Close X
Friday, November 15, 2024
ADVT 
India

Bihar liquor ban gave rise to unauthorised trade, means ‘big money’ for officials: Patna HC

Darpan News Desk IANS, 15 Nov, 2024 04:21 PM
  • Bihar liquor ban gave rise to unauthorised trade, means ‘big money’ for officials: Patna HC

Patna, Nov 15 (IANS) The Patna High Court has said the liquor prohibition in Bihar gave rise to unauthorised trade of liquor and other contraband items.

A bench of Justice Purnendu Singh said that the "draconian provisions" of the Bihar Prohibition and Excise Act, 2016, have "become handy for the police, who are in tandem with the smugglers" and innovative ideas have evolved to hoodwink law enforcing agencies and deliver the contraband.

The Justice Singh-led Bench said that while Article 47 of the Constitution mandates raising standards of living and improving public health at large, the 2016 law, enacted with the said objective, for several reasons, finds itself on the wrong side of history.

"Not only the police official, or the excise official, but also officers of the state Tax Department and the Transport Department love liquor ban, for them it means big money."

The Patna High Court said that the number of cases registered against the kingpins/syndicate operators is fewer in comparison to the magnitude of the cases registered against the poor who consume liquor. “

"The life of a majority of the poor section of the state who are facing the wrath of the Act are daily wagers who are only earning members of their family. The Investigating Officer deliberately does not substantiate the allegations made in the prosecution case by any legal document and such lacunae are left and the same allows the mafia scot free in want of evidence by not conducting search, seizure and investigation in accordance with the law," it added.

The above observations were made as the Patna High Court dealt with a plea filed by an Inspector challenging his demotion after "illicit foreign liquor" was recovered in a raid by the Excise Department conducted in a warehouse located 500 metres from the police station.

The petitioner contended that within the period of four months, he had registered 74 cases relating to excise matters, arrested 130 accused persons, recovered a total amount of 2,541.86 litres of illicit liquor, and effectively implemented prohibition within his jurisdiction.

In its judgment, the Patna High Court after perusal of the charge memo, said that it was framed on the direction of Bihar’s Director General of Police, who had directed the SSP Patna that in case of recovery of illicit liquor from any police station's territorial jurisdiction, the Station House Officer (SHO) concerned would be held guilty and strict action will be taken against him.

"In the present case, the DGP with a pre-determined mind, had observed that strict disciplinary action is required to be taken against the petitioner, which resulted in the passing of a penalty order against the petitioner by the disciplinary authority, who with pre-conceived minds, took a decision to impose penalty in compliance of the letter of the DGP," it added.

Quashing the suspension as well as the penalty order, the high court said that the authorities had pre-determined to impose a penalty on the petitioner and proceeded to hold a quasi-judicial inquiry giving the post-decisional opportunity of hearing which does not subserve the rule of natural justice and is contrary to the principle of fair play.

"The authority who embarks upon a post-decisional hearing will naturally proceed with a closed mind and there is hardly any chance of getting a proper consideration of the representation at such a post-decisional opportunity,” it said.

However, it clarified that in light of the recorded evidence, if the disciplinary authority finds that the petitioner should be subjected to disciplinary action, in that circumstance, the petitioner is required to be put under suspension to proceed afresh in light of the law laid down by the apex court.

 

MORE India ARTICLES

PM Modi’s visit to Solapur: Women applaud ‘Double-Engine’ government’s initiatives

PM Modi’s visit to Solapur: Women applaud ‘Double-Engine’ government’s initiatives
Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Tuesday addressed a public gathering in Solapur, Maharashtra as part of the election campaign. During his speech, the PM praised the work and performance of the Maharashtra government. Lauding the government’s role in the development of the state, he stated that the BJP-led government in Maharashtra, along with its alliance partners, is working with the motto of “Sabka Saath, Sabka Vikas”.

PM Modi’s visit to Solapur: Women applaud ‘Double-Engine’ government’s initiatives

Plane named ‘Rahul Baba’ bound to crash, MahaYuti will come back to power: HM Amit Shah

Plane named ‘Rahul Baba’ bound to crash, MahaYuti will come back to power: HM Amit Shah
Home Minister Amit Shah on Tuesday claimed that the MahaYuti government will come back to power in Maharashtra after the Assembly elections but taunted that the plane named ‘Rahul Baba’, which has already crashed 20 times, is bound to crash 21st time.

Plane named ‘Rahul Baba’ bound to crash, MahaYuti will come back to power: HM Amit Shah

AAP govt's approach is guided by clear intention to serve people: Punjab CM at bypoll rallies

AAP govt's approach is guided by clear intention to serve people: Punjab CM at bypoll rallies
Punjab Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann on Tuesday said that the AAP government's approach is guided by a clear intention to serve the people. He also focused on the achievements of his government in Punjab, highlighting developmental strides in education, healthcare, infrastructure, and public welfare.

AAP govt's approach is guided by clear intention to serve people: Punjab CM at bypoll rallies

Five drown in Bihar in separate incidents

Five drown in Bihar in separate incidents
On the first day of the Chhath festival in Bihar, five people drowned in separate incidents across Patna and Begusarai districts on Tuesday. In Patna’s Maner block, a tragic incident occurred when Neetu Devi, a 38-year-old woman, drowned in the Ganga River.

Five drown in Bihar in separate incidents

Indian Army lookout for robust drones: Lt Gen RC Tiwari

Indian Army lookout for robust drones: Lt Gen RC Tiwari
East Tech 2024 has been organised by the Army's Eastern Command in which nearly 140 companies engaged in defence-related production, including MSMEs and start-ups, are participating in the third edition of the event.

Indian Army lookout for robust drones: Lt Gen RC Tiwari

Maha polls: BJP to encash PM Modi’s charisma to turn anti-incumbency in its favour

Maha polls: BJP to encash PM Modi’s charisma to turn anti-incumbency in its favour
BJP, which is contesting 148 seats in the MahaYuti, proposes to ride on the Modi wave while approaching the voters. BJP also proposes to seek votes for pro-development MahaYuti opposing the anti-growth Maha Vikas Aghadi. The party also hopes to increase its vote share banking on the popularity of Amit Shah and Yogi Adityanath.

Maha polls: BJP to encash PM Modi’s charisma to turn anti-incumbency in its favour