Close X
Saturday, October 12, 2024
ADVT 
India

Delhi HC asks prosecution, legal dept to exercise due diligence in filing of cases

Darpan News Desk IANS, 10 Oct, 2024 04:43 PM
  • Delhi HC asks prosecution, legal dept to exercise due diligence in filing of cases

New Delhi, Oct 10 (IANS) Observing that the filing of frivolous cases has a far-reaching and detrimental impact on the legal system, the Delhi High Court has asked the prosecution and legal departments of the national capital to exercise due diligence before initiating cases.

A bench of Justice Amit Mahajan was hearing a plea seeking a grant of leave to appeal against a 2019 judgment passed by the Special Fast Track Court acquitted the respondents in relation to an FIR registered under Sections 376/511 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC), 1860.

As per the prosecutrix, her mother worked as a maid in several houses, and the landlord’s son attempted to commit rape upon her and fled when an alarm was raised.

The trial court framed charges under Sections 341, 323, 354, 376, and 511 of the IPC against the main accused and separate charges under Sections 341, 323 and 34 of the IPC were framed against the mother and sister of the accused.

In her cross-examination, the prosecutrix deposed that the dispute took place between her family and the family of the accused in regard to vacating the premises. Further, she replied that a false complaint was filed against the accused persons, in response to a query put forward by the trial court.

The trial court noted that the “real dispute between the parties was with regard to the rent” and the complainant had stated that the accused had not attempted to rape her.

Also, the DD entry pursuant to a PCR call, only mentions that there was a quarrel and no allegation of an attempt to rape was ever made.

Considering the affidavits filed by the prosecutrix and her mother, where they had deposed that the dispute was in regard to the rent and a false complaint was filed, the trial court acquitted the accused respondents.

Questioning the filing of a prosecution appeal, the Delhi High Court said that it was “unable to understand the reasoning behind the Department of Law & Legislative Affairs recommending an appeal in this case”.

It said: “It is trite law that this court must exercise caution and should only interfere in an appeal against acquittal where there are substantial and compelling reasons to do so. [I]t is trite law that the accused can be convicted solely on the basis of evidence of the complainant/victim as long as the same inspires confidence and corroboration is not necessary for the same.”

The Delhi HC noted that the Additional Public Prosecutor, in the proceedings before the Rohini Courts, initially opined that the case was not suitable for appeal to the High Court.

It further noted: “The Director of Prosecution also shared this view, concluding that the case did not warrant an appeal to the High Court. However, it appears that the Department of Law & Legislative Affairs later proposed filing an appeal.”

In its order, the Delhi HC said that “although the present case clearly qualifies as one where costs should be imposed on the prosecution for filing a frivolous appeal,” but has chosen to refrain from passing such an order with a direction to the Department of Law & Legislative Affairs to exercise greater vigilance and sensitivity in deciding which cases to prosecute.

“The filing of frivolous cases has a spiral effect on other litigations which are waiting for their turn to be heard before the Courts. The misuse of the legal process through frivolous litigation wastes judicial time and resources, and the Department must ensure that only meritorious cases are brought before the Court, avoiding unnecessary burden on the judicial system,” it added.

Dismissing the plea, the Delhi HC said that it is imperative that the prosecution and legal departments exercise due diligence before initiating cases, in order to preserve the integrity of the judicial process and ensure timely justice for those with legitimate grievances.

MORE India ARTICLES

India to continue transformation under PM Modi towards becoming 3rd largest economy: CII

India to continue transformation under PM Modi towards becoming 3rd largest economy: CII
The Confederation of Indian Industry (CII) on Monday said they are confident that under the astute leadership of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, the country would continue its economic transformation and emerge among the top three in the world. In a statement, Sanjiv Puri, President of CII, congratulated PM Modi for assuming charge for the third consecutive term.

India to continue transformation under PM Modi towards becoming 3rd largest economy: CII

Jalandhar (West) assembly bypoll on July 10: Punjab CEO

Jalandhar (West) assembly bypoll on July 10: Punjab CEO
Punjab Chief Electoral Officer (CEO) Sibin C on Monday said voting for the Jalandhar West (reserved) assembly by-election will be held on July 10. The seat fell vacant after the resignation of AAP legislator Sheetal Angural, who switched loyalties to the BJP in March.

Jalandhar (West) assembly bypoll on July 10: Punjab CEO

'People of India always stood for peace', PM Modi takes veiled dig at Pakistan

'People of India always stood for peace', PM Modi takes veiled dig at Pakistan
The President of the ruling party in the country, Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N), Nawaz Sharif congratulated PM Modi on Monday as the BJP-led NDA formed the government for the third consecutive time following its victory in the just-concluded Lok Sabha elections.

'People of India always stood for peace', PM Modi takes veiled dig at Pakistan

Will introduce new approaches to realise PM Modi's vision of secure Bharat: Amit Shah

Will introduce new approaches to realise PM Modi's vision of secure Bharat: Amit Shah
Taking to social media after the announcement on the allocation of portfolios among the members of the Union Council of Ministers, Shah also said that as the Minister of Cooperation, he remains committed to empowering farmers and villages.

Will introduce new approaches to realise PM Modi's vision of secure Bharat: Amit Shah

Gang involved in selling, purchasing snatched mobile phones busted; 4 held

Gang involved in selling, purchasing snatched mobile phones busted; 4 held
Delhi Police have busted a gang with links in Nepal involved in a cross-country network for the sale and purchase of snatched and stolen mobile phones, an official said on Monday, adding that the operation led to the arrest of four criminals, including a husband-wife duo, and the recovery of 226 mobile phones.

Gang involved in selling, purchasing snatched mobile phones busted; 4 held

G7 to Peace Summit, world leaders already looking forward to PM Modi's attendance at key global events

G7 to Peace Summit, world leaders already looking forward to PM Modi's attendance at key global events
Even before he takes oath for the third consecutive time, Prime Minister Narendra Modi continues to receive invites for significant events that are expected to shape the global agenda in the coming months. The upcoming summit of the Group of Seven (G7) in Italy from June 13-15 will however be the first event that PM Modi will be attending after assuming office.

G7 to Peace Summit, world leaders already looking forward to PM Modi's attendance at key global events