Close X
Thursday, November 28, 2024
ADVT 
India

Mosque Was Built On A Temple's Ruins, Argues Hindu Body In SC

Darpan News Desk IANS, 13 Aug, 2019 07:21 PM

    On Tuesday, the fifth day of hearing in the Ayodhya case at the Supreme Court, Hindus submitted that a temple was destroyed and a mosque was built over it. Such an act couldn't deprive the deity and the temple of the ownership of the place, they said.


    Though the Muslim parties objected to the proceedings, the court brushed aside their opposition.


    Advocate C.S. Vaidyanathan, appearing for deity Ram Lalla Virajman, cited the Allahabad High Court judgement where a judge restricted the Lord Ram's birthplace to the central dome of the mosque and, through a map identified the circular path for 'parikrama' by devotees to complete their worship. Therefore, the area under the 'parikrama' also became a place of the deity, Vaidyanathan submitted.


    "The three-judge Bench of the Allahabad HC also held that there was a temple at the disputed area. Justice S.U. Khan had identified that mosque was built on the temple's ruins. Therefore, the mosque was not built on the vacant land", submitted Vaidyanathan.


    Drawing an inference for his arguments, Vaidyanathan said if judges had concurred that there was a temple before the mosque, then the deity's possession right should be accepted. As the deity was never alienated from the property, there could not be adverse possession of it, he argued.


    Justice D Y Chandrachud, one of the judges of the Constitution Bench headed by Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi, queried Vaidyanathan, how would the court proceed in the light of the Allahabad HC verdict, which favoured joint possession of both parties?


    To this Vaidyanathan submitted the ouster of the Hindu deity from the site was never established. Neither was established the exclusive possession of the Muslim side. Therefore, it's logical to say those who offered prayers from the time immemorial should retain their rights. Muslim couldn't present any document to show their ownership, thus how could they establish adverse possession, he said.


    Justice Ashok Bhushan then intervened saying the Muslim side has claimed exclusive possession of the site. When Vaidyanathan argued the high court didn't accept that, the judge quipped: "We don't have to go just by the findings of the high court."


    CJI Gogoi also asked Vaidyanathan to answer how Ram Lala Virajman established its exclusive title while countering the suit by the Sunni Waqf Board.


    The counsel argued a place could also be considered a deity by virtue of belief by millions, and it's the divinity of the deity. Vaidyanathan also cited the Supreme Court judgment to claim presence of idol was not the sole condition for existence of a temple. "If people believe in its religious worth, the condition is automatically met," contended Vaidyanathan.


    K Parasaran, also appearing for Ram Lalla Virajman, concluding his arguments submitted that the court must deliver complete justice in all the matter before it.


    Rajeev Dhavan, appearing for a Muslim party, objected to the line of argument by the Hindu parties and informed the court he didn't favour the way the proceedings were being carried out.


    Dhavan said lawyers from the Hindu side had not exhibited anything yet, rather than reading out from the Allahabad HC judgement. "This is a case of hop, skip and jump. No exhibit or evidence has been placed yet. In fact, most citations was not admitted by the HC", argued Dhavan.


    When the Chief Justice said the Muslim parties would get their time, Dhavan replied, "I hope you do". To that the Chief Justice told Dhavan that from day one he had been making snide remarks at the Bench. Let it be loud and clear to all counsel appearing in the matter, we were not in hurry and they could take as much time as possible, the Bench said.


    Ram Lalla Virajman's counsel also presented P. Carnegie's historical sketches on the importance of Ayodhya along with the British administration orders.


    Vaidyanathan read out the gazetteer notices in 1850s to show that though complaints were lodged regarding the inner courtyard's construction, nothing was removed and that included the Chabutara. Therefore, everything continued. "The British wanted everything to remain undisturbed," said Vaidyanathan and added the deity predated the mosque.


    When Justice S.A. Bobde asked Vaidyanathan, "You are saying the deity can't be partitioned," Vaidyanathan replied in affirmative. "There can't be any division of the deity. If the place belongs to deity, then the construction of mosque can't change the status of deity," he argued.


    The hearing will continue on Wednesday.


    Against the 2010 Allahabad HC verdict, nearly 14 appeals have been filed in the apex court. The HC through its judgement, in four civil suits, partitioned the 2.77-acre land equally among the three parties -- the Sunni Waqf Board, the Nirmohi Akhara and Ram Lalla.

    MORE India ARTICLES

    More Than Half Punjabi, Urdu Teacher Positions Vacant In Delhi Government Schools: RTI

    More Than Half Punjabi, Urdu Teacher Positions Vacant In Delhi Government Schools: RTI
    More than half of the teacher posts for Urdu and Punjabi languages in Delhi government schools are lying vacant.

    More Than Half Punjabi, Urdu Teacher Positions Vacant In Delhi Government Schools: RTI

    Chandrayaan-2 Successfully Put Into Orbit, Lunar Landing In Sept, The Women Who Fuelled India's Ambitious Moonshot

    India's second lunar mission was on track as its 'Bahubali' GSLV rocket successfully put the moon spacecraft -- Chandrayaan-2 -- into the orbit in a copy book style on Monday afternoon.

    Chandrayaan-2 Successfully Put Into Orbit, Lunar Landing In Sept, The Women Who Fuelled India's Ambitious Moonshot

    Winner of #SareeTwitter Trend? Video Of Woman Kissing Cricketer From 1975 Goes Viral

    The woman, wearing a black saree, dodged all the police personnel and went to plant a kiss on Patel, and then went away, smiling.

    Winner of #SareeTwitter Trend? Video Of Woman Kissing Cricketer From 1975 Goes Viral

    Top Court Asks Attorney General's Assistance Over Plea To Define Minority

    Top Court Asks Attorney General's Assistance Over Plea To Define Minority
    A bench comprising Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi and Justices Deepak Gupta and Aniruddha Bose took note of the submissions of senior advocate Mukul Rohatgi.  

    Top Court Asks Attorney General's Assistance Over Plea To Define Minority

    In A First, CRPF Women Troopers Will Now Have Full Body Protectors

    Till date, they had to make do with gear designed for their male counterparts.

    In A First, CRPF Women Troopers Will Now Have Full Body Protectors

    Indian-Origin Bail Bondswoman Hema Patel Smuggled Hundreds Of Aliens Into US For A Fee, Jailed

    Indian-Origin Bail Bondswoman Hema Patel Smuggled Hundreds Of Aliens Into US For A Fee, Jailed
    Patel was also ordered to forfeit her Texas residence, two hotels, $7.2 million in bail bonds, $400,000 in cash and 11 gold bars, among other assets.  

    Indian-Origin Bail Bondswoman Hema Patel Smuggled Hundreds Of Aliens Into US For A Fee, Jailed