Thursday, March 28, 2024
ADVT 
India

Ayodhya Case: SC Says Hindus Prayed To 'Central Dome' For Its Divinity

Darpan News Desk IANS, 18 Sep, 2019 06:51 PM

    The Supreme Court on Wednesday told the Muslim parties that Hindus may have attached divinity to the central dome at the disputed structure in Ayodhya, and that they prayed to it.


    The Hindu belief was that Lord Ram was born on the 'Chabutra' (platform) in the outer courtyard. On the contrary, Hindus parties claim that Lord Ram was born in the inner courtyard located within the central dome, and that it is located 40 feet from the outer courtyard.


    A Constitution bench comprising five judges and headed by Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi is conducting the daily hearing on the matter.


    Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, one of the judges on the bench, queried senior advocate Rajeev Dhavan, who represents Sunni Central Waqf Board and other Muslim parties, "Maybe Ram Chabutra was a creation of 1855 and that it coincides with the setting up of a railing (which prohibited the entry into the inner courtyard). Why was Ram Chabutra set up in the close proximity of the railing? Hindus believed some divinity in the central dome and this is the reason they were praying at the railing."


    Dhavan equated this observation from the judge as "conjecture". The judge replied that he is referring to a scenario in 1885, when in a suit it was decided that Muslims were praying inside in the Masjid and Hindus were praying outside at the 'Chabutra'.


    Dhavan replied that the whole area was walled. Justice S.A. Bobde re-inquired whether the whole area was walled. Dhavan insisted that "we cannot assume a situation existing before 1855. At this, Justice Ashok Bhushan, another judge on the bench, quipped that witnesses have said that Hindus were used to go inside (in the inner courtyard) to pray". Dhavan did not relent, instead in a strong tone replied that witnesses can say what they want.


    Justice Bobde supported Justice Bhushan stating that they (Hindus) prayed at the railing, "there is evidence in support of this claim". "There is oral evidence where they say Hindus prayed at the railing", observed the court.


    Justice Chandrachud queried Dhavan that reference to the 'Chabutra' came (for the first time) after the railing or barrier was set up, and then Hindus praying at this barrier emerged as the focal point of worship. The judges on the bench continued probing Dhavan on the same issue.


    "Three points require attention: prior to 1855, Hindus & Muslims went inside the central dome, in 1857 Hindus could not go inside due to the railing and in the later years, the question was why this railing came up", observed the court quizzing Dhavan. He reiterated in a strong tone that it is "conjecture", as Joseph Tiefenthaler in 1770 AD pointed out that Lord Ram was born at 'Bedi' or cradle at the outer courtyard.


    Justice Chandrachud retorted, "Why do people pray at the railing? You pray as you believe divinity is ahead and not at your back." Justice Bhushan insisted that Hindus went to the railing because they believed they are praying before the birthplace of Lord Ram. Dhavan said they could have gone to the railing to destroyed the place.


    The judges replied: "People were praying at the railing hoping that they are praying at the birthplace." Justice Bobde asked Dhavan to submit the list of evidences with reference to the railing to the court. Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi insisted that submission should take place as soon as possible.


    At the end of the hearing, senior advocate C.S. Vaidyanathan, who appeared for Ram Lalla Virajman, told the court that Tiefenthaler referred to Hindus praying inside the building, and that 'Chabutra' came later.


    According to the Muslim parties' submission, Tiefenthaler recorded that Aurangzeb demolished the fortress called 'Ramcote' and erected on the site a Mohammedan temple with a triple dome, and that according to others, it was erected by Babur. "Tiefenthaler also mentions a 'bedi' (craddle) and states that it was on this where 'Beshan' (Vishnu) was born in the form of Ram", mentions the submission.


    Muslim parties argued that Tiefenthaler has to be read with witnesses' version on behalf of the Nirmohi Akhara, a party contesting against the Muslims suit, stating that Ram Chabutara was also called 'Bedi'. Therefore, it establishes the Hindu belief that Lord Ram was born at the 'Chabutara'.


    The arguments will continue tomorrow.


    Fourteen appeals have been filed in the top court against the 2010 Allahabad High Court judgement which had partitioned the 2.77-acre land in Ayodhya equally among the three parties -- Ram Lalla, the Nirmohi Akhara and Sunni Waqf Board.

    MORE India ARTICLES

    Erstwhile McDonald's India Partner Vikram Bakshi Barred From Leaving The Country

    Erstwhile McDonald's India partner Vikram Bakshi has been barred by the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal from leaving the country.

    Erstwhile McDonald's India Partner Vikram Bakshi Barred From Leaving The Country

    Can Sonia Gandhi Revive Congress?

    Can Sonia Gandhi Revive Congress?
    It has been over a month since Sonia Gandhi took charge of the Congress once again but the party is still to recover from the severe setback it suffered in the Lok Sabha elections and there seems to be no clear plan in sight about its revival.

    Can Sonia Gandhi Revive Congress?

    Children Drop Out Of Schools As Child Lifting Rumours Fly In UP

    Children Drop Out Of Schools As Child Lifting Rumours Fly In UP
    Reports on WhatsApp about child lifting that are linked to organ trade, have created panic in Banda district of the state.

    Children Drop Out Of Schools As Child Lifting Rumours Fly In UP

    Neil Nitin Mukesh Shares Video Of Cats Fighting Venomous Cobra. People Say ‘It’s Scary’

    Neil Nitin Mukesh witnessed a shocking scene on the sets of his upcoming film, 'Bypass Road’. The actor shared a 42-second clip on Sunday, which shows a standoff between four cats and a snake.    

    Neil Nitin Mukesh Shares Video Of Cats Fighting Venomous Cobra. People Say ‘It’s Scary’

    Known For Contribution To Green Revolution, Punjab Agricultural University Ex-VC Khem Singh Gill Passes Away

    Former vice chancellor of Punjab Agricultural University—who was also known for his contributions to the Green Revolution—Dr Khem Singh Gill passed away on Tuesday morning. He was 89 years old.    

    Known For Contribution To Green Revolution, Punjab Agricultural University Ex-VC Khem Singh Gill Passes Away

    Jassi Sidhu 'Honour Killing': 19 Years On, Charges Framed Against Mother Malkit Kaur Sidhu , Uncle Surjit Singh Badesha

    Jassi Sidhu 'Honour Killing': 19 Years On, Charges Framed Against Mother Malkit Kaur Sidhu , Uncle Surjit Singh Badesha
    “The court of Additional District and Sessions Judge Smriti Dhir framed charges under sections 302 , 307 and 120-B against Malkiat Kaur and Badesha.    

    Jassi Sidhu 'Honour Killing': 19 Years On, Charges Framed Against Mother Malkit Kaur Sidhu , Uncle Surjit Singh Badesha

    PrevNext