Minister and BJP MP Ajay Kumar Mishra. The victims' families have claimed that the state has not filed an appeal opposing bail granted to Mishra.
Channi also said that 997 students from the state were in Ukraine, out of whom 420 have returned, and 200 students have reached Poland and are safe but some of the people are still stuck in Ukraine.
In 2017, the Aam Aadmi Party had got around 23 per cent votes but the projections for this election is 39 per cent, while Congress seems to have lost around 11 per cent votes, against in last election's over 38 per cent now, to around 26 per cent and may see its tally come down from 77 seats to 25 seats.
Harjot's brother Prabhjot Singh, who resides in Delhi's Chhattarpur, told IANS: "The last conversation I had with Harjot was on February 26 at 9 p.m. I haven't spoken to him since then. On March 2, at night, he contacted the family and informed them about his injuries.
While directing officials to ensure safe return of the remaining students and other persons stuck in Ukraine, he said the state government is sparing no effort to help the distressed families in this hour of crisis.
Over 700 Indian students are stuck in Sumy and they are running out of basic necessities like food and water and they have been urging the Indian government to get them evacuated from there.
Over 7,400 Indian nationals are expected to be evacuated under the 'Operation Ganga' in the next two days, the government said on Thursday. The Centre has initiated an airlift operation to evacuate Indians, who have found their way to the neighbouring countries of war-torn Ukraine.
