Close X
Wednesday, January 15, 2025
ADVT 
India

Indian Supreme Court Refers Homosexuality Plea To Constitution Bench

Darpan News Desk IANS, 02 Feb, 2016 11:54 AM
    A five judge constitution bench of the Supreme Court will hear the curative petition by NGO Naaz Foundation and others seeking a relook at its verdict upholding the validity of Indian Penal Code's section 377 that criminalises homosexuality.
     
    A bench of three senior-most judges - Chief Justice T.S. Thakur, Justice Anil R. Dave and Justice Jagdish Singh Khehar - referred the curative petition to the larger bench as senior counsel Kapil Sibal said the issue involved constitutional questions of far-reaching importance and must be heard by a five judge bench.
     
    "Since several constitutional issues are sought to be agitated in these petitions, let the matter be placed before the Chief Justice of India for posting to the five judges bench," ordered the bench after a brief hearing of the curative petition on Tuesday.
     
    The court did not issue any notice, leaving it for the larger bench to take a call.
     
    At the outset, Sibal said that the issue before the court concerned the most private right, the most precious right of the people - the sexual right and argued that if it is being exercised with consensus and within four walls, then no one should have any objection.
     
    Faulting the December 12, 2013 apex court judgment and subsequent January 28, 2014 order in a review petition upholding the validity of section 377, he said the issue involved the rights of the gay people who are facing indignity and stigma by the judgment of a two judge bench.
     
    Telling the court that the issue before it was within four corners of the right to privacy under the constitution's article 19(1) guaranteeing freedom of speech and expression, Sibal said that it should be heard by a five judges bench.
     
    As senior counsel Anand Grover appearing for one of the eight petitioners seeking a relook at the apex court verdict sought to address the court, Chief Justice Thakur asked: "Is there anyone opposing it?"
     
    The court was told that an organisation representing the church, the All India Muslim Personnel Law Board and a few individuals were opposing the plea.
     
    The apex court by its December 12, 2013 order and on the review petition on January 28, 2014, upheld the validity of section 377, finding no constitutional infirmity in the penal provision that criminalises homosexuality.
     
    It had set aside the Delhi High Court's July 2, 2009 verdict reading down section 377 and decriminalising consensual sex between the adults of same gender.
     
    The then bench of Chief Justice P.Sathasivam, Justice R.M.Lodha, Justice H.L.Dattu and Justice S.J.Mukhopadhaya (all retired since then) had on April 3, 2014, directed hearing of the curative petition in open court after they considered the plea by Naz Foundation in their chambers.
     
    The NGO had moved the Supreme Court seeking to cure "gross miscarriage of justice" in its judgment upholding the validity of section 377. 
     
    It had contended that 2013 amendment to section 375, dealing with rape, had held consensual sex between an adult male and woman was not an offence, and by implication, no longer prohibited. Thus section 377 now effectively only criminalises all forms of penetrative sex, including, penile-anal sex and penile oral sex, which makes it ex facie discriminatory against homosexual men and transgender persons and thus violative of the consarticle 14 of the constitution.
     
    It had said that the amendments were carried out after the judgment in the gay sex case was reserved and the parties did not have a chance to address the court on the issue, and the court ought to have heard the parties on the effect of the amendments.
     
    The impugned judgment, it said, "reflects an issue bias against the LGBT persons, as evident from such observations like "the so-called rights of LGBT persons" and "miniscule fraction of the country's population" which vitiates the judgment and renders it a nullity.

    MORE India ARTICLES

    Video: Muslim Management Graduate Denied Job On Religious Grounds In Mumbai

    Video: Muslim Management Graduate Denied Job On Religious Grounds In Mumbai
    A management graduate here on Thursday lodged a police complaint accusing a leading diamond export firm of "religious discrimination" and refusing him a job because he was a Muslim.

    Video: Muslim Management Graduate Denied Job On Religious Grounds In Mumbai

    US Ambassador Richard R. Verma Walks Down Memory Lane In Punjab

    US Ambassador Richard R. Verma Walks Down Memory Lane In Punjab
    It was a trip down memory lane for US Ambassador Richard R. Verma, whose visit to his maternal grandmother's house in Punjab turned emotional on Thursday.

    US Ambassador Richard R. Verma Walks Down Memory Lane In Punjab

    Geelani Should Declare Himself Indian For Passport: Defence Minister Manohar Parrikar

    Geelani Should Declare Himself Indian For Passport: Defence Minister Manohar Parrikar
    Separatist Kashmiri leader Syed Ali Shah Geelani should declare he is an Indian to get a passport, Defence Minister Manohar Parrikar said on Thursday.

    Geelani Should Declare Himself Indian For Passport: Defence Minister Manohar Parrikar

    Beef Eaters Can Go To Pakistan: Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi

    Beef Eaters Can Go To Pakistan: Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi
    Minister of State for Parliamentary Affairs Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi on Thursday justified ban on cow slaughter and asked all those who want to eat beef to go to Pakistan.

    Beef Eaters Can Go To Pakistan: Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi

    Investment Policy For Overseas Indians Tweaked

    Investment Policy For Overseas Indians Tweaked
    The union cabinet on Thursday approved certain amendments to the Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) policy to make investments by overseas Indians in the country easier and simpler.

    Investment Policy For Overseas Indians Tweaked

    India's First Gay Marriage Ad: Mother Places Matrimonial Ad, Seeks 'Vegetarian' Groom For Gay Son!

    India's First Gay Marriage Ad: Mother Places Matrimonial Ad, Seeks 'Vegetarian' Groom For Gay Son!
    In what is billed as perhaps India's first, Harrish's mother Padma (58), placed the ad in Mumbai tabloid, Mid-Day, on Tuesday - and it caught wild fire on social media networks.

    India's First Gay Marriage Ad: Mother Places Matrimonial Ad, Seeks 'Vegetarian' Groom For Gay Son!