Close X
Sunday, December 1, 2024
ADVT 
India

Navjot Singh Sidhu TV Show Case: Can't Moral Police Politicians, Says High Court

Darpan News Desk IANS, 11 May, 2017 01:06 PM
    The Punjab and Haryana High Court today observed that it cannot issue any direction against former cricketer-turned Punjab minister Navjot Singh Sidhu's participation in a television show due to absence of any statutory provisions.
     
    "People emulate these things... No doubt those in public life should exercise restraint, but how far can we go? We can't start moral policing of politicians," a bench of Justices SS Saron and Darshan Singh observed.
     
    The court was hearing a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) filed by Chandigarh-based advocate HC Arora against Mr Sidhu's continuation with 'The Kapil Sharma Show' after becoming a minister in the Amarinder Singh Government.
     
    The court, however, did not accept the plea of the advocate general, who had questioned the "maintainability' of the PIL, and asked him to respond to various issues raised in the petition. 
     
    Earlier, the state Advocate General, Atul Nanda, argued that in the absence of provisions, the court of law cannot interfere. He contended that there is no convention, "but even if it is assumed that it existed, the court can't issue a direction for enforcement of convention in the absence of any law".
     
    Asked by the bench whether a convention can be enforced, Mr Nanda cited the judgements of the Supreme Court. He submitted a 600-page compilation of precedents where the courts have categorically stated that they will not enforce conventions.
     
     
    The bench heard the arguments of the parties for about two hours. 
     
    "Lakhs of people follow the example set by ministers, and public conduct of ministers is being watched.
     
    "In such a situation, can a minister resort to a conduct which is not in consonance with the dignity and status of a Cabinet Minister?" the bench asked the advocate general. Mr Nanda maintained that Mr Sidhu has not violated the code of conduct for ministers. 
     
    The petitioner argued that the Cabinet Minister is not only participating in the comedy show, but is also appearing in an advertisement, and promoting a "magic machine" for learning spoken English. 
     
     
    Such conduct of a minister must be interfered with, the petitioner submitted.
     
     
     
    Mr Arora quoted a 2004 judgement of the Supreme Court in Jayalalitha's case, wherein referring to enforceability of Code of Conduct, the Supreme Court had observed that "morally speaking, can there be one law for small officials of the government and another law for the chief minister...?" 
     
    The petitioner argued saying, "a stage has come, when the high court should come forward to interfere in the matter of code of conduct, as a Cabinet Minister promoting 'magic English speaking machines' is something unheard of in the past." 
     
    The advocate general, however, interjected and told the HC that this advertisement was shot by Mr Sidhu several years ago.
     
    On being asked by the petitioner, he could not disclose as to when the contract for this advertisement is expiring. 
     
    The advocate general argued that the code of conduct for ministers is not enforceable through courts. 
     
    At this stage, the bench repeatedly asked him, "Assuming that the code of conduct is not enforceable through courts, then the question would arise - whether it is worth the paper on which it is written?" 
     
    "We may feel that Sidhu while working as a minister and a television actor may be ethically wrong, but this is no violation of law. We can only stop him from working if he is violating a law and not on the basis of moral or conduct grounds. 
     
     
     
    "Participating in a television show is an engagement of an artiste and not a business or employment. The petitioner should prove that it was a propriety or conflict of interest issue," the bench observed. 
     
    The next hearing will be on August 2. 

    MORE India ARTICLES

    Yogi Adityanath's Hindu Yuva Vahini Thrashes Couple In UP On Suspicion Of 'Love Jihad'

    Yogi Adityanath's Hindu Yuva Vahini Thrashes Couple In UP On Suspicion Of 'Love Jihad'
    Members of a Hindu youth group founded by Uttar Pradesh chief minister Yogi Adityanath allegedly barged into a house in Meerut and thrashed a Muslim man for being in a compromising position with a woman, sources told HT on Wednesday.

    Yogi Adityanath's Hindu Yuva Vahini Thrashes Couple In UP On Suspicion Of 'Love Jihad'

    He Is A Khalistani Sympathiser: Amarinder Singh Refuses To Meet Defence Minister Harjit Sajjan

    He Is A Khalistani Sympathiser: Amarinder Singh Refuses To Meet Defence Minister Harjit Sajjan
    Dubbing Canadian defence minister Harjit Singh Sajjan a “Khalistani sympathiser”, Punjab chief minister Captain Amarinder Singh on Wednesday said he will not meet the Indo-Canadian leader during his expected visit to India later this month.

    He Is A Khalistani Sympathiser: Amarinder Singh Refuses To Meet Defence Minister Harjit Sajjan

    Deserted By NRI Husband, Kapurthala Woman Seeks Sushma’s Help To Get Him Deported From New Zealand

    Deserted By NRI Husband, Kapurthala Woman Seeks Sushma’s Help To Get Him Deported From New Zealand
    A woman deserted by her non-resident Indian (NRI) husband has appealed to external affairs minister Sushma Swaraj to help secure deportation of her husband from New Zealand.

    Deserted By NRI Husband, Kapurthala Woman Seeks Sushma’s Help To Get Him Deported From New Zealand

    7,000 Girls Perform 'Kuchipudi' In Vizag To Set New Record

    7,000 Girls Perform 'Kuchipudi' In Vizag To Set New Record
    As many as 7,000 girl students on Tuesday performed classical dance 'Kuchpudi' in this Andhra Pradesh coastal city to set a Guinness World record.

    7,000 Girls Perform 'Kuchipudi' In Vizag To Set New Record

    Ekam Dhillon Murder Case: 22 Days On, Mohali Woman Seerat Kaur’s Mother Gives Up

    Ekam Dhillon Murder Case: 22 Days On, Mohali Woman Seerat Kaur’s Mother Gives Up
    Twenty-two days after Aikom's murder came to light, the victim’s mother-in-law, Jaswinder Kaur, surrendered herself in the office of the Mohali Senior Superintendent of Police at the District Police Headquarters in Sector 76 here this afternoon.

    Ekam Dhillon Murder Case: 22 Days On, Mohali Woman Seerat Kaur’s Mother Gives Up

    Telangana Techie Madhukar Reddy Gudur, Who Committed Suicide In US, Cremated

    Telangana Techie Madhukar Reddy Gudur, Who Committed Suicide In US, Cremated
    The body of a techie who allegedly committed suicide in the US last week was on Tuesday cremated at his home town Bhongir in Telangana.

    Telangana Techie Madhukar Reddy Gudur, Who Committed Suicide In US, Cremated