Close X
Monday, October 14, 2024
ADVT 
India

Delhi HC asks prosecution, legal dept to exercise due diligence in filing of cases

Darpan News Desk IANS, 10 Oct, 2024 04:43 PM
  • Delhi HC asks prosecution, legal dept to exercise due diligence in filing of cases

New Delhi, Oct 10 (IANS) Observing that the filing of frivolous cases has a far-reaching and detrimental impact on the legal system, the Delhi High Court has asked the prosecution and legal departments of the national capital to exercise due diligence before initiating cases.

A bench of Justice Amit Mahajan was hearing a plea seeking a grant of leave to appeal against a 2019 judgment passed by the Special Fast Track Court acquitted the respondents in relation to an FIR registered under Sections 376/511 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC), 1860.

As per the prosecutrix, her mother worked as a maid in several houses, and the landlord’s son attempted to commit rape upon her and fled when an alarm was raised.

The trial court framed charges under Sections 341, 323, 354, 376, and 511 of the IPC against the main accused and separate charges under Sections 341, 323 and 34 of the IPC were framed against the mother and sister of the accused.

In her cross-examination, the prosecutrix deposed that the dispute took place between her family and the family of the accused in regard to vacating the premises. Further, she replied that a false complaint was filed against the accused persons, in response to a query put forward by the trial court.

The trial court noted that the “real dispute between the parties was with regard to the rent” and the complainant had stated that the accused had not attempted to rape her.

Also, the DD entry pursuant to a PCR call, only mentions that there was a quarrel and no allegation of an attempt to rape was ever made.

Considering the affidavits filed by the prosecutrix and her mother, where they had deposed that the dispute was in regard to the rent and a false complaint was filed, the trial court acquitted the accused respondents.

Questioning the filing of a prosecution appeal, the Delhi High Court said that it was “unable to understand the reasoning behind the Department of Law & Legislative Affairs recommending an appeal in this case”.

It said: “It is trite law that this court must exercise caution and should only interfere in an appeal against acquittal where there are substantial and compelling reasons to do so. [I]t is trite law that the accused can be convicted solely on the basis of evidence of the complainant/victim as long as the same inspires confidence and corroboration is not necessary for the same.”

The Delhi HC noted that the Additional Public Prosecutor, in the proceedings before the Rohini Courts, initially opined that the case was not suitable for appeal to the High Court.

It further noted: “The Director of Prosecution also shared this view, concluding that the case did not warrant an appeal to the High Court. However, it appears that the Department of Law & Legislative Affairs later proposed filing an appeal.”

In its order, the Delhi HC said that “although the present case clearly qualifies as one where costs should be imposed on the prosecution for filing a frivolous appeal,” but has chosen to refrain from passing such an order with a direction to the Department of Law & Legislative Affairs to exercise greater vigilance and sensitivity in deciding which cases to prosecute.

“The filing of frivolous cases has a spiral effect on other litigations which are waiting for their turn to be heard before the Courts. The misuse of the legal process through frivolous litigation wastes judicial time and resources, and the Department must ensure that only meritorious cases are brought before the Court, avoiding unnecessary burden on the judicial system,” it added.

Dismissing the plea, the Delhi HC said that it is imperative that the prosecution and legal departments exercise due diligence before initiating cases, in order to preserve the integrity of the judicial process and ensure timely justice for those with legitimate grievances.

MORE India ARTICLES

Amit Shah to inaugurate steel plant in Maoist-infested Gadchiroli on Dec 9

Amit Shah to inaugurate steel plant in Maoist-infested Gadchiroli on Dec 9
Reaching here late on Friday, Shah will fly down to Gadchiroli the next morning to inaugurate a direct reduced iron plan of Lloyds Metals & Energy Ltd, which will be the first big project coming up in the Maoist hinterland. He is also likely to perform the ground-breaking ceremony of other LMEL projects as part of the company’s Rs 20,000-crore integrated steel manufacturing unit in Kondseri on a 1000-acre complex.

Amit Shah to inaugurate steel plant in Maoist-infested Gadchiroli on Dec 9

India-Germany military cooperation meeting held in New Delhi

India-Germany military cooperation meeting held in New Delhi
The Ministry said that the meeting was co-chaired from the Indian side by Brigadier Vivek Narang, Deputy Assistant Chief of Integrated Staff IDC (A), HQ IDS, and Col (GS) Christian Schmidt, Director, Department International Cooperation Armed Forces Office from the German side. The meeting was conducted in a friendly, warm, and cordial atmosphere.  

India-Germany military cooperation meeting held in New Delhi

Raghav Chadha highlights 25 'unfulfilled promises' of BJP in RS

Raghav Chadha highlights 25 'unfulfilled promises' of BJP in RS
Drawing attention to the BJP's pledge to forge a "New India" by "Amrit Kaal 2022", Chadha underscored the imminent arrival of 2024 and urged the government to make strides in fulfilling its commitments. He highlighted 25 promises made by the BJP that remain unfulfilled till date.

Raghav Chadha highlights 25 'unfulfilled promises' of BJP in RS

After ruling for 22 years, Congress almost wiped out in Mizoram

After ruling for 22 years, Congress almost wiped out in Mizoram
The Congress, which governed Mizoram for more than 22 years in different terms since 1984 under the Chief Ministership of party stalwart Lal Thanhawla, performed disastrously in the state assembly elections, result of which was announced on Monday. The Congress fielded candidates in all 40 seats but its nominee C. Ngunlianchunga is the only winner in Lawngtlai West seat by a margin of 432 votes.

After ruling for 22 years, Congress almost wiped out in Mizoram

Telangana: 80 newly-elected MLAs have criminal cases against them

Telangana: 80 newly-elected MLAs have criminal cases against them
Fifty out of the 64 newly-elected MLAs of Congress have cases against them, which comes to 78 per cent of ruling party MLAs. The NGO said that 19 out of 39 MLAs of BRS (48 per cent) have cases against them. The percentage is highest at 87 per cent for the BJP as seven of its eight MLAs have criminal cases against them.

Telangana: 80 newly-elected MLAs have criminal cases against them

13 unidentified bodies recovered in Manipur border district, probe on

13 unidentified bodies recovered in Manipur border district, probe on
Sources said that the bodies were recovered after the security forces reached the forested village after a heavy gun fight between the rival group in an area dominated by the Kuki tribal community. The bodies are yet to be identified.  

13 unidentified bodies recovered in Manipur border district, probe on