Close X
Friday, November 22, 2024
ADVT 
India

Mosque Integral To Islam?: Top Court Reserves Order On Review Appeal

IANS, 20 Jul, 2018 02:24 PM
    The Supreme Court today reserved its order on a plea by Muslim groups of the Ram Janmabhoomi-Babri Masjid title dispute seeking reconsideration by a larger bench the observations made by it in a 1994 verdict that a mosque was not integral to Islam.
     
     
    M Siddiq, one of the original litigants of the Ayodhya case who has died and is being represented through his legal heir, had assailed certain findings of the 1994 verdict in the case of M Ismail Faruqui holding that a mosque was not integral to the prayers offered by the followers of Islam.
     
     
    It was argued by Muslim groups before a special bench comprising Chief Justice Dipak Misra and justices Ashok Bhushan and S A Nazeer that the "sweeping" observation of the top court in the verdict needed to be reconsidered by a five-judge bench as "it had and will have a bearing" on the Babri Masjid-Ram Temple land dispute case.
     
     
    "The order is reserved," the bench said and asked the parties to give written submissions by July 24.
     
     
    Senior advocate Rajeev Dhavan, appearing for legal representative of Mr Siddiq, said the observations that mosques are not essential for practising Islam were made by the top court without conducting any enquiry or considering the religious texts.
     
     
    "It was a sweeping observation which requires to be reconsidered before the top court hears the title dispute," he said.
     
     
    At the outset, sharp exchanges of words took place when a lawyer objected to Mr Dhavan's earlier remarks that "Hindu Taliban" had destroyed the Babri mosque in 1991.
     
     
    "He cannot be allowed to use such words against the entire Hindu community," the lawyer said.
     
     
    "The destruction of Babri mosque was a terrorist act. I will not take back my words. I stand by my words," Mr Dhavan said.
     
     
    The bench termed the use of words (Hindu Taliban) as inappropriate and said that the decorum of court should be maintained.
     
     
    It asked the security guards to escort the lawyer, who had entered into verbal duel with Mr Dhavan, outside the court room.
     
     
    On July 13, Mr Dhavan had said that the Babri Masjid was destroyed by the "Hindu Taliban" just like the demolition of the Buddha statue by the Taliban at Bamiyan in Afghanistan.
     
     
     The Uttar Pradesh government had earlier told the top court that some Muslim groups were trying to delay the hearing in the "long-pending" Ayodhya temple-mosque land dispute case by seeking reconsideration of the observation in the 1994 verdict that a mosque was not integral to Islam.
     
     
    Additional Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, appearing for the Uttar Pradesh government, had said this dispute has been awaiting final adjudication for "almost a century".
     
     
    He had also said that the issue of the observation was neither taken up by any litigant since 1994, nor in the present appeals which were filed in 2010 after the high court's verdict.
     
     
    The state government had said the law decided by this court in the Ismail Farooqi case was "the correct law which does not deserve to be disturbed either by referring it as belatedly prayed for or otherwise".
     
     
    Earlier, Hindu groups had opposed the plea of their Muslim counterparts that the 1994 verdict holding that a mosque was not integral to the prayers offered by the followers of Islam be referred to a larger bench.
     
     
    The observations were made in the land acquisition matter pertaining to the Ayodhya site and the top court had to consider two aspects as to whether a mosque could be acquired at all and whether a religious place of worship like a mosque, church or temple was immune from acquisition if it is a place of special significance for that religion and formed an essential and integral part of that religion.
     
     
    The special bench of the top court is seized of a total of 14 appeals filed against the high court judgement delivered in four civil suits.
     
     
    A three-judge bench of the Allahabad High Court, in a 2:1 majority ruling, had in 2010 ordered that the land be partitioned equally among three parties -- the Sunni Waqf Board, the Nirmohi Akhara and Ram Lalla.

    MORE India ARTICLES

    Delhi Fast Becoming ‘Safe Haven For Drug Smugglers’: Punjab CM Amarinder Singh

      Delhi is fast turning into a “safe haven for drug peddlers and smugglers” and criminals, who have “disappeared” from Punjab and are hiding in neighbouring states, including the national capital, Chief Minister Amarinder Singh has claimed. 

    Delhi Fast Becoming ‘Safe Haven For Drug Smugglers’: Punjab CM Amarinder Singh

    David Cameron In Kolkata: India Is Fortunate To Have Leader Like Narendra Modi: David Cameron

    Hailing Prime Minister Narendra Modi, former British Prime Minister David Cameron on Thursday said India is fortunate to have a leadership with a clear vision, but greater focus is needed on developing skills and infrastructure.

    David Cameron In Kolkata: India Is Fortunate To Have Leader Like Narendra Modi: David Cameron

    New York-Based Writer Amarpreet Kaur Dhami's Story Lives On Year After Death

    New York-Based Writer Amarpreet Kaur Dhami's Story Lives On Year After Death
    New York-based writer Amarpreet Kaur Dhami was working on a children’s book when she was diagnosed with colon cancer two years ago. 

    New York-Based Writer Amarpreet Kaur Dhami's Story Lives On Year After Death

    Miss Deaf Asia Deshna Jain Wants To Go To Italy, Walk At World Fashion Show

    Miss Deaf Asia Deshna Jain Wants To Go To Italy, Walk At World Fashion Show
    Deshna Jain, a 20-year-old girl from Tikamgarh who has become Miss Deaf Asia and the third runner-up of Miss Deaf International held in Taiwan, says that the platform has given her a new boost and she now wants to go to Italy and participate in fashion shows globally.

    Miss Deaf Asia Deshna Jain Wants To Go To Italy, Walk At World Fashion Show

    For Third Time, 10-Year-Old Indian Boy Harmanpreet Singh Denied Visa To Visit Father In Australia

    A visitor visa for Harmanpreet Singh was applied so that the boy can meet his father and stepmother in Melbourne during his school summer vacation, the Australian media reported on Tuesday.

    For Third Time, 10-Year-Old Indian Boy Harmanpreet Singh Denied Visa To Visit Father In Australia

    India A 'Huge Priority' For US, A ‘Force For Good’ Says American Diplomat

    India A 'Huge Priority' For US, A ‘Force For Good’ Says American Diplomat
    Tom Vajda said as India plays a larger role in the world, there is a sense in the Trump administration that this benefits the US.  

    India A 'Huge Priority' For US, A ‘Force For Good’ Says American Diplomat